A  W  O R L D  B A N K  P O  L I C Y  R E S E A R C H  R E P O   R T
.1 ...L *-||1,9 _ffi9 11_ I :s1... Ask
~, ,/ 1 , I S
21 776






I  ,,.  1 -  10~I 



-1 _oLI, / '1t�9j ~,I14Ij j,#1- @ ;1LJA JS- e: a1l ,  &dl 9 
,Uy__I         - IJi -  /      ZeT, su .   ,xT,     r Ly3
t..�s1J9149~~~~It",118
4 Ehmal
Engendering Development: Through Gender Equality in Rights,Resources, & Voice
Copyright C) 2001 by the International Bank for Reconstruction & Development /
The World Bank
) #LoJ   4A 1__   a ;  Ia
Vo r * A / Vo  rA
,,S1 i oc. / Z;fI1 1
The findings, interpretations, and conclusions expressed here in are those of the
author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Board of Executive Directors
of the World Bank or the government they represent.
The World Bank does not guarantee the accuracy of the data included in this work.
The boundaries, colors, denominations, and other information shown on any map in
this work do not imply any judgment on the part of the World Bank concerning the
legal status of any territory or the endorsement or acceptance of such boundaries.
IJi'l JJJ 91.8J-u-    t91g J'Sye :5          ;> 
This work was originally published by the World Bank in English as Engendering
Development: Through Gender Equality in Rights, Resources, & Voice. This
Arabic translation was arranged by the Arab Institute for Research & Publishing. The
Arab Institute for Research & Publishing is responsible for the accuracy of the trans-
lation. In case of any discrepancies, the original language will govern.
Arab Institute for Research & Publishing: ISBN 9953-36-137-1
World Bank: ISBN 0-19-521596-6



0                 ~~~~~~~~~~0@
11�l'161p~~~~~~~~~ Ei  l0 .3n L 
d- a \
*-       *~~~~~~0
11n''.L*I^
1Si 10-.|s~oni






JL L- -     JQZ  j  W'l jz-ja.)   )+-
A L-�j)~>  j  I j  ~~9W.~
wfiA IJI?  AIW JG 8t ;L., Wi J. !JI KJ  -
L JI  0-I-1 i r  &LJ-  y  i   A Ji  
j~~d IJJI      -r S 4D typ9
cY - 21 s ;If J , ~)W2~  ~ .A, jU  p 
JL)          jj ji I,v,YI ,L ,il:syl ,1  t5  Lc   -I 1
L-j 0-r 4i -+ti- a  a!-^L v?j i;;9
IL- 'tl   zA LiUNl  j   <3iL-J L.4   $!L   a--1!J a-JJ lzl
:5I 1-!   'LSl ZL)1;.  O!  w1o 9 oj 9
aaXI~~~~~~~~~~~~ 1. 2S0^ I> z- -�j  p  ? lL  u  9
5



'-1J 1 J L1F > 2-J-~ DT -j  2Q 91 OKk-'   &
*_A Ju-    UX,J 3 9 .L1 CAW J! r11 L1
*91 J->-, L1 S9L4+ -J -Y,   I &  LA1Ji LLI
Ial- Li                        t>; ii;:51 s :,J91 1b J tv tLu 
3  H  ;! ;1 aS:~~~--I! L4J  LeiGI AD9
ui ! J~~~J L3  Ij% FL-JI ,  olJ L E -dl,l
48G1. 5191 <5Lc _1 H L3 sliJ 4L.X t-tai



yJ ~~ .K, W A ^ 
L    J ,4iOA 1 sw E uwuJ  1W s; oLl Cs i
a-u; 4JI--j      'U>  L6LJ)  -12- 1 i   !, J   i   D
L4W              L� 
iJU I   5Ij         i i   I  ci  -  -
ijJl A
-  7 La.j I
! S1 e 1 ,! ~~~~~~L-J aIJ 4j  lJlzI  i ej vU
+  oJl Nl  lp J!JJ  ,S1 ,<JJI  H p<J  zJL  ji  L<JI 4 JI
;J,~~.;;J J    _15- il    LUP -



O. iyQ :9i J .Ai .. t+ UM oa1 Jl,1
J~~~~~,                    Li   :LL  sJI . ya 1
.(www.worldbank.org/gender/prr) :,j5l >'Y  U< s  l*Lc 9;U
jlPi ,l               L .u1- 1y ,
l4- i,J1 A1 A13 : W :J} -- 91 ') UIJ
,�yl ,? AWI 45 -  1  JI J-,I Li  ZZt.d Li  91919  l
y  -I      I  ;l-  JD - L  -  J I JAI J  4A
a ilii 5J >s L1 oS Xi 9 u91 J  Z- ji .
w  ;1,LW  ~~~~~~~~J  L4J ~ ~ ~ oi,lJ &J
8



6
y ~~ -         -. -[  1  1C  ,r 
<~~                  .Q} S  - +r:;j  rfw ,:>)1



Ja/K ,41 J!~ ,W  1~ 1 y. S ) 41 ?*> -v ,, Jfb
W s l W r1y zz,~ji o z JS
,    4Cy~L s j~ ' 4W J ,  Jy 4j,,yAA J9  $ Wj 4Li
4LJy eJ5 4!upLASJ iJ{~ 4g1)U 4.s 4UZN) 4 
j~~~i U`--j*4A       L~
10



j '. 1 '1 9>9 '3S  !  '> Jj  ' LZ
-G-5 9       L)        jr Jl  I
Wu,) jyA  S    9i99 y   9y WLJ1 ySZ l'
'  L4 3,W� 3�U J  J1 Js,14y  A";
j U         &jul 2,  Lz 4WI! G 
W1,,3,;IJ ,SI  u8I<  G  ols^Jl  JI WJ!W9 11l



L4.A Q.X1 SirLJ  J  - 3 sis CUl Ij (5 +;>K) "2000 ;,
J +            J I
12



I^ t     I 4



<u~~ .;yI ,-is 45>1y J_l  LxU la <oA  3sJI JIj>
_9J .oty ,KJ ,39 <1 -IIU JLLU JpX 4 yJ ,AJ X
A! .a4 LAJIJ 2LiJ -. ;Sl!~ s$xW2 j�> ;A uX j;l 
. 1  1p JJ J JI  Lir-z 'L5 6
~~  -~~~  L;  ;IL
J~~~~~~~~L
L-11~~1
eg - ab-o41i Z -~  j S i 3LAl -y oJ;l w)LI s -Py o
L) j  - 1?S;?foL. J j L)
eL-'  y  lJl L)J; <:>Ual  ;  ZIl y 
UJ I1 Z  .2 A I j_4:   8l,-)   l;  uXiJ i!.J  5  5
S w   AU a^ ilj aI :e  w>r jblj! Lol ,r L.L4P  Zr S
1 OJ>;J *'GI lJllCXt;4L  ;1;P! G;)J  4
L)~~~:2 L ojlll :.,L       Lj;  S  1 - J2J
.Ji p1 9 *a;LS 913 31 Jog4 1tV



;9>.tiJ ,3Ij.~Ij <19d~tI IO -   oL l  U--
jsz  4a.u JU, c   L             !L4 j-  9  b �  ---  s
4,qisl 1! X y1 o;>         L~,-l  F.L1 +L ,19
&j    JLA4 J� u  a9         4
LPL--  ykK, L         SL-  -;  W-tl S 19,
AiL- -  L1 15          Li
i,,191,~~     Z-,Z 9 5,  Lu1  yl L -,i JS> a;e  J  y
, &, M9~~~~15A -S  1l



JMJ  ��;       1       A ,1 J, .Q.J 4,+   oJ_l ag,  A-f
jaGe i       5LP         1          1          L y yj,g
ZL         i l
,     J di 4JAL &A-UL JiiL  61 1-Lui >-,i o  U   C
ozSJ ;s  <-!WR AJ  1JIJ!JI.S osS eplj  olJJJJ Ss a  l
j bL j S "1j1 wi Hi  o Al        gender 
'91 oWl JI s 5 H S> L-l;5. JJ J W ,-o ...  U i q 
1 6



"QI,,;5K 1 - 9a LM  Ij~ JUi 41F
\ j  S  20Sl J  15  .jz  I 1
.U1  O,1 J ul  Jj
1t7
.9420 L;1 15  _)I S  l,  LXs  l  1,1s   J
197 ;., 09 ,LJl J Lj  zLL l  ;o6J <!.>CIJ
JA~~~~~~~~~40 I, a,;1 l 14JrIs  F 
Js~~~L,~ 0.r      LSe JS ,l  >u
i299l a 29i 1 - 1 e J I  Lz  L-  io
J  ir-,1  1970   C-LI  JI .LSJ-  Ga-L-J jJI  Li -I
stf ->t~~~~~~178  .1i ll 59.L1



:0    r:~                  _                              j)l)
j  o.5t          7       *                                            0vA) 4
.  z~  �.n    n                               ;k S     t44
*n H >-n ,aL S; Ai <  S )               4ad      j    n~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~r~
tt~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~J                            -  '4) .'~_.



zyl~~~~)  jL C-I         L, LFo I  Jj 
is,1 xtj 5  L-J  -X--l a  i-! ,, 91, 5S91L iH,Nl, ii
,     ~~~~L.J;i LA  ];J  Lod I X 
Ly isu ,9 ,F~                      Jr U l  boL  S  >1j  1C
C5 -                     - 4-1  - 
Ae~i U .LA F   ajj  .JLi sF  LoU olL �S<Wj.-
,#i SjU                   2._51oi 
.+ ~~,aI J9 A ,j~ -  , J   JI , >F 42 -U9F
j _Jl5 LJI p;-s 4    J   j   YAJU
73 s!.<1W 4                    _ly WS  j 42  Ji 
u aAlL 73 <SJ >9s  L: ;UuG 77 -1jl i,>F,FL 
~~ ~~y4~~I ~~ ;I~~~L~~U  ~- A  L~ I �  .J au  ~ 
19



UU 10 e JiP -k Y1 8  JX 1    A b 
.01i,   . 19-18 31  ;) i  LT j   d-l )LU
ji .S  i .~4,jii ~uii a. 6iu 8 y     3LL  LJ l
j-3 zd-s      7  j  1625 1 b; 7 
4_1,~~~~~~~~~~~~~ -     -vjiI,  iU  28  J !OljL_llU
^&c s1Y itiJ 41 ,3LSJ2vOJ!eLJ SS 1S
~~ j~~~  ~ ~   -~~~   u       c, i;Li�
J,,A   L,-IJ rY-Ji j  L o ,L(JI)
~~~~~~~.:15  <n  alNl ~j I J  lilo  N J oJ~
,  lel  .:Jl )i, tJJ <.) JJJ  oli, JyI ,3   fA1 Y1  gJ
8 SIJJI <,!.(3   22l)JoJI jJI sI 2l 
-I~~ W                     S1 vA Wziv1< -u ii 
Jy :.!a-yl~ };  J i  ,   U ! I
J.)i      ,L-i 5 !  ;lf5 + -t l  3!  _J1! l t2
20



6l;'Yl *sili 6-j ;'YgLQI       pIa :2 ;1
3.0  .
2.5  -- _
2.0 -   -  -
1.0
0.5        ------
0.0
0.0  0.5  1.0  1.5  2.0  2.5  3.0
if ):1 ipJlLL 114-6  aJY J,lL k, -:
*  t1t  j JS 91  40 9-9  t ' > 
;  Jy-U  I ,U  ,
(I 999)  A  : i 41
* 1;    ;t 1         .*A: I 11 jW1 P a
-     L    LI  I  ,  3 (>142,  ,,-! .a5A1 L- ^  JL;U DL LsJb
.-;j a  l  &> f
21



,+-i1              J,aJl 29jl       >    ,> J,i   sil  ' J)-o
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.0
1970 1980 1990 ' 1995 1970 '1980 1990 ':1995 1970  1980 1990 ' 1995
J.01 i l             G�l y   , Il
S~~~~~~~z a.         1-d j6Ailw_c rcu  i , tl  Iv ,A ?MibYl iN
.-J )I   A L yUi                    . Jil 
.1975 r'l  .l      -i
.1985 r''' . d  :diUL -
.1997 tWl o -+si  ii-
*(1999) 1JA)U1l L)J$d A U oiit(l998) WISTAT  ri  iiJI
Li         -       A           Ki;  0 1                .;y- Oi
KrU J�L 5 UQAL L2
22



j*O  100y60 a4  j LA jJ  i   LA
tsi  y  j. Ujj..xiU  ,$L   -   j1   .1  L
Zi a1jA1 -!     .,S W OUt  L i j SI  JL
4    (5 J5L  ) ji u -  F
-~~~~~~ :-L -l jL a<,- . JXlL) JSL- I  Jb )
L--j ~.s>I Ij   zS!4)1 OLu
4-l    L >    o    Jsj WIl ,> 4L 3� S
;u1 L >3 3S1 J - , <6- .> D L) i ,--rI -1 0s sY
J,1k .      :(5J< s>1y             ly
,i~~4L l J8 Il, ,9L , Ji.l t'L- 5 
23



C-             L V   C  '  v   U  It  t
4_ C '
a~ ~ ~ ~ r   W_-             F
';  Gt >f _ K_.  ~--, _
V~~~~- , .>. t<tKT .cC  A
i~~ ~~~~           'C _t -_ 



&"i M1@1 t 1Ai @. j   s1                  + ti ,-ID  ,   :5 
35
20
*     *      . 
20*         * * 
0          10         20         30
j3 15j 4& l<Jlj >JI. ai L5 _t- 20  sIJ  L ,iW 32) aJ72 tIW  ii
w)U4+ 1uj.a Z-XJI  41 (o! cL aJ-,L   ~Jj  sly j,.lJ,1 j 4  !  stT
(1998) ),i:J  11
W1I a l; 41;IiLY   1 4lJ SX     I 941.1  J
2 5                   J -
25



*S LJ j1 J-,,U ~Pj), o1e2 J-L,9,)4 L-Y X 3 - ;IF 3 
.JU-i ~~~UJ
o     *J' . ..a, LJ ti ?>  jti ,Wi otY rL. 3L�z �Li
iJ -LT E      K W JJWJJJ siui J  i<S\JJ 
0a UAL M;iLI, 41960 C  j L)T   CAS  l,WI zAs
j4 1992-1960  a i;jIi J-Ai 2_T  'bj 5  Jul.1i
0,)~Lej -          S L 0. 9 Lj 0.5 )-Uc v L ,; 
.(6~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
;JAR; P-UD  ;RS SIJ$X L4-- L) )J1 Lj   H 
3                                    i
2 
1                -      1
,;JI~ -Jv xT if,, t1960 is L1 W1
.1992 LM 1960,>.
26



__ Jv  j     'd1  uIj $1 ijh5 :7 J,I
10
6~~~~~~~
4~~~~~~~~
2~~~~~~~~
8 *           44 -4
4
2~~~ * 4               4
2                     *** +
4.0  4.5  5.0  5.5  6.0  6.5  7.0
tf  :iL  rj-z) (ICRG) " ,dl JILUl 6U  :.UL "L.J
I     4lj o110"!I,         , 2 x (1- ICRG  IO-0 ,
45U (WESHR) J4"    7  j_,i  i,l ol z"  WI U  oije j
j"l A;Li .W  s-L  u-y 3 l> l   C--J U e -),!J ,,i11 ,S,   Y1j !63 . J , i 
L) ~~S--)ala zi Jj d I
L)~~~~~ (z 1)  9                LOw!   ,s  ,
JaJ C_ 10
-rl ]Jl j1j-   < ! ;ii. .Ji L g 2 2Wi7
.(7 JlI);LyIos!;+!XJ1;J,LI Jol ,P--
27



j  J iL, Wy o4   Li oFA 1 W -   82   UA,L  L
~ c. -~ .~  ~ ~L- o>-      c g ! sLJI +
)S J;U~- Lbgnx Ji W 91 <;JC 41 ei >J    350 <
~,pll,_JlL72-   Zt .I 2JI L DIC   _G5
j    L      _U  9 < u1  I.,Jyy 
-  y l   1  -  >   *-  1   -I  1   X   C  I~~~~~~~~~~~~~Jl   I
- MLJ ?l2,9  j? ,< 01   1 C  JL  9l .
-Ij~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
28t5 J     , C; JI �AI  L)
<1                   4e%11 4>>! >3 <_n~~~~~~j  Aa- )1p9 5h z.1P~ _
jl    _l61 - 1         tJl
- 191 u+1 1 21 yl alsye yl D 1 -
-ill Fp  *4sJ%  l,Y!  \  y  , 4Jliy  O 9289 o



Jj    -J    FW-a
JKA' ~ )~~i 9P J sLiyJ )9 A               -U 'L >  -LLF JI
,y,'yl  L"Lj e  yl,9--Ul  j  ! .     ,  l    9
~L.4l ,1y i.pl�A Q,� j4Jl JF U9e~ ~JF S  - U 
L"L~.>FGPJ                      L v - cJ' lI i -
L+5   ,  _  z          J19 1,$ ,y\l Ji 
WE ol~~~~~~~~~~~~~~JLU              "b4iLc S A XJI! -Y 1
J;J j  jIX k1X 1J zl,5 l, IJ yL,
az0-).) L) .AS  .flQlo-il  aIw
D A1 O1,1,2 @ JgE~~~~I -  '-S 1   ,;Ij2 1  .S1  L'1 ;>  LUS P-) E
91 91         91 .1 ry -G91lJ29
29



J,,, ,_t3  S t�If LaA I it  ,)   � }   �
s4wUJI! J iEU iiLJQ 4jJ191,i VAI  $JI ~L4olPa )L; -1
30~~~~~~~~~~04
+1 Ds Ji ,,$1  ~-LJI ju-) Zti fj S ,1 Uf
-_,3 -iL)  s        A            iu1,
Oy                 i  OWL G oW Y ii W3 OWL ~~~J-, ? 1 , ;?saY
-YJ ? gP n5X1:iYt BJI ! 43-OL.J s-1j1 iloPi 
<+J<1JU olll Y 4 -";La oo. . ;95  Q"41 7zj1
WS! isi; ti 4J1iyl 1! WS, 811 ,Ei;JI OLL ,# H olLll obJ, I 
4; U  OHJ!G,J;I! J+1  ,1  > oALeloJl S  LN
o;! oill L1ii Z'JIoll.l X  N  L;C130l_



, 1J-  1~ jil          j_OP j1 i 41 aI 
,]; uLd 2.1J       YJyl Gy!ee1u+  e  l 
t 1d Il  Z,,2kJ I   a G L  <J)!;1,r
ifuX1!~~~~~~~J LJ1  jl J<1 Hi-Il  '  1 1
~,j JI  I  9H, .: )MI L3 J; I! ;L ij 
oJua jF j, <l1     0aW,SiJ        lA
411  ,3  W;yA1   -I  LX.CC  1  ,;JSJl  O_S UAS  J+1  GOIP
y L -cUlJu -   j 'i  u  1J O 
jj 21Jj,l a, >S ILj j .zcz- j ,), -a1 :l JL
,l~~~~~~~~~iJ_ L4, , -4. 1i,>y -, J I
i5 8i J @2~~~~~1 li e i  - ,-zl



wotlj ll R ASi al " 3- Aip1 :8 JS.;tl
1995 �AjU S L  jL-j                  1995 ;JuJ J
1.00                            0.8
0.95                            086
0.90                           0;4
0.85                            0.2
0.80                            00-.!
fijJI J   u#1 J      Oo1 J         u#~~~~~~~~~~~~j,-41 L)
*  ~ ~   ~3A~ >i  ~   ~>. L~AL ~3L~J~UJ 4ij-~
,(                           ;L, jU911 &,a1 2 ,  ,     J 1 ,-U #- 2J 
J;Ji .  ;1 =l 1! ;l 1- ,;2 Jl ,LU1 ,5Ab a ~Jt .2 J ,yj-  *ifui
olJ ,#>fi Ji2.67 OJI yj cjjil j3  ; ojL  jii ji 2.33 �zI Y !
i (1998) WISTAT ,, zjd? .:uL i(1992) w,  `,jji1 ,!ojlLl lL 
.( 1999)    L21 >.
;AuSk    4jL.,xij ias -.HYj      1!4;1 Jij L)      ];J
cL-i  -yL"j  4 j    jj,?   c;   t;l --J   JA _X3
32



j .LJ II   i            I j      LI OCA1
L! >       *) 1  ls eyl   1    Al 94< F9 J &1r ia1
, ;,~Jl1 ,,~W o>~l ~f~~Lxll 9'4! jI<N -BI,Q_l LJ
L ~J  =u   9    I@  H 51-
cAL. JU .LJI >1  JI 91  L 1jK > Jl JUIn ~4+
U 9 f 1 -  ,< . l J~ oJl3 J:  O1 .Ll9 A . yLJl
~L~Jl -LJ fJ       1 -L3~ LU L3191 JLI -> !  <) i X 
� L F,)  z  J ! j L,  I, x33
z , L! ;L5,<?<; Ij1!.L
4 o9L joxj jJlo Is L?l  -;j L1i  a-.l -
33



.Su1t1 LI  ;v1,WI                  j .fJ  -  - 
- li A tKL~ Js Jy.Oii 2 )L L
a~~  ~   ~~~ JJ~) ! J 9SWsS  LW 
-,~I  1)  jts - (,)5  l.4,>,2     -,,ts 1Kj l
S Xl- , JIJI
-01~~~~,.<;        5JL1  JtPil J:riJJ L-   JL~l -S
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
,!J- 411 U-                                U (  1  1,  J;r4,9 
LUl jbUl E3El .FJJLI  o6JlD j   ;IjL   rc < i ji  31 o)L,
$;~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ;l djJ yl JM1 j - I2 J 2l
-ow      J.A   4e1 ,26 W-J21 i 1 2 
3 4



J4 iJ i:.W l J & i ;;Ju es-  J A yI  ~�i
jy- ~   "-
JAul~LAX a s s+JI@;�; 1  :9 Js,J I
1995 K,s3
1.50
1.25
1.00                AA
0.75
0.50           +
0.25
5.5   6.5    7.5   8.5   9.5   10.5
35,;            L) Zyl 
35



gU  ix-'I  v  S   4 ,y l  Al        gX  .(1O
JtU        JY l -L.U            L. LL -I
P5wl j; i.,,d o<1 ,,- Joljl ! .5 16;MI -^y jo wl: zI ojs
800
600
400
20W
8    300                30
A , LLc-  U   400  ~~y~~          .�:'Y
36



a-     !   -     _, :LJ L J jj  j  cI
oE~,l L)J2Ij 4j aw JLi;1 tj Jl3  9    11n;l
1O 4 :11 JL
1.05
-Y 0.99
1.0    0.96                1.0
-~~~~~~~~~ ~~~0.19
1.0s~~~~~~~~~0.100
. '  .  ^ $  . is       o.19~~~~~~I.   .  0
0.0           -  -         0.0
J1   _                      k 1 _
4,jii .. l ;,jL-;4 ,SfI J 2.67  j,:Yx A1 j z. !  jil Jji 2.33 J
OL;u1 M! (1998) WISTAT  zjuG,. ilL (1992) S, , 51OL:S
37



9Lj  -            ]-v- L1 i  v  AJ 4 L  I 
L5L -i  J -7.6   U, J  !4y    D 1-X
2n       ~~~~~~~~~~~L Jl -j-   O- ,   :-i)   L5  .3 t1l< 1~
jyi.a SWI X2L - JI 4L_\ J#Ia4J i(+ 9 ~ 4 . X  -3
s. ;J.> I -;l 5H p1 ypl9 3 efJy l ;l ~3 J 
D )y isLp - l;lJ ,c i J S . '-N  1 j-i GL1  j
38



e~~~4j 'j-u a1<r,Jl@i@1, U49 
,L~1   - I     &i� _,1 -K9  Aj  Y   .   yW-i
ji ji J-Z: a J<  C,UA L$il JJl      �J I L. oX 1
j-A -  j�~ #-' ~}        J       i >  U
'yJ ^ -J t) ASJ WU l l        5     - ,,-l
i-  -  - ,l t              iLl  Pr 
L            0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
iL  2I  4'9   JLII  ;tII9j1j
39



k             a  j  jF  9  9  ,F bUl a sl~~~~~~~~~~~~~L-j 
-G             jF n 1;1 + 9
~~ L,~~I J-~~~y CJ
*~~~~~J )J I 9  +9zzK J I J2
2J +A~LJ  J,>U Sa  Li, Ul Wl ,  11 J JW 
,Ls JlJ JL~JI cY�I L5              L) Y  P
~L  ~  LW J~5l ~p AJL-L L ! U
L -,  LdL j,5 jjl J+\t j;51      4    ,j
LY,I -)   W   -Cg5tJ    J J!J _),3- _-yl J9i
L)                            L)3 JI -  &4  U
slAJ6<, J&d         L.J l  ULF !;S  .~- :;zl gl�oFI
40



.V;l  Clyc ;,M  1, -  @, (4E oj-  wk J M 
91 j  9lhS  l  si>  L 
it K   L '-  -  j -1
Lj j i           iJ j   : 1 2 J 2
~~~~~~iu ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L
21  -91  souL 4;1  1  w>J1 3 ans  J
a~~~~~2-8 i  j2ylj J-,ci ti  :,W gL6A+I ?  j<
0~~~~~~~~~~j1
41



4A~) ~LJl ~J ~2I� U L ~J- , 1 4> 2
J� y.~l 4tW LW JU-l Jj L. J _s> JW ,9 ? i
,+) i wL,,L. <3 . ou s J1gtL  4+s
L4I-H  Li  ji .<A--!SJ Ll 3, <S ++ 
JUA        L)  j(f . ) , -
L-j I   LiUJ I  2W 
L--Jl J9J., ivg J 1 y )yaI
,> \_JI 2t,=ula 919L~li ,i~ LGOSA1 JI L2l
4>91~~~~~ J 1J u11 al s-  Jy 1 1 L1  r1aL~
I yl - s - 1 S DjW~~~~ -L 1 1 
.J;~~~~~~ ,Il Us;;I  - I;?4  j  4
olJllz .~.~. 91 S  j11 a1J)1  _J  D   il;  0
w:vH1$ islJl g iolJll42JjIzz4E 1> 



.0 ~ ~ ~ U  (>  K;Wt  4 i >t
C.5:tts     'd- &X 
t  \,  L   t i   E   .,  -:   .  E   X  Vt  6 (
-~ ~ -        I
'2~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~l
L  ~~~~~~~~~~~~c 



4.3bLLP   1  e J&<I 4i dLA  .
*.4j2  ~ok ')  oU   ? U  L1 o11S L  1y
,$1 sa Jlj S S  1591 L-.Loi LLr,y  .:, LI LA11o,
-k4- ULs   2         rJI4 A  I  F 
1  -I 1  H- Jki -  Wil -Lr , 
Lii A! i .  - d -, 91 owk,   .W 
-1]y FJI I, Ls CK- ,
,AI) tl! Jz O  cy>l      ,, L1
44



I 5)
U-i ~  . JJI J~,  W~ j
Llbfl JJ> U1n o>A  nll >fAL -P JA-)lJce_
+�3L          j  j. 0
_jL           L) eoJJ j JWI  5 o  L  /
L-I1   LL t -TI UeL- Ii ,J-
wJi
uP  A! CLll  }T  J�S j51iAi,-,lJ1o A1 ,S ,G  il
cI~~  ~       ~            ;-i i
45~~~~      L
ZL,,ljll1S ,3- 4JI  t   ~ l;oC 31 lJ ,I
4  J  !.s1 1   9  a5  J  .!A  Lj I
9~~~~~~~~~L1  1 )L1Sc ,JI  U,-l ia!o-#Ljl j!  UiLl
,> D!-J? X Z'L1J -w J4>J  oW 3J!(Jl, 
~~~~~~~~.4c> ; 111!<ai f1,,;-s
-,fslse jfXu1sz    19ar,S,45



oyl2A J-  o1 <            1 1j 8  I J i .j 1  u<      . j  -1
. (1992, Humana)                  > ,  A  /1 .i 
J' (4 ! I          _5-) vi-      s -o J'J' z
2     I I  9j                        j 7  4  3)2)A  I
J1lU  ,  1 ;2  ,;;i, .OJiA- o1   J- s-lil >, ->, 1-1 u1   #.ii
,21<rGlyl^J2 uJLL' ,k; .11~ 69 u8! e7 ;4! e  '2~  JKSL;Y ,j i)
.1 1 '9! 48) 3 JL<9  l -
46



sA
.5   *  I
*l%s
$5s
Id
j
.2
*s t



j JI :u  JL-Li 4-is, J,- L i -_   8 L 1i 9,  j4 J  ,W
*   -w SSaJ i U� +1s&2 u
~~ o~~,~l JAZ *4-1~ J; ;9iJ I'
j-'-\ >Lij t-,  - ,.JI  -  td r  deah-
-I LJ U,; , 1   LU;  J:, 4j W-j  U' Lj,
9$!J9! G(1975  ) Ls JIPJvF48
.~~~~L IiZl LJ jJUs Lk  b  li S(1995) ,:fi c(1985)
;IoJlLil   4p2!-ii Ja    -uE 411J+1J
,XJI S ousyl _r~-.U    IJ  &! JI  JX, jt  -,P
X J2l  -XJ} L  i L ,! vL;1L 9SY~~It L I  L) jeYiSv L)
ts~~~~~~~~~j- ij ZL-J        L)> It    L+J-  IJ 
L. JI                     Wu WS1 'L %G  l6Ji l4
a;1Sjb I J: J I_U   -A   J)JI j3 JL-)l  Z   LJI  jA  o 
X- iI                               A <!isl+,~liiJi,1t ,-J llGowry death
'4')       }  11O   ,  ?e  ,i-ji iJalb J1C  J
48



AX      Li    u  <1 '+1 b �-! i-'9 WI'
j,-,~~w. j-,j~ aaA,
'1991 JI� 1992 61989 ) o  e  100-60 _  l,  WI
4"')IJ -w eJ      1s      j>     (1994- 
-  yl 4;tylob W_,- 9   ij-yl  y   j 1
$Jj .1993 �- 1.14 .Lj 1980 - c- 1.07  l .  AY
. 1 4,Yj  > 1.18                 Jupl JiNl.1uiIii<
G  1,1    U  .JLL,s 9UF  SW . Ln W 2s -i }> - .J   b-, , J
Uol z, jl� ;,<     >  ,;F  j'z. aJ t u 
S1 sIz LJLIs SS1  1<a L L,# J-l
Ja ;   L)                        U J,,  l 
..;1 <_z oF oJI - ,X<l !-~ Y.r  ,'IiL9i!  iU
* c4UJ ~  4  ~iU ~Ly J~ JI -
a 10 ? Ji >zU J  S
49



; te <  t <- 5a !     L-          C! V    W 
5* Vb- S~  t     k X 'C't -st C  W  bx tA 9,. c
tGt  (  e >'>  n tl i.t gi >g &      U 
, , ,r L <GS �- ' � 'r Ct:f1, t t �.'> tis. zo.ci. 0r



g LylJ <     jjl2 - oL.1I CJ JWai J ~> *5t i21 jfi-
-I A- lllp �&,llil,IJI LX igGus ,J l  J
a-Aul JJ JJs  
-LJ tz2  Uy  J    :- JJ-I it_L1 -**X 2,Jl Li1  oJLll )I
J <54sJI JrLc oJWi  ._T j+ J �L~ 4L  LJJ8 i uJr4  I l
~~~~~~~~~~.J J.JJ  4  ILi   J,oU~2iW
L)1    -aJ    oI JI (EDR 1     J-I i1; Li
j  L   4 :c 9! .I zL SI ,ljl s    . -  l JII
P-,       KAl  v     YI U (GENDER) 4WJ -
-;! Uie)42YJ; l  r rjJ JL-)l  e)L LJ
JL~                      ,\     JL-)  - u  4,14W1> l  SL- 9-lg 
Pj1 j-1 <' J Lslj~  sL , eA1 sl 5i J5
51



j~  9,    ees1 ;1 Sy S! ,$ ?,        - U�~
j-J       JI  f    ji > , , , Nj 
LJyl                     - a -  5
ai;Up- ylJ 4.jI - J 9 p C- - J.      pl-
Z. 9y,jI 4
j  1  ;l.  .21  -J:  I l  -js_-  __1,-  Li U$ 4+  IJL,
91*9jk1~4I J y L2j,  -   - j
~IL,~A jzA,;I J>c 'ii1 .2 41 91J A)  -)
5 2



s.uV (tJiUzs (ej)u1 I,0U-i L4K, ~J&9 ;XW Js 
(2) w  )  U
,3L    o    l    uy   L5i9 jl  ZlJlll,Jil 't-  I 1 i
9j -xi ]3JI   . oJ   -j ; j ..J z
s1,;9 A! .dS1 Hs J AJi 44.1 ;1 C9 1U  9
ci ~ JL~~ .L.J J.4j
5L 3       J         L 
> -i1poJ                      l< --6   L:J o. jl1ui
> olJJ 4sJJ'-iA  SJj LZ-  _dS  rvl, jlz_J   jS= 
i-du ! ji,,J,  L)  Ol ,,>  Lt-U J L   ., + JIj , j _ 4
91  J  -I 11  C  ,,L-!  ~~kt.AF! l 4L,b I j,fl_ ,,? oJlUJl
-iSl~~~~~~-U j6 Ss 5s 9JI U1  1    -0 IL_r It
53    !o1L1sJO



.e n    k  c~.   i i tY C; 
V o  C   C.X   t W' s      S Uh
Xt      F tt  U X  t i; ~~~~~~~~~.cPLt
Y ~ ~ ~ ~  ~  c   ['. 's  z  t>t  i  SC- *
t  L9 G  S   tV,9  Z < G   K 0t ^;t 
Ac.c4�..   l:7t t kY.  vW  0te ;
k rA C ~~-i  8;  t    < * i. tt k_, 
,^ C .- ZE<'   W  f    W F  r,, 



LJI,.iy~J _e v JI ~A'l .(1996 U41 L )  L4 21 1  l
<y J; -$ 6,r,GN:l+, 42e , (1997  , 9j 
1- i sll S 4     z9yI sJLU ~.L iu 9 
.(1995
iL;llo;LIs EllJ! oLg(1992  61986) ie :
Wi 4~ 34 (_-L# }o. iYI1) I a  UI i -
s ys yl -91 1 -+ ~~~~(3) (    + u X 1 s l
(4)J11 jeS ls LIJC-~ lj)
@ <S- ?JI8L^J I ,!j <,J s,y JI L, & - JJ -uL;L
I;JL c.(5)1- l9 198 oJji UYJ ~,z< JeF ,  J,l <UI LJuEoi
L)~~~()
55-G 3 1I  LT 2-Jj IJJJi Ls
I;~~-~    u,  eJI- Lljt  +J iyJ1 -Jlj  E9 T
-6U;bli 3j (i 'JJ >I_4 - Jl)         LS oJ) 51 <e
L JJ 6LLll Li     -7- l   s  ( -  ;F1 jj41  1 
c > Lp.JU Iijb  LZ-L, ,    L  =Fi  l  iy
alji--l ,il l*4 1990i 1985  ay -ail  J-  J  <Ij <ilS   P:  1
(6) LiL>-
5 5



AT iez, 'A! Lwyi J~ s U=.�Jl Ul j 
~~  U   - ~~~~%~~~'� ~~~: L- J--
WK>r4l,�1J ,1l ?  j iD L1  O s     As1
43 !L u zD~ji  !4e!4      L-J 41 i  Li
.1990 - 1985  J, ;il J '#- S  j o lJLll   1c
j-  1 j ,  J�lA *LA: 1 1 Edgl
^  JL I ^ 3;iY - u N  ii J tcdUL (1992 - 1986 UL-jA) L1,z JVY  -
J).r4    W J  &LJ)l J  A  J
0XS - JaJX <,1986 CWM J, cjLI J iyL , AHJ 
.- 3    j4iJ 3       _J-u      " 
.<y@X olt Y rJJ 1991 4 
(rJ -i J5  40LA         L :)l \j,3J yf~iIi  AJ+ 
.ij>,, S 'U3 ol j3 ,,y ,ze18ol  a,
J  -,Jd29  A  \ >1Ou \
j,          J 9  -, -t 5L J, 3  Lc     D ?>  S X
L uy - 3 1   *J Y-'
;:3 j 56ll        -J  JJ-i
.(21 J^JI vU  = liIJ4  ;IJll: 
.(22 J8yJ)   LJ .:iY$!4c L.;A-,Y ;xL. -D
.(37 Jly$  154JJ  j  !,8<soJL 
56



Ji.it LM - 5x:1_l 
1990-1985 4jif      IJJ
4
3
2
1
*  1985                    1990
1990,1985 ZA,--:iYj Zf-::-Yl ,ji,~-
4
3
2
*  1985                El 1990
57



1990-1985 &<5Wtj r jX ;3J e
4
3
* 1985          1990
*.iJ,  Jfrii oW ;,l   I ejll cvl  S L.A o zl y o j  1-1 3! J  )i  :1 ri;,zi- 
oa1i   z5 3 J.~U~s! C          a4 -1  z 41 LL1 1o J s1 s
3.        jQz- ,5' 4 A  y5l 8  llz  j -
a5s~~~~~~~~    J_pJ2  skS s,9J .:A  L5  Di   !
.  -Y jl Zuyc -P l  O LJYD  j-,1 \o  c 1 i-ol
L5.L. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 5



o zJi J .l L    1     ~a j   4
Lj_i           L.1 LJ1 ;z,  J i A tA j
4   Lj~l urj-j L;J              z 3sl- oJ l<  QUpi ju_  .
444;       4.J A3 j-  i2l J <l j  Luj- I.:�LJI Ii  i
slJ il-j ~LJ< .19 iL 198 ,?0 o:l SGs  JLjyl <S
5    1 5 ,,....  ,L   -(2000  L3
Jj J   -)AP L I(CEDAW) %LJsl -3  9W,   JK9ll  L0-I j a.;x " j! Z
je  JJK . J   .dj -  l JI jj  LJ-I Ui  -1985  i L.  u   10I
4'  i,u..U p   .4W1   L) j- olp iy 1 
59;ll     LiJI  j-i t.Jl j  16.LJUJI
L)1 JI  L)                    L)l cD w  LI1   IJL  <5  WIIJ  J9
i5<                     4198 fW L= rz 3f4  llJ<  jJ .7)i 16
59,A11jS e



L  �;, -W _      J - olJI ?  -4 1 J~ F L3yJ  l
Q) 4)L--j I~~~~~~13L 
e�,jA (,Ld Jidi -  y LL"  JU- J  -     yL 
;Su1, ,\ Jul i,! ;asl2til t,! .w, l ,, :2 1 Ai:l H
120                    1.1
100
8009
20~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.
1970  1980  1990  1995  1970  1980  1990  1995
60



120                              1.2
80                              0
0.8
40
0.6.....                    .
0        .0.4
1970    1980    1990    1995    1970    1980    1990    1995
Ss! >1 >; ~~~~~~........... T_
11 X,, 6,,,i ~~~~~~.........,.. l < y
10                              1.0
0.8
6
4                                                     ..........
�  |                           0.2  __
1970        1980        1990    1970        1980         1990
-I!  tT  Wl,                ............j.,
-                 LSJA                  bU1 lf i *----------' L..............l.
t~~~~~~~~~~~..... .jLE, i                    ZSLyl2,J
ee:1  U1g!t+    JJWy, oU  iWS   A 1 9a1 A1 :>
.(X 1999) iJA11 911 ,,s(1994)
61



L4JI'  > UJ Jlj Lx ~(2-1 J�.ZJi)  j j 4  > L  Jlj '- Jfi
L)  L)  -LKJl U
;S JL.{  -                    tt ij1{   Ju') .31
t4 z>-i;l <>LW1218- I  1980 1970 a, Lo:I JL&,) LL S3J yl
.   U   , iU, U Z ZAI)L l . :-U lUj .Zi4  54 & 
E lJXJ  jL-JUl DE&  ;S  .s5 l 4.U1 Jj-dI  ;J '-II -.d Ly
.1990 �  2.2 4_JIo_l_> 1955 �Lc ailU 14 ;^Y~S
JIjs_ G1970 �W8 ibLd 4_Ij I!rIbJ~JUl  JD_L
D>ZL > L�NI., .LWI Ds yi s. C4- 9      ;L-I~ui OUJI
j=X  i., -dul ltdu L-  2J  JJiJ +   jL ve  lLI 
.Ll)d   ~462  90  - U
62



311975 o i J s1  ; J y 
j1 ,3 - > 1_.n)l iSl2.W j  Jl ! ~zLSl ~-<,- CA YlJ\ .1995
-2 K     J O1   S    1 J5. &L Y LI 1 < 3 
>     U:.Nlj At.~   L%WU 4_1J\JI) a  4pJ� L...J5  J I
,Xi -s           c z i ii L -i i  )JWi
.(1998 =; Si
1 990 J) 1980 <>. oW' NS ,       ci 1  -;IJI
Oby 'Yk1 J�  A  2  Qr"-"1 u-<Y- Y&  WI 4 iAJ
J . W j, -  JI ;L-  L, o >  - si~ cI .Su jLi  -
.1 990 1970 e :,LlU JS J J j  J
Uj .l yl J�,;~J�~Lw JL.    AK   cJ_  _1970 CU3I
'v1l <  9i, L1 < J s tzX1-J L, L,41 J 
L-J1 JLZ-; l s  JSL;, 1  Io  LZy JI JL -I)
U!,;;t -JI . p11   %.. ,5k :j  J5 J,  ,3i
63



rk:JI~ U9�}  .LS      J    -)L   W1  L
L  '  D    a  -e (P tJlWI    L) J 1
J~-)1-5    4  3�l LjAL  Au L-.-  jJ ~i j~li
C941  ,3   :l)  ,  .  L J- 4 JLj  OW ok
.yi)       J 91S7  5L -. -  j   U Js. . l esi I I J
o J                     a)u1 -i -2�  'j C/
15 <RJ   lJ;l7I-11970 CSI! WJIr      ;j W
Q,-t3 CeAl >1 W)s.1Ui a  i yJii Lk1 ,J  ,
.   yW I > LA-A' ; iF ,J+ e yL u1
yj 1   i641 S J wL1 Jj 
*!.(1986  Jlg   r4; l 1 9 l3 :vil  c  Ioli
'Luj  ')a  O- s~ z.-a-- ZL-   L)j   1 
.~~~~J      LA , L5p Ly 2ul e a9> j>e1
64



Jj~A 9- j e4\UYj      >    \! ;1! 990 Q AJI A 19
jugfill Qg  1997 J 1970 ,   yi JYl .(3-1;I) ALiI
~~L  ;.~~~U3        J   t
w)i ~>           -    5   Ci -JJJ J<i  -1 +4;J!42I rlW
Ull  jsY   J>UW .)u1J eSW ,>- j>* 4  A-
J. 1997      J 197 0  J-
jJ! ;51y J L~~ Z8  -ui ,L--U, 6
jjiS  8 J.)J         3 OiJ tA I4SJ 
y sA- ~ ji 31 j  .'199  j,yy 1991  199   198
JJ L> i J,Sl4  j Ji ai;lgJ 1 wL; gfJlesJ65iJ



OUS eA1 >1             eA1 91~:3-16LQ
85                              1.15
65 = 1.05 ..............................
75                              1.--'1.0  ............s-----------
65                              1.05         __________
55          *.  .1.00
45                              0.95
1970    1980     1990    1997    1970    1980     1990   1997
_ .U1, LT u ............ ...,L 
-    T  Lj,6,i-                            1 
JL<j iy  . f                 .(..8. . 9 a.... ..L.2  DyJ
$ U    2Jji ~   c  'di J       (AU>Jd ji 4W1) >J
*(L1999) j11:,,l
f  i;L; ?  Ol;  s   +    S --J    *(1987 W 
A(+987 L                                     -, ,  9+,K,  s Jl l L Iji
4 JoIjJ iu4j I  I  L6ai6
~~~~~ -W                        Z<>-rJb L a.oJ LUSi, 41,yA :26Yl
JI 91 a; ,1 xii 11 3 bf (1998 :r'S < :,)aJ)
66



5----. -1993 c 1.14 J1 1980 cL 1.7 e  -
;v:GAj .(1998  C j )J-ll94L>!t3j  jp-9 v2L
e wL431 '      x 1       - LJ+l uz    UJs1;ylilS
- -! (1994 J   j ,;46)  JLA  , c4.U--jl A_ eLpj : CeLg1, t4 ;,U
>,W-      31 y1    1   Sl da -1 ?  L,aJ JJ  D O
.(1998 aIUW  O ( 1993 J Jy J d 415) & ,  JL 2 )l-.,LJ
CaI ~ ~    ~   ai 81 osi s  J   toJi a> lb  >  } 
W3 )All DIYSIS M Sl(DALYS) %51  J 4js .1_i.S
%J-LI~  QA1  PYDI - -A  .(1996 1 5)iJL_ 4IJI
16j    jj-di J   JU.-A J;e 4i2Y;8  1  27 eOj JW j
j�JlpYI 81 -              L) iA' 8 J  ,
U:S9J l JI <eioD  JJ,3L~J ,jJ-i 6
SJ8 Let oJ" t;3lols i,52iLd!ilI ;
a5J_ ~J 49 j i;;5l! isji L w-JI i j- j 3oY_ii
_t \_D}i LJ 571i L- l  J 410 L|S  L>~ L1:- j! tj i
.(I 1999   ) 
67



.1 990 Uw 44-15 Zw
4iS,LgfjLI                    wL//ibL
7.0                  1   y9     2.8
6.3                ,IJI a,1e   4.9           ( FJ'i IsjJ ___
6.0            (9vej1,,        4.0             >1
12I                            3.7 jf�J .  18y
4.7             JZLU    i5b3LL   4                    i
4.1                       ,       3.0          (6     -1 i 
3.1.LS              4  ,1k1    3.0          .J.2l ,j'L~ s;,w  I
3.0             _v66 sYU 6U    2.9                 w~uj
2.8               iyW .l       2.82
2.7              xJL_L    i    2.7                   W
12.7                2      L-  19.8                   A ;1a6i r=J'2
11.3               5v9 J.Ai     5 9             iU
7.2       '.L721 5,wi,�_>', i,s   4.6 l6
5.6                 -53iL  jii L~Ll  4.5    .g24Si6v_
4.3               ivJI    e    3.8       41!Yzla_ vskk
3.8               ,xal s-      3.2               289U
3.2                     _,-,Jl  3.2              CGJIBLLtA
3.1                   ., ,lsi2.4 (&><ia
3.1              44-                          ,L 2.3  , l AJJL L531  VuL~
2.5                                              - T w6,J  22_lSl i, Wl
>5J~~~~~~~~-J I) i 3 1 J;  s L.Cif  U JIZ j.   v , l  L iil  il OiJ A A*I
.(I1 996)  ,s :,
68



L2J.1  M -G1 K1  , i o 99     L~ 21    J j,- I
S/, *>   & Ji 4U.jl v91 KU �s, O p3 Y ,z e r'j A1 91
ft                   Jayl L A1 A Q ~~~4~ -  ; ,2 
3  L-J Ji3 <     .(tl)(2000 41Wz L-JI Z:L) akP'D HS
>x-ki A S1J oUX1 A� *S u~ j i J<-k jyX 9
<L;LJ I JS <P Y ,-1- 4  JlSi oi  9
.jal J %:_L. ,u+    %   5         j Si
-15 5f                  0 i&I 
Ji J*Svn4 _       ><lIJJ       S;:lvO\ 50
J1SAJ     -iJv -(1999 SE+ Qf     ?)J J 2)
'G~~~~~~~~~~3               L5  169Y 9 W9 \L Ji Lb
91  e SSIvZlY\!GvYI  v/Y;! J1 691



95   ,    5 .(1999 j-4i .o)i ._y   joNsly ,e  -A16  i jij
j '.ysjg 20 i;1<uy           j  S 2XE JsjjJ -
.zel >kylJyAi '199   6,s,  ulT J,,  2 j
> yJ 20 .|20 ~L 5 J1, ;1 J l j ,,
rl10   C    ?l   I  i  JI:s       JW *11999
. 1950 CW LJI             !.,+1 uJ 91S L5c
Le-YZl             9J  PJJJG ,A1  ;-L, <ji   JF
L), ,,1J   1   Alj>;   J,)   1)       04s     !
aszJv~~~~.OlLzl- 'j            +          !C  1  A  1)CJ j  GO
JL-)  iLsJI ?! 91Jl Lj            L.J UL63Y?AC j 
2L? adl 5JJ 4  0> AL)J  -SJ 4YI DYJ - uj  J  2LJU
&)1 ASJJ!.AIJI ,? S (SS JA22 ?Ld 55S IJ
Y-)         B S �kSOU OUL S 5  4  ZL;A Z4L 19  .X! 15_44J
<3~~~~~j 1     4I1  X JILD}S  1  J1  L5!- -(1999 jlO
70



a~~ �v                 i     u-;!9  1 >Is
A1 Ki   S        i    , 3'--  91-Q  9JW1  g19 31S. 1; 
-X 1996 si  As -~ 82 Jl 2JI W      S1   j JSU ,..x< JI
4S LW - 1997 '+    A:   'D   Al '4200   -1-   J Hji  yji
;,51jK4 ,N    JL ;S1 '   yo9  31 >^J   >3, 'K 1 J,i o-
J ,.J'ji~ jv- jr  4Ai      L  Ui!   LLJA> JiJJ r , .Wt>&1 -^ 
*~~~~~~~~~~~~~(1999                      ��>y0) >JI >J2J jL5YjS
p~~~7
-1996 CS~~~~~~~~~~JI 3C; L 2J,; 1 i S>, ;l ,
JaJz~~~~~~~~~)           > >J  HI  JSL 3()-L!C; 50 L
-3 199   PL WDJyl )e jA Ul-  -J!J 82 LJ   L)
,?~~~~ j                           (9I W3W 5Ro l 11  lJ21 S
9! .(~1997 QLAS3 L5) Z. 20 LJ 
jJ      .(ei   4S1,     )   ,Y           i,N,iil2 ojl
,JI              WJ                      11 0S -i j)Jlj ~,, SS;AL OV
.(1994 DW
.71



41 j ,.Le,JI , j1       L, zi4) ,> tj1 IA  a  ~-
L, W  jl 9 LJIP   ;Ll S 3S5a 5 j 
lL;JI , ?! -J2.4 ,i  9JL0.8 - JL-J W I.l? <k)1 CLj-1;
FL1! J)l R J;) ,<.(1994 j.;A ^), uli
L J1 )it,iJ    .    v I, J, ,l jI oyl
a Wii b:9t a: (1996 si,S9 , ,
.(1994 jiJs 41997 j-iJj It- Iw  r  x'-J  > 
ji~~~~~~~~ -;1a-9131sK  >-X  X     91 LJIp
*(1994 )  ;;SL  f)   J T    JIYI      JI4I-II1
as1l JI- IIJ  ?   1? r1 92    O   1   l;.+    S
!;~~~~ JLl -JY �J)l        < 1 38 Jj  j9 1-j 4JJ4I
HIJYI  J  !  *(99I 1  J JL-J WS <J ,     A,
;IJi J. I  4 j I!    CLl ,- ,;2 IIJI
MY WA !; !; ~~-7                   I ,RJ- J9S P I 1
*(1998     s1      -
A.9 J! 0- ?e OjU  LLJ w(1998 OJjT3 I,, 4-~1994 _qj5
W1 ,21 HI ,a &l1  70-12  I!,j  JL121 J ji OL;j J
-I!(1994      ,LX)   L+I. ji, 1YI,  D  58-9,ik  ;
JL Y .,;J !k SY A j                       _tSU-l J< S  2L-
RS JljIP.1P4FS       1  JJI?    !   ES; ,
72



J    1  )i1 o        7 j .(1978  J, 
(995  . JL4,_~j )(1994 8 j ;UzJ 5  ,  J J, 
J zi � �~ WJ            j   ,l       y3~ o119o u i 
Si tt23 jGt51o      21)19S              55 9
*(1998 AJLj 19   '1994
~ 45 Ji.,- J! 1995 Ss Y>J J'~ >  J LI - U J25 L  -
*(1995   IUUJy �  i       clj 195jJI  Jo 1970 y t   J '
uaJ L-JI L-JI 9  ,� (2000 ,--uIjO8"1   A<j    g
.(998 jAiX ' 1998 t  1994 _9
4L.1 L5-9  p 9,lSl   ;    :G.$t a6.g       .l
tJ-Ji jS Z-a 45 ,X�W11995 �ls- L Z_; JUF! jE  _-J Jz a,! 1 25 , E 
Y;l ;+f11  1j! (4-1 J<tJ) L55-P LT i< $j -jj
,! ,4, 821 ,98 ? ,;11 -,11995 .l1970 ? ,e >
73



ie,;,t~~~~~~ -Z ;.;t I1 6 &fZtSQ :4.1 6C
LJ  5At WI  0. ;           - 
50
10
..................         .... ....-.I 
~~~~~~~ ~~~~~..........., 'r,i
20~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ . .. .. . .. . ..,, l ty o J
10
1970      1980      1990      1995
. 1999) 32     ,
S1 2sl J;U1< 91 ts 2,                                     L)
.:Zlp o      i ,L-Js ta1  iJ 3 j i        u         -L ji
Z--j ~    .3l ,3 C,>Lk   ZLl  L) & t;AW  JL,) L,3  'i ZL, Zi
Si~-:-~       cl-JI jil  ,!,   JUb (5-1 J<  91 ,i
-Nl <                          ~'S1 J~  i  ~  , jW;-l     wij .oL1 ji 421 J    9
74



sJfjJI~ ~ ~~~~~" l!- J5Y.1
4
j   *-t &  J  L"     ZA 0
U  ~         E.l jjd
*i5s4 91 J9 ,9,, 1A1! t+1 J-K,--l oY-X   I j9M1 )i :aS 99s
(1999)~ ~ ~ ~~~~.198 Zkl_          U0 a:
L19)                                             e<LZA:i ) X0 E oil L3 +J
- 91-  o  11 ! St, Jv J L 99 u C"S
f~~                    J ~~~9U > 
U                                     Lyi;  J- �J  .o
5Jlj            L) eo L~                  Ji  jrO;8 )JI S S ; J7
75



4vJfi2 sL%WI CJI oi~ .x .JGJI K Yi  U$S      L
4..� U' ~L 77 j    x   JfJ J L.J    Ui .L 71 JI-i ~W
iej .(15)(2-1 J5Al) J-Ji  <  U iLU 73 4,LUJI Jj  i  cJl)
qI (1995) XU'WI j A 87 J! (94-1993) Ai1 L  LJIj 43 L 9f.l
9l 90 L;! (1991) 1;, 3E  43 , <lj     ;L-Jl J>U z,Ju
Y alulJi  Ji> ,9!.(1996) _1  3, I1 101  1 19 89) -L L; j3
Ji J16 +,Lj�  As U  J I  L   JI A   pc , 
l_i,yij -9  C>F, ;zIj  Jj- ?  l  9S1-y9
�2 JY-<Liy  4.- S jL-.i  4UJI  ,X 5 )L l Z))L1  ,, isl
.(3 j-d)         LC. Ju UALU7jb  I
s"IJ JL>.U oAmkJ 6wAVI1 :2-1 Jg=
_aJ) I .I ILJ J              I J
80.4       0.23       0.77      (19=J) a.A.XLI JJ,i
82.2       0.27       0.73      (42=K)) kAUJ JJWi
J} ,,zil  s,13-1u ,;'i J. JS.)Uw JI j>8  AJ  : JI 
~A33 _4 .          -111                  4L , 
76



1-Jl JL j -         Al        '; L  J''j JA 1 
J, Ou, L JLi- .J,I Z   M Lt      S 
L~ j   A    6 J6L~ I L j 5
z L1 LL- J; u  w i :.)LI,  --  oL     .J i
4,~U  ~     Z Uk                  L
2~~~~r,     o L. L  e i  U,> I  i  i  L!>J;, I 1 
4  j-J I      I   J  9I L   >, 1   A )
77
-  .j  . -,1999   J  9 JU  gXJl <:E Jj 0,U-i IwoTet;
J!             j 5te9  li-UI  J  &-yl   i,- S1 i   -
<L1~ ~  ~~ __,,,j,J  jj- .(96tP)OJ!9SUW  ln^ W
J >131DE>gc b? 2Xit1 0 A jj l42il.7
L;lli L~~~asJ;JjJ 3 (92,F ,,) )<9JI -
aLL  0-0  x  ,JA1J-al , 4;il  lJ iN wlio77l1



LJ9 J10   91 J 1     J~J ,2  3 .(199 ojL1 J,fr I
,.-i S,'-, -Ul   S,       , - I  9N -L-: -LJj -u Jj-j
.(1985   1,013  - 9 1999 al>lis s ac  J;
L) &1- J- -) l L ) l<'LJ>is.  _W  >i
a  9sX ~j - L? Jj w &19  j  - (1998 .ajs-) JjJJl
J  L Js), zJGjkJ ,e -)-  iJ-Ip  L-Jl JL)l  -,L   J1 
(16)  _ 1j  S j  L5
> J S21 syl Ji S~-U-U L1 -U IJJJ 1!  .Oi S1l
rL-     L6,              Li i UJI jU  Li .(2-1 JjA
91~~4.L j G., J  (1)      wy I  I2 o1 J  \j l 
-    Q-_ >g lll aJ -JI  LUkP )JL,4 J L9  W ih2iSl
- >L.~-UJ j   L AfOl  J-- :I)L.L  ,
Ji~~~~~~~                  Le  L,Jl llIL U! L1 1!S  SJX
L L.,-   , L j 
L& K]-Jl JJ\W�       I so- <   JL U 
I4  G Ii �Lz J L- ,U S   L J   jL<,  ;LJL.  k 
L.   Z i  X\JaJI          !51 JK,-t L i   OIJL_I7
78



l~~~~ lU~~                       Ll}
*(1997 ;  A   .9   1975 j U j 
iJI Ji~- e3  41 s   (> o Ul �i4 tL JaI L. 4<!U' Ll<
er4i~ JfJ LL1 9j  -~ oS  -6 7 JA i Xil 25jy-- 
LUy) 1998JiJ eCJI- Q GL , - 8 ;1i 91  '3J .(6-1 
JS L0               ?             JI L1 4l J S L, I $ 5L
J          j1 9- }JI  ' :  L ) .1995- 1975 ,Jj
DIJu2 4 d ~KLLJ L! ta9J ,3}a L Js-i<J13! .lUD 20 
<>~~~~~~L                   -tl,J 3>J> )1  ;Li W ,ts oL e , L^
,5J>i'f JJI a4 , SdiAj 8  7 jl Ut 25LJ J�.J L  25
3lJI 51            JJlJi J>; < 41 jul ljJ .U (}7) Jl
4~~~~ ~ ~~~~ LYj ii
2 ,? ,fi ;)l ,<-5Y O<' ~JllJ LJlL J W!.l> Lsel:K
aLjL -l
;I466                   Z-LJ  -A+     l
(a-v4  20  l  CJ LWl yj> L3 P 19;Jzj- >11 .JLll?
5   Ji) Ja�i )    I 22 f 5i  )!
.(2000  j ujil . Lzli)  :J8j  L,4iP  Mi  j.
79



30
20  ____-_ \                         GJI   - L9 J A f
.~~~~J
\ .... ~~~~........... ,L 
10                          ........... S-,L-
O~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~...... Z--J --  ....~PDjc~ .
0
1975   1985    1990   1995
iJ,Z~ JjWl ,1~ 1 oLisAi :aW
.(: 1999) J1 LII ,  A1J  i s(1998) (WISTAT) , aL ;UU :9.l
J=j1AaM,...t,>l!ueaiow
I-a jL-1~ Z_ 1) &  \l ,yiS       i?au     o
;~~~~~Z-19 L;uj 15  lj~  L!  .   i j-  14
4j    Y                    Jj .(1999 Ai)
VJI l  l               .JIJ
80



pi uz 2,, + ii , 4gi L-,J~   .7-il,U JIs
Jl   i-- y  ,5i~ J~ j
oitl i28! zISL >iL ~6tio  + !2 JL;8 4rL 
L;j W.g .(1995  Jj    1992 \j   '1983 
i  yzLJi1 Jy jl a4 c,)          - L WU  0
:,!UJj Jl . LJi ~;i L jjd JJa S  X 4CJ Y - ! 
JUAIS L--, J.s J1 I, :.A3 -L'J   Ls 6Y,  L-51 
~~~~~~iLsP xi:; 4 lLCS?uA j
i7-1~~8
'3 <,1 ,,! JU-l aLjj:,,  +i  Sj.X  .(1998
-Ig      j<  2_;2Mi .g  _ _   -  U   >
_rs ive  rfiL-  J JJ) ii"aj   u  J J  5)
2t$ J isl ob L<S  .-4  \Lc, >  ,2 >y 
81



T- r
~' 1-vH' [547 Sr   (8661)
7 
988-oi~~~~~~ .90 I
i~ ~~~~~~~              -. 98  .



ci j~~ ?~i rL'  j I j :.
~~*fjJ.�  ~~  ~  A  (1999)A   '- -Y --
14   6
zi -, t J          4 4 1
40                2 0 i7  % W ( y  jf) ; u) i 4  b
jL5' 4  J ;  J 1  2< P  1 j   -(-1l  Li8
jL -JI  JI    14,3oy L8uj 6  tJ vae 9 
W�9IS1IJ ~JPJ ieSl 3,j9,99l(19)  4J 
? I! >3IH I  1 OUJ  S I4; 14.!6 di, I
iJ~~~~~~jjd jsLl ._<laxJsl Xr  !G! 1!, L4
tys !  (19<L,1 ,3 ,fii J9: JE -f-UY  _i <j I -J
.o-E 4  5 ><e5aJlI J<El 1 < > ;;j o
HY ?;u6 0 miHLs SJI ;El? tiJ20<+ eJ L83 



Ji,.)1-.(.          j.1)H         L+zQ (1-5 zj
iJy  i ~WJ <S JJI ,  - Jw2l! 4J     vjs tJi! 6
3.0
2.5
2.0
1.5
1.0
0.5
0.0
0.0  0.5   1.0  1.5   2.0  2.5   3.0
s~~~ ~~~~ 3, JA 1J ty CA .4.th _,9     .Jt A
_1 ,,2 jll J ilL S!  j 9'Ly ;Bl .2,  _JS  J 0ltl 'i!' j
14-6.11     t1J,lo J1A S,Ldt, j.;J ---j vA
*(1999) ,i:1
L)              L1 aj aL.-  : jJ WI OJ JilM2 
K'jl ,    UL juL o  4e' a- 2 29               -
84



JLI6~ WL3;Yj7c~
~ 32                              5
Z--J-L  JUL@  j'A L-5A , LI
s>YI >  -+1' J  1   -$  1  X  -~A  4  -d S i 
A~~~(2)X j:N C�� >i  &   S  I .2l J yLh
; ~ti iJ     SJ             32<- U 111<viL 91Z;IOIJ.O 
O.jiI *.A ) 1995  ~ WJJI  -7 I J. 1 ,
Jj~~L~9iii ~W           -s iy-. sI:o 49 JI?S;WJJL.K7 3
RJIJ J;l f t5 .sXYI , 1P L?JI (i J U "i.lj Ji)
_,.b j5 Q   ?3JI J LyI j l o;   j  49  ji pJLJJ>
'     XJ i  (1998 l    lll      C  x; JI ,!5 eh
a4   2.3 L y   A* J
85



>.J ) e400 Li  - Ji j! 01  o1J goo) >90
,iI           j<in  z., L;- yUJ LiL.
sj~   ~~ ,91J                -."LZ oKc. S1 Jl oze e  E  J-1s
Ni~~~~~~ ZJ otLil            >            pj o t i>
~~~~~~~~~~)- yl e!- -AW,l ^,Lsl ) J 
(22,UL< Iw I u;1!,
tyl Y 4,LaI 1' ,91  1  Js 'S  b. ! ,X  . j
IY oin L+,I j:b                        Z,. IU 1.;  F 9!;  F
.(1995 ,,9j4 isj'a  1995 J13,)   os) Jj., L) -2-4J
J~~~~~~~~~~~~L > Y 4,L U ijfi li-
.(1996 O3STi-j JI>) 4Us-l 11;ES       21= L5,I ,,plj
l} 1? OJ! ~~~~~~(23) Uj~IIJdf
iS bea iJ;15 J3j .(1997   'y )4u 8 NC7I 
86



J   k4J   .(2000                  U, 1L  j  J, cA k
zyl~~~        ~~   -di     q Aa1191o ,'1997) L ,
<:, l  L." .   jJZ  Z-Aj zxia  L) t  i  J  i> s 
S,A, -disj 4-u 1j  G  ySjzp  zie   u
o:tJ: cS\4s   1e11996 Ooj,>    1Zl
.(2000 -J -y  W  '1998 ,oj ' 1998 .20<J0% 99
Lz3JI JI-JIIJ  L7JI
S au1,, z zi ~LUz3                .1yaA  j 
J~~~JJ           j .a2000 X,<. WJoY C  1  L-ylScJI 95
87



o 3Li t1y J -'~ A!   AIiJS j1 t J Yj U L J 1
Uv 9LU�  3 ,  J19 2 1I / 9 v  ,i J j 3.(1988 3U>
--ts1231 1                 a.i - 1,y1 Ol J i  I  -U
i;r-'~~ iJj-ljgj  ~  '1981 Ij  3tJ 's-) ,Y- I y G}1 3 tJI4
$ lll  >; ~JLS>   i;i,<S   X ty  (24)(1990
3j91i1 �L1W IWi  J > )j1 o 1 Ji U  I  y 1
* (1998 , .( < 9   Jj ,
olJLl 4 5  p- Z-Ji z4A,5 9:JI G88
+1 jiJ 4JuJi o! 4J;~~~~i.j -Us Jij L. (t9_l1  i3
>1  +  9W21!~'A.   OLzyl  ,L,i j  W1 i r
*(2-1 lJ ),   g  IlI<>  llJ
A#  lQ    13(.IJYI  19a.-.   40919aa  LL- rk
s        ~~~~~~~j i j at  19  L1 ;X,L.i JI,yl 
Ja '% JI! z5~~~~~J,yl  4-1izaJ,  1, 1  J,X 
L-JII 4A,aj 1jL-J         L-J  z--ui  jj3j ji? W!6:r! J 2
L-J IX ?   ~3j e  11+-2           j - J 3-)1
,pEl >1 ? 1 ,5S w) 4,iJSJI ty  4, !! (- 1994 91
w)> Goll OlJy2JI!~~--- 4LIX  glJ I  L)! .,111  L?e  t<-J I ?
L8 o1= w59 J  199 DY 8 J;9l a si s1 ;X1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-J 
.(1999 jgl z 5i  1994 3J  J
88



Wia~~~~~~. "C1_ wNl%-a -;9 ,1 O ,si l ja 2- 5,9L, Sl
aLd- J- ;   j- b J l  J- ;aj  jjd 91wE  (Iz  ijS 
y  J.S S!-1989" �) 12
-(00 e yl 9 4zzUyI LL--I 2,tt ^4_j iX199 ~- jjy a;1991
>#    A, J--J >A  )J S  X Xsg 
-rl 9   L X   -)u ,  , >  <,;t*,,)1;1
i,> 18 lgij  ;L) ylJ9ls 1S9
.(2000 e,^!'99  @lol1JIr j 19  >  j  '91:9
31 4Li iJ!D V~-p  v > I 1 3 AtiJI nIi lOy
4jd  J vSJ:l  > L z 1- U l 9
.(00 rl)cXSvw 2sLSls  >  > JY  ;  s
J- _:e,lo il J,,4vbJiy          os
zi W. .,FJI 9 aLw ,LD >liu S a JA Xyl SJI  z
.(1995             L5 L5L"S Sl  J  X
89



-~~~~- _G1-9!91So1 (1990 ql)9  X 
(  . (1998  X
J�)~~~~~~L       L LWi Ll ).iI  L . U
1~W ~L wU1I 2   U  1   Uo1X L1~ .1 t!JW J'  o  Ii u
o191~~~~     ~~~~~ o1L4 jSW  uJ4s!1O!.L
jL  WiT  SI -yl 65  In  L3 L  .LJl  :Ac-L-JLI
.(2000 ASJI 20-10 j,;  ,U JU'l j  70 L-uy  S
L -JI  l   1; J   I S             I 'Jl , , i s A c i l   I I J - Li
j79 Ji    aiU L)  I-A-, L-5I j ,L 14 - , I
-S'- (;u Lj I Zd U43  C ;_)-  j~  ZL,?9  60 0JL-
?~~~~j       J$5        ,   t jA Ji, ; 91LAJ  l jii
5JJ Jj ;;zylL-S ILa; L-i LjUI. L+, sR,,l LI, ;tDi ;j-G
.(1998 Lrt) L5--jUIaJ>bI I r   irj'   J*I  f  S
Ja   I3  L) 5  Z-,   Z,,uix 11;; iz v
-J)12ii zdl, 20-10  r,,  S L-  l,  l  1 JL-)  I  9IJi Ll,i
L) J L) -Li J -9t!                   pJJ. 1994 JI
2 4J+|! ;vL~~j    JIl W8-SI ,! 8  )1U1 ;  L- OJI! 5
90



31 + ~593 a1,, 1>�J i4 v -
ljs )91   Uj1  J t   1594 31 UA 364 a  ,L3! -     1970
i11  4  1iz!  1  o>z ;lot:l J tA181   j-Lb 31 a
.(1999           LA--ji   t,9X iO a-'IL 22 j110 ae jL<  ?
i ' 1 jlu Ll> o JI-                     .(3-1 L1 Ai
64 1 5 ,    9j:1         1   9       S              i-
Dr4!-.6     Ja-41 u13   4 Lj1 9  65 e, ix 
oZLi 1 A,pLJEl                    >   L,U1 l .b ;L;l , Al 8  . 18
4SJ~~~~~~~~~~-I            J;I L1zoy  S1=  <  i - yl
L,   11, L ZJ  .L ,,S lWl JuAyl jubSl!  :kyL6A   (S,JI Juyl,
9 >



o5>-;~- asUJI J.-1 UL~JI y i>c 4wt atI Jl9 U
j~   ~   j  .
':-i WL5 1 t  L-  --   8  1  Ai j,L 3 - -j a91!   Iu91  G2t
O,9Ll (<  ,1 l      Al        ('n oJI 91!  U  ,iJ;L-
2< 1  l tj i..U  c  ZLicLJ 21W  l< .9UJ ,r 3  Jo
JI   4&YLJiI ,?yl  191Ji 4%JI C)Mi .43Ji A jKc4y Li
8 A~- 8  ,.,u ,,1 -$l .s .4;X Lj  J-I  ; , 
C/ ~~~4 ~~~~-' j2p L 2JZj
bW2i SiJ  L,a1' EgJil\1 lJ2. jWI& L ~} tS  4t 
if- JAi     j        UJul },Wl a   J j�< 
Jc 3� .jl - C~S-l 31 OLl J ,WI  O1Lc- J�R -1
t .  yyl 2  jA  !  gi   .U 2ya.l  S  j k
92



L)~~~~~~~~~~~~~. 
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
>,~~I .l1,1  ;iI e 985 i  Hl iji         ,
~,';   CJ. 51P z  _L    .(1995 j I iAl)     L)j 3 ,  wi
,(I 998) DFID 4J-di zl-J ijl,) (I1998) DAC J Is
.(3 999) CIDA  5(1998) 4a i                    ,
MsSl~~-~         ~'-       '  .   - lX \jy 
L--.J i  Lr-LJ 
93 yl jbC � S i Le,
~~~~~~~~~~;LJi j%L             0JSl J>YL  i Ut,, lL -u 
jj  >:L  vSX    jGe<;    e   lJL J93s



4-1 ,,a i>l  y 3-0 i>- LL U   (1992-1986) UUj-z -3
~.2 :'i ~  ~.J ~i~awi y.w j iA - 1 w -4c
D (2) 23 ;)UiJt  L sJJ  ;u.a- !l,JI L1"J i L,-4
RJI,A, Ls l i,       (1) 16  "LLI JJ 'L3Wl  l l!;4c   j
fr >j-I 4,ll 4S W! *45J U1i ji oDyy 64i e<s:yl
JJ #        a_i JL141 oJll sJ W! 4iLU  ,o SJI
yyg~J .llic <1 o� 1990LJ-l z19 4  ,   ,i ~   wi-y juyiJ -   -6
JJ () 23--J ji-il X1 slU 4.JiyJ s; l oJlll~J Z; e91uJll
,F~ j,--i J2+  J~   ;-A-1 ;H  197 G  j Ji  -7JI 
cI~~~jj,  l j9 ~J S 1     oUt. Iz,e 
4 Ld.    - Jj-J I J>!  J  u u   l
alb  JJ,S s;3Ijli -I_L--u (i-Al  I 1j  .-  I  JJi)  Jl
LL-~~~~~ 9 9J 02 ? fi;  1 9JIl 8 5J L  6
-Lj j9!LN ji J 41 :,l: J -jU -+ i - 
94



oue 24', ZL,  M,jl  ji -)Lzj 1889 �Wl J i    -8
j>  ^, .     , ;    5 j, i   138 <,  .;   cA wJl  J,Wi
i'A          -)LZ        iiw jW ;2  1  @u91 5l :X1 1
~~~~~~~~~j                , ~  UJL&Y jL-,LI  -9
-j� I�f^      -    JL6   -
*~    -~  ~     J j1 s   vl tj  l  <e)l -9
.(0 0) 
.(HAyU 91  LY  Jy    )s - k1998)  4jj - 1998
2?1J jL-J Z--   (DALE)                  -,Jis  )- Ce 1 
j4,5JI  GGY      t  Jk 3uTh  Jji      y      9k    -14
1- l,I  #  QJI jl Y J9
9~~~~~~~L.i         L- 9j 4l o1> uHjiz
.(2000) altlwl 
> t~~~~~~-i         - L 9   l2 .5r  :UL  -12
i 92/1991 Leog J      Xi6L G J      -li1 LZ 4iS
.(t;ll: JjU4    1998 j,sg-   1998
98 .L1  ail^            ,k ;- A- IE   Jj.)JI      -13
>  |9W$J,28 c  ,<  v   JJ ,A    -14
95



J;L2 Ji JiS~JI (1J! ,  '<'W z!  -  At~ r~-'~K(1955
JAS 5L2 C  1 ,11I J! 'S cJI  9V Ji   LSJ 4S ACI(
U -,Wi J>g  .GspJ DlA i oa2J *5 WA^Ji ,j 
4 j  -y L� 0.3058 JX 0.3458   W OI 4 '  !
);   s JS LPULJI Ca S  0.3097 J10.3948 
ouS1 s1z Jo 5 s   ' j O.3860 o:mA1! oJ    ruc 
>~ 1+ S21! yl ;1 yei 2.0.3804 o2
0.4030 J10.4421          y        -         Wi Ji
*(1999 y.L) OJ$J 3i JYs
J  ,La-7i L-Aj Z-U J,. 42j >~-: tJ,. 19>a,il o  -lS
.3 <
> b- + >1aLJ  J-,1  _>sl L-,L -              -16
(1999) ,r, .  ;   Jb  X     ,  k     -  U 
c,'.i LJU Jy       U              jJ     W       -1JiJi7.-.  0! J iIJ
jjL1 JJ, 1jA jlJ.) -,A -  _y             (;>l
*(1992) bI,j pf  z-i--J5, ^,j
s 'SiJ bj UL. 31LI!  j,-JI `-jJ l j   ,j-  -17
iyz d U)W+ bJL! b,s UiJ: :Jj, 5 ,e  Ul z
l;g<JI   ld  l wl jt  3 FL J t 9   )L-LI
.(2000  IAl VI) Z.-LjJ Jj, L)t,b 33 Lj 25  - aU1 2LJI Ul-J~
J1 oULL Di si  j  IL )  J 1  )
.Is S-  ,  L) j --Ji   , j 9
96



4l Yu 1 ~  a    i LJ J~ ; le- -18
Z;J  L 4 J'S C 5, (2000 jUDI oA MYI CU)
zi!H 8 jl y ,    T  r~ j Z 6, JY 7jE 
't) J   3           -Yl L i-P ))y,ij  j J  pi  J
~Li~ -~.;J -~ -%J
JS ! Lilyis, l ~57              :do<SoS 12 UL - 19
- 5Xw '1.9    -                  y�i o) Y)�!*s
.(199997   ii
_L>,i,i                               ;>E jUlX .  5j -20
;L,M, ;L-_, J~h OL: JIU~~ rSL O  ;liL  !ISI
eLia!4t_a!;! ;!,lWy! GO LC,TI fiz! ibj  21
;SJ'I13 i L5 eJlj                JU6 G,_  e
; JJ! ;LiSJJ! ;J>! eL_! eJLSl! ;JI! GI};J<! i~~~~~~~~~~-jL
Lps2j�, 8je1 4y          ,x$
iz,,i, J a.. Jf , ^,i5, i,; auL S a1~~~~_jA -2
.~~~ ~~    -,,5j Fof??   s    WJy
wix  vit1y31  Lu  - 20 ,Xl97t



',XJ' ,rLEJ >21 oUL. S ~~~~~~~syloL !9 -22
t5,~~~~~~XY;e 921 2 .S1U J),sl 'j L"
9 ;Si 3! i .9>1 5219 > s* s -i 11
'~~~j~ L.  L                L L
.SYIU Jjd L)  LO6Ld L) ;W  awi,     j   s
jyl 92 L.~ OG Ao4yl ~JLiU >J  5  J                -23
J      jAJI  I  U))                     Ji iI  L- L IJ L  U
~~S-)u'   iuz.    -i'k -    J      -24
,z,�i aVJl ,1 e 9 Y! ~~~~~~y  i   L) a ; 
-J 45LI ,,1 9                    ;,LI,JJI 41 1 oliyl -23
.(2000) 9 J8 . Y)  1989)
LeLc         'se JJZA j.6L1  ;bUlS      ri<uJ -24
1 aQJ~~~~~~L)t<|I.1 l1 bslJ 1992/1991
A;i .~~~~~~~~~~-J,-l         :  2 JIAi DIs U  4 1, i:LM:Yl ,i.
,otiLJi oic$ >1- 4i;(1998) -9!  ' (1998) 
, + <jJ ~~45                                   - sy i1 oi "J-25
,1994   4)Lo4 A;I) L,-lbEJ, ?  W  l;JI   ; Li.tj 
.(1998 OuL       j. 4J!1
98



i:eWKJI
I,: t   S   ! ; 1  , J i s 19  I



L       1 -   i 4J�  JI  a   J2
~~p�  ~~  ~~ jr~~~  w  j  Jci  L5J. JW  L5  i
4XJ'l 3    &: iJL J4,oL .4 a      4 ,.i <lli
,W!Q JJ llWAWl    {,:   ol4Kl �l Jl- ei
iJJyl <J +U Ji A'Jl<J g-5kDJIWJI ) 4!ol
�,e3 .lJ *jS /)ps 9l-~ < <p1 41 w) -  >lJ   Jy, -1K,? oltk
ULJ;  1   I:JI -Li  Uj- . -Aul   JJ l  JU JbyUl 4UUJIl
Aj6l3, ll j  I  a-i jL l  J!  ja..  ""Ul Zb100
.i    -  fl,       L J   iJi .,, I+!,2
S~~~~    ~~~                -) Ltyl 1  LiZ skE i i   L, ?
tirFY8 GslJI! L2;l Lgp   1  ! 7 uti  ; - 
'> i:$- 8 ! i1 H 91 ><- a >S1 zu:'-U  j gj  j 
J             S  Y:  SS1! O 1 ~~~~~~~~~X  -J  ,-t.191
.<L 91 1 o~~~~'S'9 ai LS IRSS y  Dy
100



i-1 JS aC-~ ?i�  OLy oS L, >    jW 91
ci; coBJI$ 64Asy ji , ~ CJ  b  kiLJ'T ;f WS  a
-)L4-iY  Gj y <   J 4 -.  +-  J�- Ja  A  s   --   -j-j-G
u,  y o> ,  I ,,   j.Sl jjI              -aYl lc1 
Jb JUlJi - ,,Jz X,YI ,i 91 l a  1 
i2    ;.-J\J (1984)  aij J    LJ-~i J, .I L,91  -J- 
;,5r;�  J3SY-~ -K  ~1 l .s.A-tZk  ~   ji  -,  L-  U l O-L
jLJl  j,,I  L-J  j~44- ~-~
101



,# ~JI.., Jl-y j  J;L,)I ;;L-J  L5-  UL,-   L9Sal L) - 
U i,L .11 ,,19 J  1 J Djlul C ,L-U Z-J  "'D  -,jI
,JL-u   y l            Lll _1   -G1 ]; Is jcjL- I  1  tl L5-s
ji t tjz 72 - 91,oj.(1-2 9)J*1-"J
--  1  o1 - a, .A.SU  ,L>t S  3l>  Pl
i;L1 J osU1) >e Sy i U I &U Y,i .(1998 I,)si6
L>U1 l LWs419          J Xll JL<>oy 1 f14
wt2I ,WJL 4! !.~  SL 4sy s    l   Iw - p 
~~~~~-u     JJiJI +-s g  io?u<J tl41 eIq   ,#i .J)D  _LNS-
.u'          JU lIlO  llH!.Ll
<, ja,5 j L,,  ,J    t-li J;L +, s"e .s1 -! Jj  %
,L ,XI i_- 1j1l -  4_,aj   <rl, ,;l ja Ls-  -:'L J y
102



35                              35
20                              20          _
5 *
0                               0
0.7   0.9   1.1  1.3   1.5       0      10      20     30
39-20                             (4   i)
15, cL,-,jL<J8! >J C e wf 20, j l  9    32) t,72    b  :
3yA  l , i             . o        K' S  'L-X GL Jk � 4  ,
28 jJyJi~ ASX 1 stkI );j .(j 4 j3 yW,i~U p A1 �&JI 2. Zj j  ;j Ij  r
(1998) zJl
o~~ cLJ            G1G sS>U1  J9   J  jAI alu
L  JL z l !                             : - ,WU) 98  J
103



J1 Ly guY j 1 JI1 4J~ j Z- �G 59 ck'U C
)5Xi1 191 c1 � .azA-91 W C L C. )i  -  4k'  XJ
-Y (1995                           :,JL; ,YJ 
~J 4>1   c  u sIJ -T fs  z  J S1U  +*.A  LY19
.(T I1999 J21  9  < 
-ia,9 b-,J ss !LJ 5�9 2 
,S1 ,61 ,; s >         2  ,i  S   ,+S 
39~~~~~~    JL.;  j! y w2  ,6aX  mJj
;L6     - ill  , L W  oil J3L< 1eJ,:tCl  E (I   s  l,
~~~ 5k-)' i ~ ~   a-LAJL)
?J  W3 J; rl JA  s4 J  _1JJ _  N <j  l.L.  j -21,iJ1
_r't JJ- ,,- ,iI  e   (2000 O3S1 4  bU)oA  i  n
b! :A1 > ~J.N                      2IJbay Ys - > (1998
.(1998  9i
Hlysl H J 19 uJ GL<`        1 4,1Iylsj
j 1997j 1990  c > JL-) ;.Li! 4J
104



-('999~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
IJ4 >E <:XC! .(1999  gT Ujh2) ;U3i  1 1X bYI~ I99
Kri J9J U>I w)J9I eo-E _a$ ,b;Y$ 4All:<1;1<
u sAl lJi J < a+! .s~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~LJI sJ Jvl5 X
- ~~~     .(194 ~ 2000  ZA,l JU) '~Qi  ij-i
J4:;)i sX slfi .195 sJL&a <yW ]JI G -XA- 1 J'X ll
U.(S1999 , ') 1993
Lpl,,sEl y  -ui .Zi L 5 JA JJ$,J          GJ,10
bE8! oJjl} 3JJI s*4Y -.JX  L)J!GJIz<  -09 )- >  JGJI
3.2O                 J'l; 1 U39 GJ 4u uY
1    1a!.499 JIc            L:LI   '(,99 ZJ 1  l O199
<:,,c \ 9 ~~~~1 05j!oG 1 - y>1



CL~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~C
i  C  .  *   t  . ''  '.C-.  C-t
- t  C! k   1< : tf    'CS'   : ; ;'t* 



aiKL  c ~  ~.(1993   i}'1995 ;j+-l -   L il ~-
o~ a o Jf <  <BJI h)U e yS i22 ji  9 4, C.UYX Ci
1     ;1 W5  cA xJ oUL,-JS j-L  .(1998 5 -) w  +kI
cLJl JL 'Ls OJ .(1990 1-,6O oY1 %D )  K, - M "-i >
~~~ -~ 91 2-2i J�W I,1 4a �
J     .(    19967A.4j) 3L59 .Al      - 3  r
a lJ-1jvll jLxcPYI  2-2 J-<- i-Jl a-,; j .& l ;b  ,   i1
A S +  S S AXs Jj SUL! ~-41 sy LS~ j+- ':
lT  e  J 9, jE 9u1 sj Gju1j  j j �L +  Aj  l
1l J,iLZ 1 :  J  -y99  419  L- cJ  j LSij
oiri J  kjlnJI AS l b bs <JI3 oril FJI ,!   :A-iL .lij
J ? A~~~~~~i    - 5ce $lij-3 3lJ s
107



pi�el b tQ  til6"s i   : 2 9 211
�985zSl66211923-1 ~,~l23-12 JUA
100
80
60
40
20
O
LI j,   J    y  ZI -     ti
01 --1 -      ji J_, _
~~*     +     !  $X *  SiJi  jC'
Ai1 il, oU  oWS  o  I j91 jAi :aJ-'S*
;;S - ', g JS 1! 1SA1 oW+1 oT S jl uj +L1J :,L,6 dll
.,1999) 32 
8 j . S1 ,  J9l  J1 J j LA   y   Ui +  20 J1
) J >   J1 .L1y 4 _ A1 ,I J_ Z, - 1A
Zil   -_S-  } l3 %9J < ol'_  4 ~  o Dj <DI si U; 
-}+Wl >  S ivA;_U ,     j.A
421SJJIPS J1! o;i!o U GwJJI DS Csi;312 L i  <S
,L13        i tl :io S108
108



.(1998 jiL4;, :. '998  jS Jb  r 
OzL ~   UY C- cJI  Ji, sx IS  E  t.9CS
;vI2   o 19          ci tJ2 oW  JJ 981J 
.z- _U) ;ELJ +-   ci 3! e  X$ jiUS 9 I
Uy -; -i2 > 9 L& 11,2 51~k LYI 6S Jb2
Su 25   dv J J L 9 b 10 ,1,~ ob Jj -;Ll  u1
uiJ'  zi! �Y     -W -k  o> 4167) >199  4L19 oA L~
j
109        JYu
b~ v j  L,,l j1 ,qp I; 10 -)Lu ;ZlI J.~ zgL4L
< e sJ) Jz J ,J.(1995 <J iy
*(T 1999 as) ,l~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~yl j-di ,5,oYly  O l ,2
L))
UA :~~~~~~.UJ  J:j   L-



JY~ ~~4
*L Zl J,    <AoxW    AUI    F   ,6 ; sA  -
LiL       I u-  - - ;ty i KL A-4  -*99 y 2
~~~~~~~~ j�~  izl -JiSW p>.   oi,lA LrsoJ ,Fi
CAJ RAjl iJyl 91 ?  , ,  K.1 .Ji p%I 
*+ 3j~i -1  i L    1        L1 (5)i -Jl z  ,g   4;l
L) Jb 50          3 L- <Us 3 . Lp (Jl 4J ,F 4 a
*J 4 Sj- 500 ;,       jj LW J UJJU J6 
-,,1<        JA j wA>! LSi f>.  u.�i-a  j .l' Z-
oF Y! 021 J,I  ji> ju61  S  )S J"I LS;..EU  +
5~~~~~~~~~J',         it, - ?JY + ?S-1L ,t;S -J ;
* 1999-< :rw S        4 A  oJJ 5 )S' 1-U-;
.eljJi,,aB1!ui,Nl oU,eL; "' Ss i!>  ii  LLJbL
K,J~~X4~ JLA1+ Ji  ^R j .da -1 JI )LL -P +j
(6) (177 ,<  41995     L)1 "-j,110
LY--~~~~~ :91 ;Ll ? ; LWI </ ,  -],l f4
.&,kXA  Jw'! ,5; + X, 11- OT J)>!
I110



+    H -   ,  ,                  ci J9 o !D- 'lSlO
l990 fW1 cj UA� l   (  o � -1 (1999) 3   ,,  ..sJi
aj cul C 294 ow A  ,  ooDj 0.23  .
)LC JL.  J I              rL2 I LWU
J    o1 os~~L   ;.U  �Jj !  i   .(1999  j4L)  o Jj0.32,1LZ.
-i~ ~ (7)-j - -e A' sb ,  �r t,-' 4,t-U 4JWAI 
�iSI zL sxJl-5 lS Zi (1999) 3U; t> (1992 UL43-9 :e) oS
1s~~~~~t 6.ij LO I
,,;U' -S >S1  ! .1  J l f     J9 <  ,   Jyl t
LlU ZjAs -UjSS,s o    tS
,i 5+1 3! vil 9 ,Al i S .s,yl I "LJo j  ,o
.Ln   4    P      i       -4l5 .!M1 - -  1 l cS1 A 
a,-L  L) L4~1        JL-, J~J111
.1) asal ,2aL8-  Y 6s j 1  
4J9lUl  Jl,L>I JIJI,! E JI ,JLC 1 )  L YI 4j  rL,+1 1   JL



,F         '-1 vv    -,,          V        -pM�  1 1 iu.,
+(1994       11bi     L.41 JLL  JlI .Jl
2.1  GLUi O11     JLS   JJl   jlY ;   1.6 -DYJ
;y1 4'Y~I�z 4tJ <yL  S  MS (J4J JHJ )1         -3
il; 1.7 i  !JiJ I   ;jH E ,?U :,IO JJ 
..? 42Ul>1 y -#WD 1 ~ 4L -JI  L          aj; 3.1 
Ol4.-l O AYIJu6  -L-,#I~ Jj 1  (1994 S .JijJ9 4>,j-x jLbJY
( 9.(991       +-p
i~~~~~LJIJ ;1-.      L-  -196   JjiN z199   j  1995lil 
,,ej9:ij .e9f)L - i1993 e1991 '~Jjl   eJI2  J  c Aii) 1 -;lji FL--
-)-LZ CLW; JSX  <LJI rLL ,e ioLjL~ i_, fiU, <oGL- -OWI iiol *(1992
J J;)ij CL-Ji >, L+- ',JL   ILYJ 'Liiijj- ';:I s-L'
fil L:L .)-~ D.i s;L-Ji  J i  '-+A 1!0991 jJ-r3eJj J g
JL-Jll '<e L:i vLL lJJ  -~12?  &A ZqLaj i L JLrl
.k;51~ ~  L' ,~ a,35+1  v1>  li,m  n 9  ilp zzi L:N \.U
112



&~~ ;~~~w~~ Y~~  ~ ~   ~~  ~~s~~�~~l ~~~ A +~~~i'  ~l 
(9)(1996 s   '1994  XJ X j   d1993  -sA3  ,4   '1976 .y)
t  2 Y      I J JI  J.o  ;I L  : A-j (1 199
~zAi~l ~rLA;J ~)i L,  I  .J ji~i.
AHi~ ASJR j  A     >S .. 4- ya  e-  1   2
;,�c�lsl H +1 Hs,         jj S11 j) oujl c
I $1  'I JAI A  Si AJ eS   ' W1A
.(1998  1 p    J      1--  j 
J  > |  G~j   cj -ij * jd i; Z--j  Le   -Li >
9 OR D<! Jj.) ?e -(2000 es^l! i1991 .L4L,jt-p)j1JH 
JL,JI e)i W!JST 
113  J�J      f
113



J>L--U jL J~,~i      -aJL, j  j  W-  S 
yJjJy l   Ij 1 i '11 y C1
31~~~,jJ It :9L 8L LJI cj ,Acl .(1986 _9j) 'W 
j ;iLL. �y ,i      j sj .Z4 6 jWs. ,JNu  , Xj - j,
sL-Jij ji,)l  9  ly 
a4 20-6  L L- -;yl ,,u9 j&�i -y .j) i  !   u ;s
AT j.Ls :ik ;LY~iJ Jv) -Y tGX  >11<e:a
.<Ui <U�JI ,,a,yl �11 n <  11 sI,lMl .(I996  1995
Ov~~~~~~~~~~J          ~L3 JI Jl z,SuA I lf 3U
O>l+sl a e jS1 GjJ +!       oLj   ,, >1
JJ-i14i  ? C zl, s4lJ- l< X
.,di                           -1<j +f<J  su 1i
1.6 ,i  ,>  -J ZjU bjJr 9 t5JI  JL ,3 is2
la.,b aiAL-J.Z     1  W!,!  IJI z1 j
114 ~  *IICF 1



l~~~ +l l            l     |     fr  C)   .|  | AR A9W1 
-JS +-, :1-I (I 999) wlci>           1o        j
(1)                      L
3ti j  9      9  1 .( (1-2 Jfrl) @L,J 1  U N1�>i j o
JolJ ~~ i:lsJ J  i!zlIJo   tto'\aX             z
j~~2                   4      9-    38   1987    u-J s i dY -ol 
J~2                    9l     8-    96   1980 aljFv .j
aig au,L o,::!(5) J5.  jl          C-L     OAc,  suiJI 2
vi 6-  1 JajIL4  1 iW' jui-aL, J  < -91  -j 1-
18                3      6.-  4s1 z198   )wi 1
25              4      9-    38   1987
28              6      9-    50   1989       X
23              9      8-    96   1980
18              3      6-    41   1987
20              5      8-    46   1988   ~-9S
1 8             3      6-    3 5  1989   S,S
37              9      13-   59   1966     ,8F
1 4             2      6-    25   1989    Y-e
28              8      8-    61   1989
16              3      8-    30   1989   Ljj)9'l
12              2      6-    24   1987
1(I999)5
115



fol  9 LJI ,,4 -i J uj   (1999) w   }e,
.*4w  >Ai, ;LJ1 J J;-Ji b,U  3 J, J -  1.~  SL1~J J
;XI~~~~~ 5e -y iOk  -1 C      i .2 I JU1J Jo-J
ol >            uL f I Sx .u14 6 ul ,1 CUiyJ jj ;l
Ai 4 ~~~ &..%~~ ~~-, ~~U Lu- 4 -
A9,LI cjp oU zi 5)'- J~ AL  6         U M P JL - -j
@ Jg L < ul .5Jw  - ;> -;J   SL;i
9 ,? t- jI 2Jj-1 j; (1994) S! jjU ?e J5 -L- _U !-Uz
U- + 4JI j)    e   3 1UJ   a5,'l JJ!&LgI9 t5 L
.,5,yl ,,s Si S 1~~k.,L
5ut4- Ll) 0.0084- Mzi M  9  sJ9      9>
otylj 9W2  A  > 5L. j-!;J  ji-L  z DIJ,YI i .(0.0045
OUS )T bed-jp   '3L! S sS u 
-191 '91 ,yl s A 21 eL-! o y,, x -L 1
1164- L4jI  1 RJB ReI 4JLlU
116



(2000) a-Qy                                j -  '   -1 a 9   +.  j
J 3      1      -I 1      J    l   1    -   i 1 j  ,  ; 
,yl 1l t~~jr, fgU j1 a Ju2 0. lj1 J~ 0.3 m
y    0-0.5 w1 90      j1 zp4\:1
j 2.2         Jjj 1.7 Lj I Z  yj 9   S1 I )I-Lis. , ou
.' 1999 ~ 30.-0 1)2  j J1-<
170
0.45 310.2           rL- I Lue  I1 Z-.  uN Lp J 9
>1 a , jJI iJb 0.I S! 0.3 l
,bi JJ, ji p s zi ,, i - (1-2 jj-L,--,2J) 4A,,sl- j- ,
J   j Jl j5 Lsl Ujl
<:~~~~L2Y_ *   L-J.*'PlJ fy <J  >        o IJ  1960 �ls, LTi
,C) DL5   X     J      Y� 1992  1960 y           il T 
Z."j2i 0.9-0.5 <yW 5c  A) ;o;lS         19yJ
Lj_l,-:-J L) 2.2       J T <, 1.7  ,J    l  i, . 
.(I 1999 - f3-2 j,k) i  l
17



plAal WI  ;�t�u�I      jW :12 231'a
U 4.iYJ Jn ,'J9 >>o  9  1  Itt 1,    _S 
4 w,L U 5 sl      L: )L1 -d Lj cJj$i JlAJl > sLp i }-i L
oivly  ~  (1994) j JA L� LJ4U C !  J 
�ili LsLc   A'4 Z!Ll  ~-  j5-~j  ~   J   U A,2-Fl ~94U
)i (1994)  >  Li  j- J)4Q 1J F S  ;i<S  ";JI - oaI lo
jlq                  ~ji  G          'J  199
jJ                 -' ylUl Z  i .J~Ubj .4j U I 4~%W
L5j-y-1<r Qj 2JA l  , L)! .j~jJij  (M lt'collinaiy
J9 JY ? M9                 UI *L L3 -J JI *jl  JJ~ j-l
)6 1j- 4 �Ja! S i59 ? '19l N;l -199 :jij 4 (99
118



*~ Jy ~iL1 _     (2000) ,y     jy
o~~~~aLJ 991   Ij 1  s   1990 -1960  --J aj; 5A1 ow 9  ULJ
IJ9 j,         2 . S  a�1 z J21 :z   S   9bY H- >b   ai~ >JJ5-
y_y65 JL Ji ovs3 bl v 
)fW' + 't- -a.. ' cQ3,.~�L 1~ SyiA OJ X 1 
- ~ ~  ~~J2 +-u~' .il9' JL! o#il u'
-9 JJ W(noeniy 3u 9        aJi  j W14 2Rjos 
19
,VJI ,5L; 11 oin �P .olSll  iJ;1  ; 1)  JI OLZ Ecw ,CyUl i~ll
jy s:$  a11 v6$8! H21 2- otu(1999) 3L n, 1 
4Jst~~~~5L- I    - eUNl     I1   jLsa~'   (19YI 1999)
u21 H~- a U  1, Sj o11JaLT iL!
J:-   UL (1999, 3U ,,,C\   .   o.b   L:. O- 
> osLl oj~ oiLH(endogeneity) iJ J  l  ,?vl  y
119



(I 1999)  :)IJz  :LL   ;W l,  L   i_W   A -  - 1992
,.,I) l  ;-L,I)  ( j) JJ-,J   :d   Ll j  Zz302~   L,p  ,jSl   itl
1960              16 0 JL <e A  iJ17 1930 J ,  i;  l
svaA   Di N   :-,I uDlj4Ny  !,L-  i,->-J   4j V: S :,AJI,  t- Yt ji  _  .1992
vs iU <IJz-YIj11 O- Jj%v jiLr 1975j 1930 U?5 $ 
A ~~ i~ j~'-~~ii A  ~ c~Ub .1960 ~L,JL-~j
j   L  -   z   ,J;l  JJi U_bJ      L-Jl *  u-
*,A~JIA j9J H iDCJ 3Qo~9  J  iJi  L%We 41lJ, l;
)J L   j JI   I J   j; 1992, 1960  L, o ;,:l1 J 4J 4i 
.(T 1999   '0.3 Pv IJfJ 4  -  l)4: L a3 L  5   Wj
sY!~~~~~~L                          isSlLls j Oy zlb 
J1- J>b 4SJ                      > 9Iv  U IA!>$tbl:L 
--,WillW Ls,KI Js yKlj 1    1) 1 cL-Lc2-'   oI j-to>
,  5.3 ji  j iJJW < >. i  1.6-1.3 > U A 
,Iv L_21Ji  Lw!) o-L lIisij  s      I v  L--
- ! .(1999 zL4,1j  4  i   0.3 )1. .,il JiJ  J  (3JI
120



1992-1960 f > W   C   5J 2LR
4
3
2
1
. �  L Uj1                  1 I                   i I cs l  J.k
;,:a9L J,s L_ wJsa   :. co4! 1960 �L> L_1 -ts~>y  i ri 1Jl
.1992-1960
.11999) rf  11        1   , -:1
Lsei  ;iIz    L1   j L-i Y    J  1     - 1 
ZjJl   1 -J9l ,;>9 j9 s1ous
121



s 91s ,zy~~~~~~L5t i!, Jl %1-4 iD L91
3i'JI 3 e 1 - L1  WJi  I  ZpJ    1999)         -L zS KI
31 ;X1 H S f UX > 1 sy W, 1 J-Ij>1
~-    b    W-           --1
g yQ.~jB y.L~a~  ~   U,L-j 1   '1995 Jj)jL '995 _pSj �3 �)
'  } .  J  -I       j- "           - u  L      )6
ju-~l   9:U L, ISI i
122



II 
S Lt -s1                 1                - 1. 981 JA ii?s
ij, J!  FL4,-l ziw ovL 1 L  4-4v123
i~~~~~~Lj iJLli ~en 2-juy l jjy .,5-1�l 
o>1! +1  ,1 iL1 -9 JL,Yl                     L--
Ijs swi yi  1991     431  1981 3!  j- 18il s;   4
JL) jt5 'u1!991 zWL C7 fy L)      9    o12 
O_- L+UL, ji a;j;1  Z5,i OW_j (J2i,5_ :.Jj-j
Yw  ; ;JI )i 991Ca JJ,43 M! 981S^ JJJ18 ? "1981HJ
(lJ^}J '  4J!S! ,V<) J;l ?  J PSI>! 9HZ JF;SL)
As          <:SJLI z J;l ,> -i sll i123:



L~�I  cASzju.JI jJ   L            k .AJl
L<sJ     ,   .   1  o1    J    1o-   X2u
,,(13)I Li)   i   l   14-105 I6 JL 1 J ,i  J  o
' '  U 44 4J-&p (1998) (L.j;S t  A
. j Jui~  W  1 ;oyf A1.J�~ 1  ,  (4-2
LJI j -W        10~ 3 's i O1- Ll Li,:y .LI &,  j10 
)Ai S- 8as,l L)  1    L.     L, 10,9  492-1_   ZZC
Si~~L~         pP C2s il _.- DJz19 US zLJ  ;X9 94  z
zu 491 3S6, ,yl ~~~J  ,    ,j , ls '5(-
ouss  w ,, S ; ~~L5,ijl ,  >L iz ,L  3!,
~- UUJ         3 4J
124



l~~~~~~~~~~i
.iv;' l J'-f JyA'-- ijAl,1 tsw &WtY  t4�sn>:2 2 J L,jl
67,9          63,7           1 aS 4 ciU Ii
64,9          60,3             J         J o9    ,  A
61,5          54,4          ze73I 21  _     .         j
79,5          72,9                           & 
87,2          83,1                  j       ,  z    o    i4
51,6         43,9                       h;,;ekb2
50,9          45,1                   4eLI '  2�I ai    ,
77,3          72,4                  dli   12 L   i o   J-j
57,1          52,0                           i
67,6          61,8             2  KuY-4 i    r ,. t       ;
74,4          69,1                     JI        j zU)i63I J,
83,4          74,2                             )  ;
~ 5 a1 bt,J19.1991 �  ,43  1981      18 _ 3f>   L    Lu
.0,0001 s-.. - ~ -. Y   :- .83.532 S! 52.107
.L2 9L  az!araa: 
125 U               -   *Xf
,tk-tl UAL<-   L S..i ;J Ji4F ru1l_          J Si           M
125



J.)u    L    ~J- SI L 1!, L-1 o1,19 L-  I;    L1J   "-
i,1~~~~~J iSiI                                 j U  S o  v1  og-9  L,
jTi A' -;",i 3L :4 2 1LQ
0 -
8        _       _    _+    _-
6 
4.0  4.5   5.0   5.5   6.d   6.5   7.0
-10= ,1- -,6Ll rpz :uC. 2 22 b  eJ .:UL )uLajJIr 
WESHR) `Z yL- Ylj  4Yj Z.LAjY ; r Ioll jj`  ;Ip .jA,  ;1. 
j_ill, L) ;ljL-  ,ii LL,g bG   7            i       4j 3 :l 1iJ
~-j  .)  C!, U z JJ L.)  5L'J j-' L ,x  2s,. L,2  Ls, L  I
.(I 998)   L-<  1  i,  ,   ,-:
126



Y 187 e (2000) aWSJI $lY A;I ' 
)~~~  ~ 5 
r11 45lu 1j,, i>21 YI ,i         , i,6L
1>~~     -1; ,9  4LJ~ A, OW9  jUl siL s!H
;JI~~~~~ LJI J<1 biJ 9 * . 
j L.'-' A-LJI JyxJlj I  j   4 ,  *  L2  >
KL)1
ju5                                    Ai1W  ;1J,L s  1OL 
L. JI ,       C1 J!
L5S  EX  AIJ80  -cl!   JLffiN  3J Z\MI JLL ,4)D41J
J Hi li>! ~~~~~L- 3  S - ,iC !zi
.(2000  J  ILJ  l l
(16) ~~~  J)  LJ 6
(1997,,@\ J9i  >  JL-)l y 12
127



L1W~ (3Ji UY 4 LUl - 1 1 -- 
-JI,.)                       - iIs  ;I 
s-&.L, zs     JW)1 ,S i) 3!J c41i, 4, t-4Il 1  .yxJ .,i
o ~Ji  S  JA)I S 41S J 91  A, -    j.  A    o3 ALl
t5 t5i oS1 :,9~~.lgL   Ll   jj_ll zj   e 1  s,t,L I L   ,
.SuLJ t2-1 tM  1 jl
Lsp    JL-I)l  ji 
128~~~~~L1
j4J 1995  L-UW3-   i1993  �Wy)            -as' o Illil g
> sill JL&J(93-1990) " J            LU; =-" ;,bti �1j .(2000
< )1A llJ SLLI!(S1AIj 5L;1 OliJ-(1997) )T l-Y
*(17, .0.3 1  LJ r;-0.3 riz  J cyl 0.3
*W4    ! ze ,,-tl     o l9 -l OjA=l%GW_ 61W 
(tsYI 5yJ 4A s, J IL a_ u  L4- 91  zi      J
?~~~~~j.                  jj_         Z__l  1!>k __.1 Ul!;1S
128



4GLU    JXyllS.s 4,JI ?Jw -  i j� C,-1 S JLi ?' 1
,XS t+j  iS  ;G1J!"5tl!4u01,L    ll
j     ~~J                J  L-
L-3 I 1  ei o) Jl  I^ z  w;-,   I j  osIYJ it5..  1 9 1 
(,S,j 4JJY1! 4AJ JL.k 49 i;,   l  C4)J  , ;;
J -dQl � -!       Jl y4M LJ I   ,i  J i
~     J L~ ~L  -~ 4~J~3I>J l JJl- Jk
L-  9 (dWl >IJ ~,-il -j- 
129



oaKu 4  ;Ai      - 9  o  Uu l A
,j191x o41 Cje  !  .  9yl! i1! 91x~~~A.  LCjj
, -      3�2 u  i l  o  C�-+-~~ ,  Jli C,;J,I 
3tuly u1 Cje 2 Lrs's- j                  j 3�  . 4 5  o
,BJ jlL Z-l ,$ $L- 2 S
~~> I~L~U  t!L,U l WL4i s wAi)J U!y 4J!  3�21,J
9! rsS eg J JIJ5iJ 4l ll 91 lai-Jy
ji L-5   .,:,Li J) DL-Jl_  j ti 4J,eff  4- 3   e eio y  nj  (
eY I ,5  JiJi jL5- I-sl L .          c. c L: L2l
'-y        S-          .Ou1  i  1~   J  )yJl l  i1
L1~~~~~~~ cc#i 3�2le9  e<83 
-L)    -q jj            L U3
&J -Uic   Z;JUAl <^j> 9- ISL )jk~ ,FJL) Jb lJLIj  :.,LrLI 2j sJ
4icyl~~~~~~~~~- at7yjG        IJ9 Li 1 p1  -
- - Nl  ~-Jb^lJ z.L:1  4L:i)1 l;,1<  3oll_l<.4  1
J! .4,,iyl OSI Ji ,130l?i-4>Y       ;



I~ ~ ~ ~  ~   ~  ~   ~~~I
91 u  W S! '    <   3j U�) 4 ~-,      - } WI 
4--! )~- Jj ;  Jl A l 3          JUAIJ rl 4
iJ  oi-W L ) L:i-  -G 13
-- i
- mb A~~;JL- iu     Ai    ;1 *i ZiEl  Ju6S  o
JoXll vl-l iNJI,5k H ,131 ,s2I>1< >ll ll



L1X ID -1 ZL.sJA  I  L1
i ,>1 Ji ,csi vFi si J i f1j -I JL1
.gRyl S (S,u,) +g, Hv C Dl  y  66  jjl Hi4
JW '      -tu,LSiU Jiu~ -L iyLi ci u- s J Ci
2i-~l  jG - uJI
4  t .Ju)i eis  5        j-JI   ci   JL    -
-I ,w t 14  e14_,1-J jj::, 41i i4sIlJI  24,1 L4sLl
cA4 5LA+ i. UJJ  . jJw -,L, Ju
91                                 J HLsLA-O+1U1  1A i   I A 
,:,iA1 - >ji ugj ci . i .-jw  J
132



_S lS il-  j   -o   X JL; ji S .Dl
S.     4uL (ui Ji i    491 > i ,1~ J  ;1) 
j        LLuy5 
j Hui Sl 4> aM  J
13,
<g 4JL--  9   i8 5L<-  s J  L5-L y
W3 G JA ~~~~~~jiJ J:J 219 i*p;I I
Ol . Nl 951 ;w;YI �,9! ';,>+JI! DI9YS J < HYI ;,19J
;SUJs 9 3 4ffi\9JF JA A A1 DT <9S;JUYI!Jpj3 W lJl
LH 9 GS;. C1 CS Ol; G1 33 (v1J)DIY 



>  J     I As 4b  OL_.\a*::   LN  L4,�J-  .&AdWJI
.(1990 ,j) -   Y  I ow N   LL-4Ih
_4 oSL< Ul J2l a     Sl4      0-p zSl i).) 3 i-
CL i     )L~  3SS  CZ c�f is        'uo  U ; s
.; -pJlj J  IAy eti~,2' .~A J  ij.. o LJ I ; L'- Sjji )iJ -4l1
aL3V ,   <:IJJ W$d WL +vg> o4'L~J ig  F-- .QIJ c'LL,
cjL:I i  lJ, .              -L  !  ;  ,F
134_X5 tL            J
jj-I! J, zt"-I JL- I 4,Lj I ,,G1 5S L3 J, JI , I
',5J I iO!L-J (4S1'l   4;-ULJ  9  L:ljA 
iXL L8 jJ I8                    L)a 
zxj- JI- LI J-.  .1 a S      lL -   a1, 
W11 J>ll 3 J9Ql! L1 S-                jS' 4Ls  I. <I!D > 2
134l,S 4j2 #H    eL ij4



l~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~~- t-o-K   zjl |j-,- |   |  % |  R  
~~W .A~~tJ~  j >~~_I .AS 4. I �(i L~L5~
tz1 - d  ojlW 9 LLx:  2--,- Ll,IJl  _U1 i  isX L p  1 
Iu,> 4+s oU91 ~~~~~~, J   '1 kj  ' S~   k?-   'L i;1a  1
J  G! olll: S ,1 4_JID GU1 UJ  O1-J ZI-uhudl Jn0
J49                v2000 9Lp  1995
4.J1 \ ts;) ? Q,I 1   LS aiD LJL >C-ul - 4cJo
J     W4 L1  t . ?W 1 6i   e     -4 '& J�W aiU
WIS ai>>l                       YSl J- i Li 21  i Y11
J~~~~& ;4  ? g)  ~'J ,1.LeS,,
l    -& 1> 1  Liy a 
135



j ~  ~    cl J; ,W Hr  A     4 j�
J .zA-AJ I  c29 1  ';Z  '  W   ;41 l  -
. (1999           <a zj , - -  Hl < 
-A' s J~ isI _ Li                _> J - Sl Z,jL
L.;.UU -,: u   L) Zj  
(1998)         4,j )  jU J. , i JL s  -1
.(2000 sTg 29>% 8) o1 a 9  '(1999
-I ll bl J l  -  katjyl if-j i~L2-91oc
198 5W A  A 998A o         tS-
136



YJ               - J<3 (Proxy variables) i )IpU1 JAM
il.: P-I1 3� , 1   .1995 Jl 1970 C�WI  J
jl,'-j  -,LJ 1AS1 J9 11l -C\~   -;uj l)j
Uk -  iA -1i1 ,JI  ZJI z (2000) )lL,-,     -4
Le  s   j        Lail J 1        1+.jy S 5'W C A
ai ?T;oil   1 4i191 &r 5L. >n ,   N  4i (1997
,iL1 4J9 lX oDy JI 1;; 5XJ (Y41 YS1 4 (2000) ,1, S  j ,l
_ 9 ( OU�y    Ji) sIWl?LSH         J    H
A+r,e W_Y2 1 z2000,A, -_) 3E i ojLc     ;j,4
.(1996 W 2   1998
-,4i (1996) Q,. -L-j i,-i4 J) (1992) UUe  ,uy  i  -5
(1992)  :,U  (1999
Y4j i _         I jc ~137  4-1
, b~~~~~L6J              -   i, 5 .   ,4 , zJ J  1   -6
L5  L              j~~. LI 'uj~
,<YSj  (1995)  <9j J-  -1-   ieJ  . Lj l J oJ 
..4Ls ~  j~ jjI .X ,e -- ,L1999l) z
137



aal 1L>41 4+-  , %  ,L!,:l L J Jc. bLi  L J  -8
-Al     ju               kSr1o J -  UL
a   & - l  o5U@'    >       ,UL U3JU j 
L.9 ->- U  -s; (1994 1J   < vL,l r-L.  j 51
(4 J 1I
^ 1 s~~~LiLc,      k     J) i4 (1996)  i   -9
-JI~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 10l JIiY 
~~.,-l Ju ;yLUI ,jiI l   U' lZL,aL. Li Cj1u LU Jlj JL,)l
1970  � 1, 2,n JI ,.yGl o   )j-  (1985)  _  ItJlj 1  -11
(  L7 ) j  J  15 Lzj  U, 9 Ju)   -)U
"Li~ 'TJ+f~l ,A�l" a (1998) jlAJ J-<l �1'  (  JL. -12
j-G  I-L   JL,.yl �-  ,3 ;J+ &J+;f  jJi,, 1.6
L71 (1995) _A� y 9 01 Y! 4  O  JLL -
j�S. .91 f J            A  j1!5;{1
;J991I1996 J!Le  J<l) p  iXJ Jj J JI @1
.(1998 J
138



-13
JviY' + # .   " " 14) 'IYI     "�     jF qUj9 4i -
cj                                            j. 2  C   - l  o  :- u
,A Jf &ALi oUI .-U    �NI Lt\S'!5M      S
*i-Jils L) -jj,:  LJU -                          i\ +  %  9  -14
.(1998)
5^         tv e oi98 uA \<jl-~  (1998)  jL-< L5  -15
Ajn 9% z\ ji Y!  ~~ji% Lo  -i L3JI: (1992 t1986)
.L5^ tv c\l J z M 2-2 J<-j
J=+L~~~~-.U     tj- LJ ) . JlJJ ,<, e<         -16
* ( 1997) J    
J>Jj ,b '<" :Jt Jx ,<tJj "a2J"ZL "  sj,> l;FY,,S i  -17
9 Si ji~U i,  uoi jKy;\J    J-e 9   Lca    :,jU
-N   JJ 1fj J<~L4l  *J "L >J <yi Jj i  3   U
jL<y    Js ial L~: "a;x tvi L-  a.j-,  cz,; y J1i39
,? 1                       J>$ g OLiL \v ,:,r4 >J+t f  J
.(335 ,,1997; R!t Y 
139



i
I
i



IWIW               I I c
9tattj                 f
9La    vl"
6i  41-



1  -  -  yl  DI  YL)  I,              LSJI  O S-  - - 
JL-) .6>;e jj1 4l6i11                 -  W
i~~~~~~~~L s~-- .ic jJlEJ 3 J ;5 i1,olllC4i AI1 
.g 1S J9, v2Ji;v i Jl ._ .J < -1 JL-)
4-jU1 L~ L4sy JL-1 Je J_14+  1 61oS
-LJ
4LIy, al�,! Gv Lf, S U Jt' oi*1 O aX JiS$ XJY
,JI ja LJ L.   . JU      95
-L .;ibb L-;, JL_-  2-mijdi1   Zze)l S  tixY  + Hs o1
.91! .~;L; J; I  AN  gA   I  !U   y   j
~~Lj ~        -IJ J_,   st w-  s:  2-1oOt  !
,jj-LJI vblJ .  i il L-II 51c  li  1   -I ljl--lj  CjIj
J)i 20                    j j      i
L.-U Ij' .:I  e)  4J1' J) J-jIU )L,   -L !  I L) J-~l ! J  -1
LLaij  -~z, t1'j1 L>91  C;J -,-j*- LS   4 A:P1 4u5Jl 1950
4U ;lo; &--L  0)L1 X-LJ jL, JJUJ J2Iby -Us-, J>-A, ;
�G  2000   cWI L)'Iji Lj    ,-s  -)L u LyL l L"   ;.Ll ,.), o
142



LO~~~~~~~~~.oy ,)S jji , ot 
45-_                           ZH  J<!1nly -;l-uy 
Js,1 1 ,<yl ,~~~~~~~~~~ Jij  -Lr,  X  -v
SS5 ,-     'ri                  LL-  -i L}?
Jub: 4  JieDpXJIJi su ilr 3  ) 
-~ ~ L yl   u j ,i  i  ll  i  llJ y  i
Jli ;IJ: �si + JL' riY4 !e .Lss-L u<I a-
,YI 5A1 y1JA1 ,5 ! ioil ,4 JiL  A ,2_   U
143   +Jb- ji 



?-x 'e5y1 4.Jy (,YyU! t1~ y#! L1 Jo1 91'
-IeWJ( 1199 j Q  1
144~ ~  ~   L
5      5l
S 2;ul!  200 ss .PT uln6s zte J-P 0Jnl9  a  91 1l
~~~~~~~.;41j U2jI slSJ 4JJl i:,JL; < 5!.)rA ,9!o
- J;pl a3! .o i-uJ I I  I  Li,,   .(sI -3   ie+
.(2000  -Sj   )l)J +JJ199   LO1JH y
.(1983 J Pg O?_1X) U1  l  o1  Sc o99
1  H zIJjJI JJ-  !  .(1998 :)l?J  )Ld' LPL. 'Al
,- G1,1(tJLa  oL) 4tJj Io     } S    1 5i ;J
Dljl Dzyl:S-1 3 ,^LU i,  --,  5,ja  j  1-7,0.'
,l wizSl:,jll. i:JEeYJ .' (1998 3~ OL)*-il 1995 ;
144



*&X4U yl J>l. ef
La    s  t~"J_ w4  J*.lg sxJ l SU 6al!   J I JI  -Qt as: 13  � l
JL'9-)J ! LJI 1993 j 1990  L- ZU   W J  J I i  Jl  cIL;
Ji (1998 j~_qAj s_j@leJl  el .J    11+1>    J4 
g 6     A1 J0  ; ak.  yLJI         JL-3      : I
ji j, JI .;:L ; -Ji        �J4j ,! S     J:  W .JfI
JL )J;, .L1,J :5 .(L  Ail) "Lbj <j.)   GJW  O]8,j
j4'.~~~~~~4
<)JL- J;l- sJI  -j o <vj 11fSj .(jL-J 0.99 j JJY J:IJ 0.85 J
jj-4l- JL-l j?   eAL -,-l )Ij lij oLI,$ ;-S  > jliNJbl
.(JS J8! s0.60 z  l ,       J <   l ,i,       iL
,9iiJ60-40, E  h    !<>J S>1 Ll%!- JLJ yiLk 
1,YX GHI 11 ,  1  EaUl C>z! ;1Lj  JU I J2~l .JjyI
1)   JI."  3JL   L+) eLs;2aJ$   Ii 1 1 i -,<j  jul,H  o L-Jll ji
145



~~-.l  J   JL-)Ij  --L-J'l  ;~~~~~6  04  U
S;-a9J 4 J+2  LS4L            I
.              -4  l.; ,4 I &4   ,'-
0           20          40          60          80          100
(1998) ~~rU       LL      U 
J J~-i ~    ~    JL-ji ;A~         L-Jyj JLU) ~>.
.(1993 @')LiJ 1'J2'~y            
146



J 2a-U 54 j Uy~ j a-t 71-  J,'j 
;jy JAAi >3 o;l ;liy JJI lJu  4ju4! j)ll W3  As JJ 
-     3~4LJOi~-          -         j   36iA 
S~~suzi ~  c~J-i j  j4 J
61j,995    -U 82j"147
> ;9 ;1 ,,> JJ  C:j .,1   ub}  rt3  L1Jil
cZ-cL - ,-   :.L6I z, L-yy   LiI  >   W
>1              L_4  4_;_4->JI gP1! 1__^tl 4Jw <Sv J tyl ; 5 >~~~~~~~J
4,>iNl J29\! +  J o1J147  ;u . J 



L"- L6. 1_91J L".Jj  L6,-  ji , j J-jJ L) 3  a , ipi  >1
*(1996  QS) O,1Jj           JAI5,l    0_fflyl  9 I C 41 Ii 
->'L,  1  L oss1 J X1 jx ;91 C J;l jz
;vI,9w Js o yj, aL1,, a t+! 91f9 
:L; Ja jL~JL 5-JjJ .(1998 E)LzPjA ck^~  c jjw) aJl I:SJ d,3 oJl
_ l    Jios j1 �ij    5   Jl  .i LzL  S L t J .s , Y  1J
4,,yl~~~~~~L     as- JvDJriljG  _OW  JIJ
C ,9-X .oL5L - lzj ji _ ;L  44
4&1~~~~    c -  - IJl Lli;I jJJ L-6 I-j     U;,
S .rJi 1!  ~~L LLE     p o9 -            _ sl -1C-  PGb
148



I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I
U     UJ .xiW o1o   Y#r91  LG J >y�3 ;s1,;1   JKi~ Lgi S 
? 49-91 se@1 �L1 alwi S H  A  1 4 i I . 1 t1 Oa
a ~J ' ,I 91 1915  I       AjI0
;b~�~ ~ LL~ ~  LU u~ j~ AL   -t4 L 
31 - 91 419~~~~' JI  ; vJ J JII .R4U J  ZiL ,-l  ,sI o;i
.41 DyK \  2 LJ 4,>ii fL.~WI ~$< W -  J ,I I  _Jl
U ~~U,U .o f J YJ1  ~,J5J j9k a1I s)  -#-
,L-YJ~ 1,;1a -tL  -U@1 4,-yg 1S L zl
IoJL j43 eS Jb   .zy93 1W  4 !
L)  1I 49
41_^,N~~~~~~~CL) OL jy   j  - i ; iJ9  L1 -
,? JI �~~~~~1   iEs b soiXlw1 Al,49G I,4



,       L)               )-,, oJll  C_J94 Fi -U>i C tG_JI  w -lzi L1
W1J6 9, clzi L> 5/ .e jI J  - sFJL 
jEl ,r4 5J          j3 jqWl L3u  *4 i  L  199 >
~(~8~L )LL)  �,~  ,-~  i- ~  ;~  4-uJ  -L;i
Us t"99 e''e sXLJ e3   &-J jK9 (a-y >+J!L391 J+I>  L
L)   .La-Y  j_   _s ]; iW Z  j1i _x Jyll,   ; rd 
(CEDAW) ",i Q; I   I U  L*   'Laa   -LI,,~10L J ) ;
- i it J  jtl  4XJ 4X 5j   ."L- ,U  ok  j-d) l jUts A~ 1979 tu,,
,(7j~~~~~~ 8i oj-Lj )9 4JLjyl  L)  y lf  p-
J$ X3 <>i 51 C1 ;? Ijo ij1) , oJl_l >J -JI -L JI)  I 
L3 ,;Jlj (1  -4L-J  j DlWj  *:1, ,- y  ., ,J- I) i2 y   I j
JI J<< ,! .J6 ala ;.L"I,"1 4juibt L!L iJIo
,>191! i1984 cj - (f aS zL dsl uA e 9U w>Lc JIsX -L- -L,
L~~~* , "199  Jel rLc i< on p oo 
? 4 Ij t  -LiL  o Jlj  Ln- ?I L,i _>   u)  J Ji  5~ 3i"; L5L
G(7 8JI1JI) 4I f lxi ,9,1 u U1 i50JeL J



j, jy       * 1995 C "         oi iLl
-8, JY ;,.slp 1995  L,u X  nkp "   -61 t-5, ;I,-Y   j ;J -
46 <-!   j_NLs  L3 J ;I  RIl  1)- Ay i
-9.(19 97 7
<91)~~~ o      lrl !iJj) 165  cD 2000  CSJI 4\>,u
~~S%L~K,  j -jIj -Th
<L.L-j ,J  W<<   <>9oil -I           G~O
e)>j 43 > < X;�Y ji sjj 31 i (1997 ;ol:   I E l)
-Lo22~~~~~~~~~~5 I..  w:S 1-1  )lJ9  4   IJ
151



jiwi;t;-tl ~      ;*-Wj:mJ1  ) lh A -     13 J
1995 ;4jUl 1,L6 vyI              -I,Jjl jL-y
1.00                       1.00
0.95                        0.95
0.90                       0.90
0.85                        0.85
0.80                       0.80
l1997 -  9199 o1 
1.08                        0.8
1.04                        0.6
1.00                        0.4
0.96                        0.2
0.92    *                   0.00               U
L)     j,l vl ^1J^1j                    J+
*iAl~~    ;3Oll L)vglJ1  Ml  j_,<P4'S' i ;fLl   cL v U ZL _Wj rS P  >
A 2.33         .(I. b i   (1992) U; a  4 100 ,. i
r3~J  -I jj-,1-1   Ia;l )ijc-   iL   jt }Sl Aj 2.67  jic.  ;
fti2 :-Jl   jj J~  ~i  U.',- Wi    :.y~.*J~~
i(1998) WISTAT  1,, O     ;(1992 )  ,A iL,:J15
. 1999) ;j-& XIe ,tL< -J <
152



;v6 8rC Y Q 91 J  f7 L -�1 
-I L1 tJLc JJI oL5jc  jj4 ,  jjjWp  4  J  l  ? J 9
~~~j--  L! p 194 >   L"U-  js;Ui  oG  "!,u  J a,1e3ojll 
j 'UJ al!,l j1zsJ  e1  ls1o     - Wi
,U9 )Li lzbi     YU 1; >-s!(JI9 
iuyl i  4t_yl  6  >  4y 153e  9 j9lJ



jK9 i .? Q lujua; es fLj tl 4t15y  oJs J9 J% .(1998 j ) &12J
UJI L>YIY j-4    J jz 1950 �W, U H j Q,G
~-'--~ (1984 jj  i1985   ) o <XJ 4jWJ1IJ L:AI)J WI  g   :
91 JW J     ,   , Aa- ,  (7)2,zyl Js ra1 -,l7 u4 ,
, J,zi -, Wc ~A~.oVc Ui z"   o  u-  v   JU i c j_
j~~ -~~'W  ..aU ~j  .,-J  kja JL2.A  L 
)G-  t  >   W l jL j;# i,j Sz JI_ Je ULc Wy oAlloUAW
(8) 1 IS   ;1       >l,,tiy  J<_ lw|
uNb u A~Ll 200     L) 4 1!1   Fj>
.J-U             L'5 WJ1 -8 sJ ; Jd by J)
LL_   ) .(199 jJL_JI  J 3) iHJI (sisLi e! eA   JL ,  o D e15 4
&A     ;- ,J I a*,s sj :L.:LI i?j_   ~,cLf  pC 4 eJ!
kjul  e teL_JI ::,ua.i  .:,! ,e SY I -i  J ll!eI_i  Us  4V- L)
L)~~~~~~~~~~.SD jAkl  L
S4 ~~~_~ lX ki L<, IS  j1s 
154



LJ    s              Ai 1994-1960  J
!91~~-Ji     JL 3: o-zC, l ,:,
(1998  Zij
4bs G~~~~-- 1  1 ,5'  J 2      J         i19941 
4--1c�I ouf  LUi 9    4�ul   L 4l-J Lt LW
>/ ' )51 4J 4.'^ wYj  9 j91 9sJ   }zlX, 
jj -, 1994 -   Q-�J CWl Jj ,    4!  *9   Ju K  1994
;lEr      U  -iA      -  9    il JI I'l
;~Lt~~  ~   ~  ~4J.itU  ,W   !  .(1999       I 8   !   A 
4    v   es L .i .J,lj 4 i  j  -  Wj l-,  JW - 
Lpl E_ :1-~ ;SyU ~- , 9 ,     .Gyy i J
,i~ .;1J �Lo1 2,s Ki 1  *(99     J-f-J ;t4,
AJI oLs 'LL i 9~155  S1@S 11C 



zj gova > uSj,-6- L' L. L19 .(1999 assT '1998 4,3
H~~~~u L,-               AP I D$ 1 51Z D1ji a=JI z-JI
,921 ,RI H! ;4A11 4>yl f  i .(1999 ELJ ST jJ
oL jiN - o;> :1 i^l:ti 5
*(1999 )Aq-, L'tA!3  jj,~  )Al- Sj SEX,ze1YU
;X >iy LJ JQy  n a,\u J-A  Le
iL~~~~~~~~~~~ J$JeU  llY9  >J !%  v 
1 HsJy~~~~~~L    I  <!j,      J ^lz!ei
9 t12      a--1u 45, Ll,  s 1992  .X! 1990 oJ Jci
i5-1uyl~~~~~ ifLl             I J A ( j<!gv2X, t
,1996  Lc, SL~L ,  L- I >J ~,J n I  I  I  6 0 ,;  Li
63  1J   K       IY       .1995 Lc- a1 12,4
*(1999 J1  H)  l J   l.24L~ .L d
156



aIsSl @ s2- 91 X1 i � e e9l aY,            - )
;;�J_U LU1 g1 be JWJU =i .(1997 4j A) C<9' o >
Ojj,  ? e J 1 G, J1y jj1
;99f 4Lil irA o j;,4 J  ,Y 4�1.      D     ll > cZ 
J~~~~~~~"              L--   Lioi J< b y 
1996 cW  o     UiL a i 4                       U
J -  yl Cly~J.lXJl ,+_ULO _tyL yD 1997 � Lt s zU
Lt . JJ .y�1  I- LA            jlfr  Uu_ Au '-ua ~,
;1A       1     ,      D        Y i r l      l i UJ ~W 
(199       ;,-j  iS _   .5L  , i  ,y5j  Lje ,: 9 ,Si  JX L,)
L-u       J I< a- s ,6  Y' j
jJi �e    Jj       jr z 3u
.(1996       t 199723 Pl:ug<l g 5;ioSJ
~~~UU-                         js�   ~L2 >;Jl J ,ul4i191J
.(2-96 R3 5) L97 1JJ
157



i92A ij. N e LpJ i| 'Li L1  9Y sJlj _IJU  -j J jy
.(1988          ij.)J jru ,9U   _;; L.g -|Sz l  s5t
5jJj I    ;Y 5 4 JSJI 1,>11  .JIJ i  I S S
IJYI F GLCYI D\   1 L+t    I  L-1 L. ,j4 L5 Wa;.
> 1! 91 > ,yyL Ji               Jj.   41  Ji j alW
S~~~~~~~~~~L        L jyl a5.I JU6l  3-1 z-1A!.-1a l
J>ol gL-,~ 4a2-,a  J  r o  J     i  Stil J,.YlJ
.(1992 ,,smj 3 #)L4)
.0 !(999 L))Ij1  ) PY     -L-Jl Ji 4UL1 IPJ
J 2 slJje   3J I,rll Lp1 ,Qas,Q   J;L_)   L'i ;Alc
SS - Ji            Huyl o>> ! J! ? 41,J  -L<gl
ew1~~~~~~.,,J jy UJI S1_              u 65  1  1->oX  y 
li  45 G:I i     50 LIs 1?y  t  #C  Ji4  tEf
U* -5 LO--1 rs S S ,lJfJ        4JI 
158



o�El S&:AIJ 8ipi e5iU ."1996 CU j   zK 1
po� L~     ^1J o lS%LJ l�U S J9al-    1  JSAI cA4 O S 
- t:;1  - 4gb > -aA0  .j>   JL1 i s ;I LJ J<o
+ 'j,Xl I-SA  L.-7  a       Lu          +19
,I 893 cL- ;;  -1svL         eljf;t       t    jp .
(10)  O  es 1J? L-Xs JI JIj U (1901 Cwi J    -i
4?JI ;S1 UlJ AJI  OL W3 eJs pl G  ? Jlj I  -JHJ <A
e5  A '.11! 98 SiJ 4 jJy   J2.z J  JL-  J  1!
(2000 <4,&   ify- 'I lSTAT 1998 S)1 Y$ J;JLA ;Jy  L. (4U 
-,,,J I   J<! ;HJ  l p I  L;~  Jj  ?e  J Ij5
.- N- 1 , j,>  JL) giJ  sS   S      as-)d G1SJ GLJI\ J
t <;,\,;y~ ~     l   ,   ;   U  J2,a1  z sL5   1931
C  <3-Z l:II <1 ~~-Jl aJ;I �1 -;L;I  I JA�S  )S  13
.(I0 (2000 JI,l Ji  WISTAT 1998)  i-44l ui  L     S  
159



L&s3so'I@ 2 j�
.8SJI J DL ji ? Xf ~~5 ;11  v9i- JLL-, YI L
ejLLJI >S jaj GSJI - u  --    ~ 4, L) 3
,391 jyS1! 4p j ! 5  x
91 L- w -21 slzf i!L1Al r-  ;l jw 3~-IIl Lju1 0
,; LJ i9 ,  & 7�f! fu ,,1 <: ti vfa  iWR,-'! 22J 0
j-  IAJ 4 L1 J)I  "1Xl  zj  j  B  3
.ifL lpj il. P,tj i! -I 
ji  LJ- -L"   '4; 1 'Z1  a e  s
isjji~~~~~~ a.� OLJ l  >1 j  SA L 
1L60 Jf ,J  fO%J- u+
Jj                 uL)  c Yp ,<-c J,S,;iJJj f5 li J
t�-  Al8 j  ofzL  ^ -JfJ160y  --



Ic-~~~~~~~
I, ~ ~ (I
*d ( oT L t ~~R C                 -c
'  s E .e e' S  / i , t  t            ir.



atfYl -  as ij.-  al -- S!,yJ41  u
:11  Lr <L, J,A 1 >S1  i L IC.J oSLJ  4sN IL  vI;
a-1.  JL j  g  J-JI  O   f L36   IJ - >LM LL_,S1;i p .4
JdlI LA J,Ll Uo) J  AL! J  fJ 
4SRJI;91 OJLI~  J.''  o-Jls JJ p S<J41  1
-  .(2000 D1 4L > GJ) L, I , W- J D Lie  i ;
Kr1   ; JyI GL3 .  LA !UJI JJi
.,4JI ~ L' ,  J L;Y  9WJ--Ij<e 9il JcD l   J
O191 Ji -J  9 ,p,i ZJ%I'j jj-L Y O -1 LJ!5
v~~~~~~~~~J-J .(2000 ,L. L,X LA-  -&+1 i  L 9
,9       ~1       L-  -g l j~  'j   21L y
162



p .&S1 ;W 4LuI>JI  -1 3 C,L2 aS JL y~ S
g-9 <,lj SU o1 f isO,        $ 
J~~ Li
L::,1 D aslzJ  b  .(3-3 jjU-Ji ) -W yi  u  >O
.(1971 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ (98  ..JA
;   ie 1  J   !4  1  J4 -J Ij -16
1  jJA  GZj5219 S ! .171S)<<X  IjiJ .JU 99 l
JS~~~~ ~~~              4'La -llH  3>u!1 zr:J  !.1-7jJ
i i;L_ ~j  A,FIDjl )  i J4-, 31 ,e
oLX1 S usU1! up1 S ~~~~~~1 e987 SoJ
163~.+



6'iLill" :3-3 a
3lJ;)4 :,JI -,2J-  �9 I1 <1  J< 42 j1  > -   
�~ J .LWI vLL JiA W-g ~.ut ?  cs u I    Ji rJl9 JjL
.(2-3
ot  > Js ,L< -Li .;-L JL<L .zAI- ;I144 <,y 
-191, 1 sWL41A i22l. JI!  JK91   j,2  u 91! ; 6IY
Syl 1 jI y)2JI 1 1 e) A~~L:L ,>1 1e)i
- -3lJ:j        1_-1u 1;J~ _5i JL-   U) As LJ ;JI 
9 Li   !     k; Yx  --1,1  C  s J  ~~ uJ 4j I) I - e
.(1997 X3J  J
.,X1 z_L)i     j  J j ?sl,1>  <e  < 5T LiJi 
-C     4- j El j  j1 7 . eCJs ij
jl 5     A l ao  )! HJl 4,-. j
164



6,1ud WA ,        9u -i k1 nJLi :J;l  9,J
Z     GS     OJA 291W - 4iJ I  j  o 1 
LJ,  I       L ,; C L-5  i II
U! U j   -U   L   -  1) 65
oaJ ) z91 L1 iSULJ uylDS Sy 4s<A1 -  O ! Ui 
Zs-      S1J Gj3       .(1975
-  J- Yj .~(1985  &---az1JI  p  ,9i  '1  s
>91 J <1 W nrYI ~j ol L S  5L.  LL.Y 
1! -L;                               u iO e -  A5l oia519jjs
-,L-C   JL --     ,-  i s I   ai- 4   L  -  ,i  e e -G  i..ll ij,2 
; j,L - ;.9 -A                     j
; Ec! 5  <! �9 , JSl <:-sJ eS <! e<11! ~~~~~~~~~~~~J-J
i;X_ JJJI G- � 4+1  165  u!;uC     < J



Lzl1.) ."<b  aai- m s , JL- cl  9   i,
'~~~~Ljf .J89je8jiS  u , l   oo ,
,WiJ ,i? 4 4s>1 LiL-yl J              OLli S 
i1  i  -+ ~~~~Z jm lb -ieJ1       2A    (lg
JL-eul )         -1 ---- 9~   ,. I  je~i .~ 4&JU- l 
>! *(1999  Jj rY ZL-) tyl ,- olLllUs A  -iJ- i+ lJ .5 }AJl
ZL.L,l ,  o LJ 1 ) alLe 3u *: ,2SI  j 9  157  A   'L1   l
1999                   jj-W "Z* Z-, n.3  L--u 4,j)4 >CIJli2  S  lxi
>3~~jjL Z clJJJ iLsl ,8yJ  4J IX>:l1j  !(383 z
w:~~~~~~~~~~ z1 L           s      J I S  :i iJ L-j! .ZSY
J -I  j  > GSYL:LI 4A,- > 3, 4,L1 JF J,Xl  )I -aY
Sl 81 WLC ,- SI J - yl 9, ,_491 ,3 ISA~L 9  9y
s 5 Y1DiXC)-_;9 t J r ,;?! li,k
G11 ,ro ,~~~~~LJI        .s -    J     zifkj 5-4L BI  IUU
9! G9~~~~~~~~1 .a~          4    LA ,,S!.ll?v ejJI_ i <JI 'S, 
eilJ, 11! eoUnl4l ,>n1!  <    bj,:,cU  OA sP
.(1999 1;*I) -L+ a
166



J-1
P ~~     Le
1990 g  -      ) L6  JrI4  .  plml  LJ u
z, J,xl J s iou1, _4 >j .~)  aj- 21, e  - 
ill , L     )    IJJ J4?ol
-0999  l L~W ~LW           m~�J
i  1_6Jj 7L1
L5 ~  .L JJ 91j! 9 
;1 11 J i ayl ,3 olJl ll Sy1 ~~~~~p  L5 y e--Z 
wrnAI e1 Joplwn Y4 lJ ,M1 n ojll 1  5-s2
i Si .iJ >c Jlj ~167LJ j2 si->loWS >



~~Wl ~-L ,, _> ~jL JLi�s Lt  L_J LLe- J  ~U J
91 > S 11-L.I    L)6 _4pJI  ,L1   - 'I  z
JC   (1999 J9j~, ~)ASL) 4ljJ  U ? sP. al (C)1JJI  998
J1;1  -- yl J~lJ b c klT 2 _,j_  JJI *_.e .: ILJI ,aI#il _L 1~ .;LiJi J.
a~~~ 3JI .i3L L2I 2�i Xs4  0. 4j-u-I  91  S   >�  L4 +
09 D->Ji            4&.ij  Dii U   l Sl LSLI
iZlb  1 l   )1 jIl    J .j .Cl 4--U  e  Cli .L
Ki.wSl WH ?                    -b  j i,,  >  ll!?
1  .6 8tU
>L   (1L)9L                j,-   ,      L'lOsl ltl W
.(1994 &
,_rk  H  4'!s Lai- siS j-yiH  -   el
168



~~~U          ysL t Aj�JI 0A- i_L$J Sy Ji a,,t. lJ floyJ
o1 XwJl j ~        ~    i 1    .I 51 -bl L-
-1 y~4s     t     l ci  ,L
-4,1   "     -U z J  Jii L  t       J .1996
- i  -   -S   I  a,Si  S vjS  >L-, "7 J  JSI  g  , J1<L  i
_ , lW-y C6U LaJi l7 W 5 
JA   A      AL  * S   Ji ' A }-s ' J! iJL-i jYts  o L5
*  "7 JJ  ,11990 ;11980 W  ilJ     . 
L--- U1 \1   i            _, Jj �je1i)S1J  (1997 * n Jj  4Xt984 in
.(1996 z)Uj sf 1989 - zIj )  9;II  H;J
W AL ~           i    f cI I; DG 9*ay :WL2 OL o .C-A
O' CjI        j !;     *(1999 S)L-j, plJ) OLLQjj
L,'- iUt.a4z L      5G     :L,-JJI 
1694 5i M             j .  aL
J .Hyl~~ J i s1 ! 621A1 (X
Clyl~~~~~~~(3 Z      ,D   -1"   l i    JH- 'iW
169



cJ~9 U  . 1 j   L4,@ - 1 j4  }WI! J> 9JI ;J  AI
j--?y4  '1996 c1985 ;AU_ )Y& Al) -Z)l~ #  l  ,,iQj  FL_Jl
�J9 a-s >1�;J!iogUS31 w -i (1999 L1998 'l)a  )jA 9921996 jgx
91 Ji S  J -,l   2--Lj j jLl 19 - im aWil 
~~ c~~W~~ ~~LL  ~~~AI J  IJiI j9 ~~~~~~LL LAJ *;-, ~K
- 9 9919 88 JL�i 'j JjJI Aa-i\ '  1  L <
L;-JI 9-JI z3JIA toil  1il S  i1 s j?L5
31 D  -  j  C41 DJI  - l ji INI.2 ji  ,j-L  W  fE -JIl 
.t 9I9 i       I88  L9 J IWj2  L  U LJ
i:#JIj 5 1 o1  j1  L<fQSs 9  ty 
j .;W;
J &I ,gl  ;-i J - Jl;J  I  l ( .:A9  L- Uu,
j ;-.A1 J<   i U53Ol, U z  s     .30 u
170



63I)>J ~lf  3* jj  14 12 _  !,  -, GIjJP
IJPs,-i 18, UyJ ,y J 3  8 a 5 4A' ,9-' :J
12 ,  J              'L-A -1       > o  4,-JI
(L4) ( 999  j )  , , 1  L.� 4
L -  L-. tJi
JSlwL  w55 i! liGoiil9 AlS ~4<s  4SE jlA(1999
<, J DJ 5 o191ALJi c1  J-L- Z<i G5a  D,u  iLe 
jLul j ~,:'I,,l ?
,~� *)s & >i 4J u        4l JlJ 3l W)U1L osII<  i l
;1 11 &i oU 4 l W9Xi L$.1 (,2 9)<E ;-l:l 39W sj;)
.(1998  (          J 1994 J5 .(1998  > .L 3  > 1L1
o> 44-i ojl>=l,< (+i z1-S)  .(  1993-1969 ?
\J.<lC                          J,& 11D 4  >}JII-7
J  >98 4 8j (+i~J  9) 29 j,6  -
Z--   ' j :-, -L---  eJ\9U  W3! .(1998 �j)) il.3 4  p $
4U v Z~~~~~~~i jIs)     Aj  LJI; _4t sl~  _-Y 
<>;, . !  S; OW! .(1999 j ,),y     XY
.(1997      ), 
171



di A 7y a+1 SH  9 Ji v  aSi LJ  -
C~�I c               4_J j 4     U jU{ o- 
WtJl JJL+ Atuv yul ,J -   L l 4 y o   CA j,6,- j
J  1  P 1 t)S a,9 X -;JI! JJ~~L--jI L4o, JA I iiL< ir lAj
�J~~~~~4AJ jjij te -)Lr '! MS  JU ;. 6 ? 1 ;L-, I.rL
>J;jl ,Au) Za,  U1jl   1 .ji 'Jui >z Ji A -Ju'. L)
L-., ;1.i J.,Jl L9 LU21 JXY   je .JU  2,L, L) o
JLI 4UJi 3il 1 i+1 !zyi .* AIz C1 LC- IJ -JYI  -
,92 4  t  l o ~Ji   LWI J ixj s
J~~~~~~LLI  42J ~,JI   4I15. tIA -sopl 21,, CJlc 
oLLW ojLJ! SL~ ;,�J -, 39J 49 O1 24 y> J,i1)y
3JLJ &iJ LL.)l <v L! Gjlf4 .jULl J oWi  L.�) 9U9JI iwY I js
d-L,Jyj cu-5ai & CW JW,l ju~u~ ~j ~ l~
L       jJ172  LUa _?  O-LJ
- .11 > ,> _9>e,L1 u tS1 >z, ss~~~~-  -   J ll A
;,51 o v W~~~~-LS-  L",1!   L1 -L   t,UI   .91-J   Uau1  ?,
.(1999 l8;i)JUiS 41 l0A pWJ   LJI   ?
S1i--  cL4i    L- _5 29 IA         - Jy J  S  n
aSi ~~~~~-I ,-  _ L!)  u . ~   j S 1  -WI 5J ?;8109
? ;a;JI AL UL<, t4~ ji ju61 Lcl 4JUX iSJ Lls  nC} -~
12 ,1z1s1, L1              <^xf L LF
172



j,-~  cz>. i.l  i , &A Y  .(2000  JASi  3  ,   j,
4g1 X-~ u i 5 J,- oU%iI  oW91 4   :,Lcw j  6
91 <, j) 1j _0t2           ,,y9 , 0.5 aa9
*>1 9JJ0.24 uX +8w
.a :tYI z1- t�1 4 dtpl 9 ~~~Ji  9  1 J9
J .2Ai .(2000 j  -w�S d999 lj t  JL-}. f  ; ,�T LJ3  U
4 3 -4       O! SI ej~  �% OiJ yY1 J; ri 
*<:,- L_4d LJL,J .)\Su  4L, l   OJ lj JL - 
.(1998   ,S)4 l;    33        JLXS. DY, l 2?e 
4z,+2 4 U o     )JJ O1ii o. 4 \ ii .Xl Ji8 34S1<:i
jA  j,  j
G4s0J    S15 uyl  1  1JL WUI cA5 JI J 
15~~~~7
z-Y c- OUiD L5UJ 64 WE  J Ji  1 I CDt <
-t-J >!I  --.UI ,-J I j v!, JY  J .2; <  O S jS .(.?99 -  .4l3
W SJ   P!-;ylOl ,1 ;i >W,Y .L >. 173- 



sLi:Jij J5 isL,.l    L"-jUj .5JJA 5 *,C,^g  LJ2- sJ cwl uaS
1 J Su 1 i 1 -- yl -! >91 A!-,JI  J s'-
.(1998 jj  JL-)l  =
i ; Ib!! YI o1 - All sIj >l f - <ua; L
_,e~~~~~~~ ~Uj       j    ! Uj  L > L,) zA �~L L5LC J J' 
j11  L 01,  JJ ,-o:       pjI5jfjlol        1
j  A L,9 g1Jul _U'-J  'L, Ji-i 4e   u-y,l C~ tojs l  -J
J I I A SS G3 *( J1 994  SJWJ)DJl  I14F_ Ol,j 
- L    IzJI jN I   J iAas ZL-JI iviisy Oo  -Al-u I
L) :DlO!1JJI9k              iJL$IjJI  MLLI
-~ ~   ~   .     i)2  (   o v
w)i<S oyl9- liGo>l i:il iiy Soi174J1



(x-i13 7)  ,i.JI  " Jf   9 .�U�-jl J. 1 l  i1J
65 i   uAl j  . > L     5j L- j   1  L-      L
. .    80s SUi 4     >>    C41 J =1;1  u4
L$73 ~                       I > , 191 uy4175.  Lr L,
Cj+ :ul jL2z<1 L-. I !-  )Y J    1< 1S 
~~~~~~~~~), 1LW,~    ;l1SHs1j+ g k 
.(2000 jlJ-ia)>1@J ) F_J
~~~lU 3_" 0X  Y     Y
.1~ Z,- 32l  A-4 61  L--U 4J>u OLrf-blyl O 1b J -H l *  S
*(1999  3   9 
i,20                               &1    ;!. L-
175



WL 30 a,,Yj . U  J - 'J -j  pii 1,Yi -J JU )I
~L�   1i.Aul j . L- s >. (yU  -J  ,  j-Il 3
y.MsI         2,L jl 3    - ,j i
j~~ "Lji  .O~ 4JU3 Zy  Wy              Zi u'J
9 , - ji z
OlJlll �       As ,ASj 2     31 J1 3j '- '   -
6(1995 ~jJJi  ~LyJi l  i-)~  Jz  dX  4j   WJ  4   j3  p
ZLC, Lj  J-l  S, al o  aj., L: 't  jj ;l  oYt.a Jd
.U2) ~      jjIA~5l jsS 1J 31  ZI dl! JJ,ylj
3_H1 5b� -! 4>1  ~    J o J W IL J I
~~~ ~~~  ~~~~-  o-A       .25  3
JJ3 t.I JyUl 9! .  +J )# ;5 ,3 Ji oE Jiy 
3      o    L.JI cJl ,y1'-Li tt icA Jjl JJ JI LL3 i L) .2-3
- r 40 5 Jl J�-J   >- tLU LJ >ii o  -1 
176



i I_rj .j'X  a 2 40 o  t'i Sl  J -,>t1j 2 
.2y ~ a / v  ;b ji (1998) , 4! 9y U>
~~ Jy- ~~~~~~ ~~~UY  ~ ~ ~ ~ 2 j  A, -L
J-       ot.       J+l S S1v 1J2
J v191  ji ? + 91 G yl -Z+1 @L ~~~~~J~ i  J/1v- Su
9� v 1 J~I OL Ot ~Ji L19 L Wz iJ
14-LW j L~ -i.J L)-9 
Ay- 12 L'- Jl l gi 9   -; Ji J 
J 1    j>~J >  198 vUi 4 u1 iL gI -,-,NJ l .
_:Ill Lss~ 
i  43 L  ,;d ,4   a- jij W.L  _,? -J --9L  j  W I
3 91 .1a 4i I J,+1 >1 ,iF;j JJ'77
t| ;199                     L ,  9  +  )!(1 JL 4)
j  >   Aq  Li> A OJ  ? d pi
177



oJIhL W        j     % &            Ji, p      2-3 2.3  l
S8,_ 1984
rJM 1986
u 1982
X,,f   1989
* 1982 ......,>1t
-.1990I
S4,y  t! 1990         ..- ------
YL~1995
:I 1991
v- 1986
1992
J?1992=i- _
Al 1985
1985
L 1990
, 1985        _        _._
1990
t   1986            I
211988 
L 1992                                                 6se     Lez D 
t !i1985                                                  >1t_
5  j1986
a_Ij 1986    _                  I                -
su; 1988
b--~ 1984/85
u 1970
*      A,j X     UJl tw s- *rl 91            z      L 
.(1 999) 3J-J               qI ,<i'1998)          L,     .
178



Jr 5U >! G4,2JI  za;kilJ siY  Q)ffi U J  bJW
e)� 41984 �1Wl J<> G Jw  , .(1997  5-  l JrJ sri! A< 51I
~~  ~   ~~-~~-'~~ ~U1  JyAJj I  
Jw Jyil ! .oinJ L 2-iu 54  L- LU -j 1998 l WJ L ;i UJI
Ua4J      j.l  j 1$J1  -7 Jp_1 G9 j LizI  U C,& L5 I r
~ Ui5 !91 sS K '- .K,j Sk (Si aS.(1998 Q)Aj -
42J iKi) j.2 J1 oi&Jl AJ T'jv�" <LjvJl 9 JiII �r~il L>g-I J
-1~ 3J 1JrJ-  C 1L,i  ,)1 fLi 3W1 v >  +
179



l  2, .1 - A ? 996 o; LH 1  ej j- Lj
LJ7I L o             % '-   .LL5U ji L1 A�  , J�
iJ!SI zia-js. cU           Lc y lL.
aUL.~ 4 1pi  iy.t5otu Uc X  j sL ?U 
�. y   - J2l       Lii J,91- XS1 >jl 'ji Li
45cu eejJeg Ja Csj. gcASL < 5U1 JW;1, 29Ul
,1~~~~~*xL ssWi JUJd ? JI,  (98+  6>znlCC
180~~~~~~~~~~L1
J  e J) ILi I 1 A 9  llel  1 - 
yl j,1 rtr1e  yL 
S1 .t DS Gy Of s Ac ~~.( 991o1?'8 ta Ji  S
Lt1*   X    l 4sl,  1   94J ;J tL<,-l  lI -olji :
-L--Z~~ W AI j  ,'Su  j  jK i ,..~  J;1 Zjol
180



j ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~I~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~)~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Ji 41 .ay~LL J- l U2Ji6 L- >i      19 L
' - - - LrA ;l~L U   L. - y  -   -I j-
C i tY             k 9 5  2J.yl  S 2JU1 ?~ 
s eyl ~~~~~~-,A         4 ,F,   Lf   - u1tE CjZl 
(JU~~~~~~~~~~~~~~21               91,L 1 ) z�  ,o1 GHy 1y
.(1991 JTg s 2J1 - ) )i .1997  jF 5s JyL ,4,s
.(0999 is s) 1     2L iz-l ) L 1 wi, w18
S~~~L LFDI)1!11s     1jy?el .                1
-L-Z J ,1 ,i 1j-Y ,,i ilL.--L ;J j Lz i)LUe wS1 
>S1~~~-0    9   3 :  s oW  ;A3   L=5)'  U F i ,l-  Z Lb
. (1997 ,J  )   .UJI-4,2   ,
IRI ~ ~     -~- -



,LI  1  g.>i J vi 51o o ,k u1 1  1 , cj1 
L-j,_5JL i -LZJ ZPL,j1 iP    4.+1 3L8pj4jYI e eLI
; ,61..fi JL<_c.l      : J1,-  j_d1siI>l jIb iJ .~JjJI Ub;S
sI,IJI J I ,nsi J  (Lg a-L-y U Jj 1.61_ 1 p J-L1,-y   i
.e) FU~jJI  ok   ~e  2j-,u<J ;yl S\Jplj
i  W. <:v1 .L  ull i O+1  LJ 4 3:> ,zy ojLLI, l
;~~~~~~~~~~U         o  -  l   L  Y   -,;-i! J Cii_JI-iAJ 'A  l 9y
,~~~;j-J olJlll      'L_d 4-  .   JI  Lr, L 1.  oJLYI �4-d
fI>:I JiI cif oi i Wi . '182



.(4-3 J) 
Li?u 319181#X~J 6% *A- t"
-q~ ~   Wl  -9a A, +UW  K
Q,�z~a. I o1 *i S1984  1 ,,  :U3y.Jy3
-W   l <   ! ..i   x   I   < s  } 19 495 S6 92!t 
: (L yWI  j   UJ-Ij )4- jl
!~~~~ LWI 199     ~U JI }J !2i a'
L)~ ~~~~2
J ol Ck :~~~~~~~191921 fl J 9 ) 19 
! (l 1.11I Z tu &1 !)~  1   1 . 
uJ~~~32 JU y u\         o1995
,S, S-191 o21~L JjL5 > 1999 �wl 9 yx1 4, ;i
.J':9   js             - ui jL y   ,9 1 91> g
&�f ,.rx 9 ci Q  aI -j-   -y1 83
183



C1 *1 S  .irlnJ;Ll  Swo) l  L) 4iJIJIl  J .J  JI -di :.,;.4s~JI  uJ JI
<v4 X11J~L7-;                            Si;9( uill_liJi  - 1994
Qi--;-v'  ,          J3-dijyLl j-,2 ' o1Je 1996  �L   ze@ j
?TAJI Sjj , . >>y iLdIj      ;     1 WI 2L Mt
1998 L,s,    j,i         j ZL  L  2  >  S9v3-9
uL1~~1 -W1                     ; S Ll   <Ja-OXSI 
.1 tvy 1 si a ~~8      !,- -L, fL, 1c,  . YLs
. ( 1999) ji-:.-J-; T 
J . 1 ji 1,L   LiSlJ I  LS'l a3 5191
L3 J-<.2l s;,L -Ji  L3 DE8 (1999 6L'-Jj?   iOJ!j
oI  o ~L 5--t -1776 �21,Jl oSLg91,1,  4!
V L  w-Al o;-L,yNJ  !G       sf
184



a- s         -.      lLl 3j ,          L
i L 5                   i                      tiez4J yJd uJI ,OX
~~  ~   c~~lfl ~~  ~~i�   ~~    4 jl
JL,9  siJI<1 o-L-Jll �1oji i  L <1 ... o_UL_l
jF 1 > olJlll 5~~~~.217  J _1996yl dJ),;
-21j _ Yi 4 1 � # (               -2-1 & J  J  -1
J� Ji~~ C! .LS Y-~ Y  91   }LTh jk2 j  *Vwx., 1 
t   J 5   ' Z &i~ ~ifi 'J~3  A,-51   Y}  - 2S
185



a_Ls 45~k ;-c y~j,-)                JI :. 1A  ry Ll  -L-1  -3
Jl 4(1987                 tU, Wi t1S- gia;r,zl-sfflY
4,._ 996 oy);IL-                     -A      &,iilu I
~~~~-I-Jl      1,L2t L5s! LJ  (2000   8zJC,_IjJjb
olJlll pHl  Sc A  _iJ�%>J 4,f 8  9,, s,,  (1996 Lly.
.(J jYt) L'l v 1 ol szEl _rm   
21 alA:  1  S<1 - 'lUl imUl Si~~~~~~~~~ I9 Io 
L 9 tS221 -ks" ~5k                   J4. i -4LIjJb_
4J%yl~~~~),"- 9JI   ,- Sl  _  -3    Il AJI
.(2)              "aA 1x1 .L. bfI3     4lLI4
< j jS                                                 p J 9 ; 1U -6
y1 ,  3>y46-l C1-ul tL; 13! 1A CL-J Z.-u Ls,# L^X -  a
w~~~~~~~~~541 A;J              o~,l jl-J-+I ZL<  3 Jay ijL5- 
.(1984_, F .j 95A   Y  SJJi;l     LI
186



, S 91 ,- S 8 "til J t1ji ,l            -8
1976 in)oU         lt     laal,e        @    $
is i1e t1 ji j,I JG, 2000 Ji,i- ILs '' I 
.(1985 ,,  lJ v,il,. _5 A 
O J C>yl ? 4+1 o\'S1t-  Oi ?J             - 9
.(1997 .1999) -i JA  N  ClJ,>     L.
U              2, 9 z , C>,;L)   j,   jI.5   -10
,Sl 9 4S1J:  ,9Jl  a =c .> S
i+- J8sYZ  I -            8,9  -)L  tSG  &S S l
.(2000 Z)La?8O()z:<\ 0o1l;I L) J,1% Jl b 
L) IJL)l          W &I ILIi  L-J Iu ji jjYI J-1J  -11
.(1997 j?  jJ ,>j1996 )_y^_ ~1998 
Cr U '~ L)S   -:'JI o  lYJ tJ. L) JL- Z, ;L-j,,I  -12
L J )  Ou.'   z  L)  L)8  5-L-j   .4)' 
l,- kl).j JSl JJ_l^ 01       L 4i5 o+
LS OXys 1b~~-,J       J    L  l   ,-<j    -S  y 13A
;lL, lil J e;e Ja1L100 ,;  18,Iil 75,,  oy
187



Aj jyJ    J   y'-l' v      j tcl 12 WuL iL4- , ;-l &JLWI
.(1999 ,J  aJ lic
ji -J il                                           -bLJi
~~~~~J J,j-                  -up y2l L )eo I, soY
59 -i, .(1994 ,j,   40-20  o     W     ,L   J.WI o
&& A jj       Zc. _ a. Lj I C_i LMu l
-ol  uGSlJ      jUXl    Jt . jL188
m syll O%JI {L1ji *- ! Lc - 
,   c,3oLll2.        ;i -   1;edl ,P      .(1998 ,T
A  -  921 ulN    Ji o:-Ll,2 -d -5--  -16
S9~~~.L;,J ,! i,-WI; :LZJ Ij SI zi,j-lil Y .(1998 )
,.:,JI 'j L1;-L-   jL,al, C~Ll,1 J-i,    o         20
37 -                !.U lL  vllJ  6l 7a U-" I L) L,  U,
il4J, Li I  ? i  _zSl  Z4 j   J L=S-        Ljl9
188



L 21, L        a   44 ,1~AU. JI 1Ja         j 4d
*(1999 A,4jSj Jef  ElJelL         9       Jz.
5 KSJI ~L1J~ i- ,5k ,        JI        �     JSS JL. -18
U ,,9 5   J,L, ,j 0.56  j    L:X1   .-, u1  -+
L,L9- 0.63 J 0.62      -J1 9  91  yl 8
.(1996 b  1
189 






,rf'fif    '      1,% eIo
�~~                  *   , 4
imw-r ir(,IiQ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~



41yw ~i/~ 5i~ ~~-W cAifJI jA! 1 U91 &kJW~J JJ.)
,Jlj JL)JK         L.! c      J- _ol ];JlJ f  }j
J~~~~~~~L. Jt L<-- yl  L_,J I  L J4y  J1 9  J I_  L_.Js I
y,�~Ji j1p 'Jy 3�i .(1999 &B.3J, jolh) CU  ?   JLU 9, Jj !
44J1 n-^yl~~~~~~j c}1LJU IL1  Jyl J+ L) jL -Y
-  tz 21   I, Lj- AJI  19  .1 J, LU L)  oUuS8! L5L,: 1 -L..
.(1993  J)  1J92
A98 -z\ lwJ W LSI vY)*LS<JI.) 91 ! ii 
4J}~~~~~~~~U 51c ? jJI A- (199           93u el JD  1)
> .(1993 J< ) 1 (199 atuu; o-J Jul: +i9<_>;=>  iJ
tSJP  ^.                                 L-JuX  L_.J bl  i 5 Dl;LSJJ  o oIz
J9 '~~~~~~~1982      j  i_sya iJI 1  >



J ~~~~ j
1998   19 "11  Z1 .J U  51 -i jS JI
Aj!4SIi,zl ~>iiJ2y jil9U =C iX Jl 19 
! .  Ji1 J1  y l, K  p2 (1999  % j -1999 LLiJ -1998
~~~~~~~~~9J9 A5      o .9JI 1 
4A. - ,o  uj   J               JUAl
4,'     20_)* Ul;.  ~       ~U~
193



X1sl 11Jl  l  !  oJll�=J2i-  4 sX1 R ..) ,yZ
'-L-jij oJLS:' J-O   J  I L-  LJ I  L,"
J;t >u   l e.4 AzaJ (z;S j3 J-� j4i .rYI bL.i 03
Ji~~i~ ~, WW  ~ ~iu,  , aj -
o>J21 J;)l; a G58 1l  y
j      - 11 a-  .Lh L@.,9I oSS1 tcS  !(1997 
LiC~ I                          C -
C,~A c ,, 1 4A$)Ij +1L  Sc Ol Je-I ji -
jiJv2JI9 4uJ,>A-f-  s  9j.4>  1  2>~  J1   J L,l
-~~~4UL JI.,sl 3S zv LJ~ xiJ -2r1
iLliyl~~~ j>y ,,iiJ i.  >L 3,,1  . 1 i  j4plCey
L3 Lel- <) >!      js9 J-+' l  * iL- 1
,L /~ L)  ,       "s2 L >- JI -  e ,$j ' �J :. ,
F1_ nl Ck sL XDJI  ,li    L;JId L) -)lp
-iJA ': Cyl -- ij "L.J  L-c~ jS1  ;ju1 Xc-  9 La
194



L~~~~~~~~~~
~~~iJ ~ ~   ~    ~    .   dz U! 91 Uy --
2000 M    A.A.yl ,198      S   j,JAJi *  ,LSJl ; _) 
., ,i S ll L '
31 2 1I jl                  U L~,<195
J  1  > Wi O~~~1! -:A_,J L, ~L_,-J!-U Ji  Szl
2000Ly L4 -+t-- H.X1989 �
j    _-y ,y      Jy o                         35.1  FS 
j             <5Lp G2 s<E- 5 U. z 91L<   GJL) Cje-IJ i
-      y  JLoJ, ,SJ*Jl! CeyDl iyl i 195Gy



jojJ 1! juCJ jA > ili itYl ,1yS.(1992 JjUj; -bA '1974
: w auy ;F S Si,< 9Y '
J e:~~~~jyj jF Uy At-,-            as,H3 8 FSiH
. j+aAJI U1 O%9 Jj-u
G~~~~~~~~- J.- zi ii4 irlo5J  ,L-  sj J
t-~~~~~1 ,e  6-L > ;l lJI -,A il  LiljF  (BRIDGE 1994
.(1983 1 ,>1J LJS,zsHIAJ ;-v>
,5,) i,  a- i J v, Jj u   3 9  JL, FJl 
Lvgl 4cJ ii- zl sLcZfl Jll i .(1997 
j~~! 5J   C I 11 bsS   J  DLYSIJ
f ti  11 -11 og:21 45J y 1 ~~.(1993 )ju.cr) s.<y Jl
196



.(1W  ij9Ii'1 88 j~ 
,A;1,li L  O! Le   S
X,>1~~~~~ JU'   l   Ll-d  A  i l  L 1  I^Jb E
:INL JS ,< L_,L;~ JU]Al Ji-5,  . sl jI J;
4 sS1 S : 'S1 vJ>yl ; us La,  -2i L 
.(198 jJslj e) t'197IuiS$ a!JilL



j 91 J.W~ j }�F }� 1 9LJI cfr yl a-2~~  , j .j 1999 eYI '1990
.(1995  j9J`  jiAft.11 e~3  -4 JI  ii jj1 d l
9,JjFouiaoL-~   ;;1 Jj o i ,,
J-<tsAo&| X n o11  Ji 3_1t~lj  ;164  si "-,-u J~5  L.IJp 
~~~~~~~~~~i             s    ll i !IG f J9 199
.(1985 J )9 9 s- i2Xii Qj1993  ji
AGJl             s             1-  _uy Lg- 2JU ilLc t
198~~~(99,4o.)J



&jx .)        A           x ,1 @ J% . i  1 -4 jt 
Jy)
m)19     ~~500 *  EE2Dn                           676
@21 L  572 *  GE}RE5lngEE               590
w)JuL  547       -                                 2EME   641
uL1iJv_     SS4*    1ffi554  mo                     579
496                                  545
366                          398
ya>8+  5791 EDNSSSEES                            678
452                                 546
416                             440
356                         1399
377                          375
411                           413
U&ul   367 * u=u}wsx BEE l      470
lsli   4101  EEEWEgE S7gN      430
u~~y    ~388     -      'E:             429
ult1      441                             440
345                        377
uIrjl       443                             443
393                           438
8Af 1   430 *  EEREX EEE=ER     429
S@X:l   ~458*   ZE    E;S:SEr            449         X  j8v
-!S\1   ~412 ~ErEr          Ef445                     rle-r
a>    �)GY}sI  428                              453
800    600   400   200      0     200    400    600    800
1 jr2z ,99  j,JI W3 _W1 .4, L,.  I L.,
199



ai          L.-k :'J  ,Ia>l 5  29 LL_ cl  JB coS
- ,,:2s  - , 1 G       j   1     -,   < 
-6 oy,+) b8l L5J9j t  9  1  sy      Jy    �
-je 91 X1    .(2000 Yljs ;   ;a-2Sj (.i 1999 qA '1999
4- L-f I                      ai L
ju                a -l  l W y   K A I
) -J>l    9J j G J9 Ulx 'd0 5K J8
200



- L91 4,L.Al H- S QS Ja- JL.J jU5 if- 4s pCJ 43s)
J J  L-
JiD (ra =2 .byl +,  UL1  A,Z1!i
JM       ,     f  l   sji   lbUA <P a au+  t  'yl
.I<eJ wk- LJ 4     H
~~~ ~~~ULJ~~~~~~~  ~L 
,ly~~~~~~~~~~i j.7  ji,  - ,1  - i  vk.j oy  i
'J a9   JJI   J6   A i~-W~j L4g  J> L 42I -I
f iW H S t5 v2  J19 j g; .-, 5ujtoE
>~~~~~~~k JI oI v  lg i!J ,l  J   3+
201



j  y 91 - t 1 tS ,S1 o i ji z
-l   &*s    > ox   C�jyl9, ,)19 rj{ J U os  s LUzI 
2 yl 9Iy        JUJJC 9-s DuUi JSW og2U  AW J fi .(199
~ rLJUI    ~J ij  ~JUyL
JWjJ e54i) 5y  l J M  Ji~ i 4i a>  U1 c1  L. ;
j,~~~j ~
6 j                                        i,kI,i,S W,_J ..,yiS1 Ij3i
;.(1998 ,p$) oJiJ > )1 Ir J; *  S! oiS' Ji J,'l
l S J1Jul 4-j 22    ji juI
pp>) '~~~1997 _t >8- ;Ijbj    't+)kL!9 
J-6 L5jr ;J!;1   ubJWHL     l jj  -L-J ,  -,J(1999
-6 -I  -L, L) 1  lRy LiL'U  > S j!
w . - jifih 191 ,<! ,,4 ,4 O%JL5 <131  j
_J1 ,, 91, ,$i ;JL-   j A   GJ-,u 4-:
9  J Sl 9 l; ,5k r k lli~l L bl:1 ,CI Ir bit  1
,>-s ,5^; 'LJ 4  JaJ J ; ,Ii lJIJ 
-(1998                   ,L Jy  l,  z  5;-_J-I aJ;:I  - ,jJ4  IAy
202



U� @1s~i ~ ~-~~j d   A    '<-c y&  �
t58'1 9 , 98Cly i;L -J)l  ,1 j LTL
L- .(2000 jl)j  '1988 1)j)  W1 j  tJJU  Z--A 6   JUl M
alWl~ ~ ~ ~~. _Ydl -,4 I O I E
L.,j  L4  j .Al !,L4;
ri5x  f  '~(1997) i>8J;Jrf  <J  (1996)  <  1,J .
*  (1990)  ' '(1990) )yr  jj U� .2,lI JyoY  ,  jW  AJJ 4(1999)
_<5e t5o6!JJ(1997)  ,L)!b- Sd>,fjf!-z, -x
.,5; Ly l ,   , y  .(1997)
JJI~~ < el iS$<JL J sLI 2      Lb; 
4-a-,- 4            J.}W    L5 +I! a,u  ,  }-Lj -6j,
-, l j          J Jl L  *J-K Al-J esi
v3 ij  > _  l 5L+ -! - ).-i S203
-  t  -1! >fiil ,@1 <;A  Az,-u ;L_;51J4  ZJ-l  *,J j  L$jl J19 Zl,
i        jo L- Si f  .(1995 n JoPeb  t  l z
.(1997  j;t4_) Z4~Jiij1  J   i:1   tlv-  4 r 
203



sJ t  y l i  O ))J I   . O f  rW t  -LS   l I 9   O I A I ? D 
J gl   jN j              Jll \1O 
44, YUA j  JI, 4}.; >1 iI      L U4;8 OJ I 2- a
JS J  yl LUS J L:. Z<yl iJsyl ,< 1! a.~~~~~~~~~~\LiX, Ji  yL5.
.4Jg41 11 ,3 Jyl! tt1 ;  S ,bl { 9! Y  1-sl
i -L      y y- .J ZUW - 1  1  -'.J L-  j 1 JJ 1  I pi
j-,�~2 jI *~ ~j(Endogene'ty) "13< IJI L!  j 'h
J1> ID>JJJ:- ID WX F~~~A G1997 JI.  ji �ve i O ui -J8SJI,L =;L
45  - L11 PI>I~~~~jJI FJI"  USU  ,Jj  L  --J 1f}   -Gj .!(1997
J; J-J k  J 1,,JI  J  I  4 S  B-ou  ju4S11
jy                        jL Z6 Loy i>jJ ,5JI JIi Z; Jl g
-4 OLIXJJI   *  (S.Y Ji JIL U.)  Ji jl Lj' J fl jr
i e  OUl=! zL.L.JI -LJIJ1  S        1204
J;J  H 4S >~~~~~~~JA   Y-- >JJ  GGI ku,, >. L>
t|~~~~~~~~~~jvJ ,,-  y l f       ai- ja; S1S (1988 tJS)
204



1983     ;x)i1981 .   A ))Th1974  j:W kAI U  
-       -,1997   -'---'-1993  AL   )L4JJJ   1986  )L:sLSi  w)J
.(L_& RS J bkp LI 7 j.;P I:)  9J o  -X4. 4
<5~~~~~L                    Le LLJ <  yll;-iC9(J
L5LP~~~~~0
;5JI W1J95 5r i ''>4! ryl s gS L;S W#!.(1986,1983
5 :99i1999 J;):  l  gl s  t-'4,k sl-jI @
ajU~~~~~~~~~~~~L iL.      ,  J .j s= :lD1S  , .(1995 Jj.<gI
.(2000 )>f i_l 1999,-l j) i,.~l2 jY lJ
S-~~~L  Y  L.=  I  L.4 o-al;2  I.1 L1, J- i   -, aS1ljy
sli~~~~~~j        L lgi?iylJ <  .  sfj' ii j9al.<
i;l~ J <Y kLfJ.t2    lili zZ     2x 
J  ! ,Ll,;l :.JL- LI,, J,ls (2-4 jjLaJl Ai) i,lj UE
205



uXi1~~ � ~   Ji 31JU- o)  U 9.21 ?U   LA7 ,Y  Jr j
L)~ ~~ ~~~~.,Y LL; jLE -k ];1S ISj Ol;YI
> a, JJI a ou1 JqS S$ I 9 z - -  y 2L, I _y 4
(6) ;Lk jLl
~~~~~~~J I 5! ,L iL oJ- )1 I:5 suti r, - ,!sJElj kJuiJ j
991  -  5  - - 21 buyl ' s I A Hl! ttI1U l   L 
j kji 
4-J IL-.Jl  j ~ ~ ~ ~ .J  jl,S  kA5L ajai~ _)  4 L)> 
(7)
- 91997 1  1997 ,J v ,i 5l  .iC20
lj-d L5LC L-.J Jl iJL) ;JI2-  g ! L--i  z9   l^t
-,.JI  y    3   iS L)  ju;l  LL, rj
206



-.e             7      i   - J l
o9lwJiJ  ll  --L3 Jj~ j)  J   iIL    .(1990,1997
*921~~ ~~ S c9Li Jt� jl UaW  X111
~~~2 4 -s -.u- t      v;   4 Jls ya1,, cA~
>s )fW -12I .i 4  s 4 ru'x ia  ci 9. j+- jx 1
ci,91  o1j4 zlJ uJL12 A(s  JK9 orY  JU- JS  SISC
.--   )j      Jio J5 > 3 
Ui ,   is JbU1 JLj                       'a �1  1 ,jl j 1 4   4 1
w   1J D)kI i   3 L   2  j,'Ji U' Lj,L JIWI
-,   J  A5.(1998 o '1998 ) 1   �   �
ogjl jui L5, 0 JJJ18 sL odi 4<~        jI5 ,iJL < ;
j   1j 4j (14 J- JHLws u' ,t 
j.J        ju jl ;-)l,# L'l 2-  40  L6iEly jI.Sl uiy,L
207



12-
39#     31l1       3yji    RlfiS      31J1    31i1               -  y    't;
U1   j21        OGl     )j51         Us UWt
0.40    0.23       0.39    0.19       0.43     0.18       a     7,Jj ju.;'
0.02    0.22       0.09    0.20       0.14     0.15              i-.-$JI
0.79    0.29      0.03-    0.08-      0.61     0.07     t_l 1t.,.JI
0.23    0.07       0.12    0.24       0.47     0.30        -du ZUjl jJi uS
14.19   2.98-      14.19    2.98      14.19    2.98-    (T) ,  Ji 31   jI J;S
11.63   4.92-      11.63   4.92-      11.63    4.92-    () ,i :J$   LJ J-J6
1.16-   0.84       0.74-   0.40       0.91-    4.25       jJ-i , 
0.50   0.74-       0.79    0.54       0.35-   0.74-            zju-I l
.wHi -                           -.  10      {     y#1' U  . ZjL  C)y :sS
AU ..j-l _ki4 z -9 -S  L�S )J  91  3    ! j   'd u.1~ j\,-)l c
((1998) j JJ
L51s- U: :,20I 8   --1'l
jj                  3|   91 oL,Yl a S si S 9 Y ;,LtIj J-Li j
ZJ                         91O;X1.(I)UL 1S 9 
_II)iJ;-;lly,.L           >1_s                              jjyitf  ,,
208



wA  J  re S :191 ,- , ~.(1908  c G998  41
,, vS Ywj(1998,)oy 1 181y S j 
419 )1t-G! .(1997               J 4Jl)  5 4,l   L jLi +j
.(1999 OJ~0) Wjazlij,yU    H      ili
46    jj, 'LSi1  gU y 10 M    j L-yw JA9 ;L1Jl
y: .He & 3191 ;X1 a t!ji jil j-: ,e a 1X 
s;  9 j4- J\, -At 35  i  ;    1    i   S
(12) (1999 Wut),,  Y>U  JI  9  Ia,)   li
"U aA ;I\> <'LIJl,;L < .(1995 4,T    5J1G996
6         iy j S ,  Yt i A          20
}fi 9JjJI  !  .(1983 A1986 j<  ;1  jilt> YJI J1
209



0U;.Lh }JL- dz J   L,  _� Y 0.(9jc~ I- 3L~  4~WI ~  U
yl~ ~~       >> ;jk > S    3 c*-- (  '  >  j-
jJ    uLJi  I        UL ~,J
AJ  j.u _ o, i  -j        0j j
4JL \1, -JIIJ !L cS S oJ9w JjU AS )L< 
210



t!i ifE Si a ,    z    oS 4;1  Lz 
L i 5        zYs  t   ;-S   ,b -sLJ, j,,l A o
j~~~~ L -,_l           j1 -0jL1 .:A,91 o
,,ySi OAA  ~  9<1          vo 41 928 OG GoJ Y,9 *99
Jj.
i L--J I                  j ~~ f  JoY  - (1994 ~-
Lra Jo'U         - I  YWJl a
j~L-� .(1993 jU.Lr,) J~~2
JL1  4l i  oL. a1  ,kJ,  . -,L
211



4         -J    :   1 4    ) S  US JI 1 -1 1
L~                                L-l l- ~
lell 4J+1 .(1997  s  i- I '1989  t l Qy ~.(1999 jiAg 8
;~~~~~L  -  y i 1  -16  O               js!', - A;1j
JL4Y ju     * ~JSl Ouil~ SL.l9'Lf, Li J s-u-
.(1987 4  W  ~              ZAs, Li  J }Q  .99
<~~~~~~~~~~~~L ZL,J 4 l  1 C-- Jl zjll!y -
a ;;El af."-  J-L J2l --.iL,  jF >j aL" ji ,;jl  L3 iy
J�~~~~~~~S aX           _ u   iJb i ?
212 JJijj,  j-ZL,
L- LJl ji  G ;L)- . Jli  JL-,l   I  Ju-
i l  . (1 997  Ai0~;41989  3  pi,N_S, i li.
Jleyl + S OA S  >+l ;9 SLa W D! .<i_>t>, (1995
212



Lii  o fr fi~y Wi -LI  1 *AA j 1 I
>l 4j ! oiSj  L  j v  a   >
Jill  sIjl � vH --jl  (2-;4 jj-  45-g ;jAl-  1Lb) jf }  a
A  4!  WY X ! 2p 90 ', N . 4 .29  XD-A0(1990 !  ,*
.(1987 i )
213



.J1, 11 JL j                       yu o9 .i  L
H)~~:-L -di -LS'!9  s  1Jie9  +     I JL :1
~~~~~ ~~~~~     < .(14)(
-_<      8  X;4 Y -5yl  J j,- (  (1998  J. *1993 J
y, 5-,i ,, WK 4s urL- 5
214~j
j,-LY    - ,1 ULA i J _>El J4  ji ZL! .(1998 ,  lJ
. > jlJ olU 5,41 Jui,ll ,- C,!: yl ,L<, .:,jj L--
%191~~~15 J-li     -j-du : ,X Ljl jLru, _S Lil -.iL_-J
,_yl ,- Lif >3.(I1996  j9w)La 41994  -GY 3 
*4>J<\ 3 SLY j<:I esL; 42 fi 21L14 J-;L L- aL:ULJ L5;
214



8  1990
7 jl                   28                          1992
31    l 20J WJ- &     li
21       - 5
vD * 7 jg yt-blS , 9L~t     28 -1     y       D 1999
95~~~~u                                         1996 ef  S  3  UaU L 
4., I.1 I 1)  Z-,e, j._1i:Jj lil jo isl2ii 2ul99
Sas ji ~(-0. 017, 0.009)      (-0.020
.,<~~~~~~~~~~~~J
2-4 ,',
215



,5; <:X1 J>l 1 SjJS 4J ! ,Xl tSb1988 1,
JLL. o1 Lii 4  igA)W )L.aif Y,J  .-1 o W�  &
.0. 134 )uac,L -as s .L 2 Ij 0. 171
ui_-!1! i_il ,HiSlll2ig1 il ol jJ_P1987
. jJ_ Si; 3 Vl <  , LJl, ,!
-0.76 , _lbO1^1y        .lj!I    0    1987 Jl-
J ee,sL2  t5A  , -1.07 xs$lY  5i  5 
iJIU CLjJil .i7A1 ~i_lJWI 1 +-0.86
.ji9 esl-0.77 , -0.91 , -0.63 Le jL-U
i% -JjJlaj ri WI  91 Wi li zl  9 .L9    1
-        ..(j--zAJJ L31  J
L5-51  1 sj4  ,,- 1.(1996  j. L 1995 S  I J
't~~L LS U              L- 1 )e X  k  i  -akS?42  1o
cU    jL--1  U' z. Lbl jL-,-J  ;jS1 :  ; LA LS 
.(2-4 JAi i) DL.1 4  e,<  <X
*u!  wNl  OLJI P-bA  U2JI  a S,- ,t-  Lc J--, y ,-l  Z -i i
W~~~~~~~ jM  9   -  .u<  kL  t   J 
216



J5l Ws ,!         9o1 u<  !   9u  J  Ji k E
~+L j ~L~~L-I i   ,~   -   KAi jLi~~J
.(3-4 jjL,4,, zt 4 ,;2J 
Lai 4 *% 27 LLW MAJ W   :3-431WtJl
+ ,s LX >5 4li;1 982  \ MljWID :
~ WK,11 a    L J * k ,  :  eJJL zi,J -g!.,I .rJLxlJ AJ
,  44 Llj 27 _� o
9Lc .(1999 sW4j ,        -) UZ  Js   .(1993 
.iL5  48  iI,-1l y-JY  4JI L~ J,S1   ,3Al=-_l P-J-  l,  ,J  1992
J~~~~~~9K
AJ11 J1 Z'LL<   223  L_jS JLi  Ayl 33 s  L,-11 JI J-L  clXi  \lj
1 L,-JI -_l ^uI jL-  5
3-4 3_,wl u
217



Z- 42,jW1 ZLO I)t 1992 cWJ j  L-i +1        I
~~~9     12� aS AL   lrz1-  x zyS 1.w  X8Y >- 
A  5   Z       mui, I-di ,  Ii Z-! .rJI  Jt) ljj y  ak L
JIl         lcSL *s(1999  L&5) -U-rjl  9 L5LI;1
~-L-   - J& ,9 XGj t 
(I5)~ 1x  1Js L-l -JI, Wi j   j  -
jl-,JI               -  IJI  i W Aj - -I --0
eLd Jl  j)i IAS.(2000 --LI S _  ?:18
JL,JL- IJ  L--: .s u 1  L-J-
A OSA~~~~~~18!T,1 } 111   A



<Li~ JJi .(2000 955)1 4;1  9 JJ. -  5 9L L
~~~~~(6)-U        0   il 38-9  u, ~, 
a~~~~-*                 .9  La;'  zL i E iclc-s ,lS,x9
) j iLJ� - 5 J 3  J5 ZaU 3 010
Si j,9 JL91, 4�j9L.. isl cjL 9ii JW,ci J�- 's L%W'
LJz-  '    '  ki OJl-  1   CA  9  ~Ji LLOy X 
J'~ ~~~~ jil, J 5, jW a-aU 12z  ,  j
3 8     9           ci j- j 
.(I~~ 999J J5A J-g Z4 5 L1 3<  31 5-
jll byyl J ~~(16'1S  191 8)
jlyl eLl c-bUi ,3! .(0  U� u J 9 (2000  1996
aL. U8-9 , Sil  ?   J  9-j   ~ 3 219
o~~~~~~~~19Hi      > ,X : 51oiIS ,J



s& GJu-ll Cu1 9 JJI. aky) U1S1 ey-J JI J 1 925L  4jl.I   A j3: ;
1J5 -Sbyl z ~5 ov sJ *(1998 J       \JI $     1
-3dI 7-;  -         jL5, ILIJ-) L) (19 (2-4 JKI) J-  J
JAl ,9 91 4j <, f >,, S ( )a2-4lii) 1 :2- 6JQl
jy!    jl9 l .,p j_ a-J ;O+y  1j -  4ja  j      ,
5
4
3
2
0
(1)      (2)
.L:L-j- Lz+Yt !.  (2) i-L-l  zbs L )i  ,  1oJr, l
.oAjWJ oJL J2t Si Xy 4,? 31 1 .(2000) yA�, i
Lua! 'S! '}  '! qI996) 0!i    !i      1 
(1) :11dJLY! '2000)      Jj qt9  ;,'2000) &}, ;j i,  (2000)
.(2000)  , 4iLf (2) 2X ti3, '(1988) 3,,, ,4
220



l~~~
J t lo X j - J~   -~ 2 -            JI 9   : i
L-   L ,2y I   2-' U 5.l 1  i,- j LLZ -0.)  ,99  4
F{J-_P!_(-A-YI Xa-- L5,U; l JAy1 1  \i) _rllJ4  16-8  H,
.(2000 LJ    S'9       +lLO
Ju zA~~L-  u*/jio                 , +-;
S ;1< >X1 f~~~~-7>-   :~,zy :v
11  s1 S j iLSL  L  i L             j -21
44_, 2;El ,,191 ?22- 1 v ano  DY\



;,}si ~  ~ L%W  b 5   j 90 Ju 70 , L J'- -s>4-U
;DS1 'H) 199  yLL-~) J ;L -L i  L >   Le1  L %   ..z-   -di
�.(1998 aj
(~L L1      1    31 4UW Sy       - . ,1
~~~>1 ~ 51
i ,ci iyl S 1,X1 91 6 ~~~90 170 
_$~~~~~~~  Yo                      5tp RR2G9i,Xj  ,VS8A
.(1995 Q4D 84 j-~i ;! Y.(1999 _O) EfJy.i,9 A .- ,s
L-s ~ ~     ~    ~     
Ga !0 G1996  ,4                U1 <11 <5k S- ,fJI s
2(1998 2)j
�  i~ iJll1 J3  i b LI 1 ,- 1 i.I Z,J  - ) i  S- .(1998 J0  k
1L -ZP   iSl  UJlll  -:3  --i   11 j W  Lffi Si j  .(1998  '1J< c
e l<-.:4 SrsS,11i                    jLe _ikrfi A
195 );41) 4-  .dl j 4  JX  -  jl,J Lq jWlD  L 
45,yl~~~L5-i; _4j EiL i>9; 1   i - yJ Ip n_zi a
222



5  , ,J_d1 j  !; jA! e9Yc1y -! (1995 jj) o
jF , ,<1 ,z1 1,.4, ,,>, lil i, ,-Jt i  -, .sj
Ja jgtal ;L2J1 gi Ju, .(1991 1)  J 9lso90  )u9y
-LZ (S<                          L i jLt JHl;8tl ).l>1 tFj
a~~~~~~~~~~~J-l I I              jIa1  Jo*lIIY  l Jt!ot L1WI
Ott~~~~~~~~~~~L         L-;9  ?   9I a S., , Lj  g  _.,
;1  11 1 +  ~jl-Jl  1j l  ,3J-  jiu -_  -ij~ itsUtl 
.(4-4 sjj-I) L at 1 
223



4A .U   j aoiAl z A J a "  4-4 ajawi
JAtI 3,3 1  1 M1 K l,j S JJ;  La~ J
Oy,  ;11 .  t  X i iy> (Tontiniers) <( tib;:  w>;
0.73  i5J Zj ll  ljl-  2.5 ig,p  -) 0.A  2 5P  L- ;A  1994
~~~~ bcJ g&1 'JLj)i + .g1 - W _  ,r>
~9 ~  ~ ~Z)~W~ j . (1994~         �-
3,3 ~    ~      
.i ,.2A U  sI JU. ji e: J   b ~9 .�j s^l i
e ws Ju-i j, z z   LU i ,,XJi gi jI Ji
*Cr li     jjicl   ;  U (  yi 3 *  l  *$U J -Y 
L5L_ LrJ 3,j,3 JL; L5 ,i_, cn LX z1, : 22
,<>~~~~~0~ 21; �e  ejsjw,t        A
4-4 .(1997i 194osj*J);   ve,    ,+
vL- 4 JI+S us_>  M,  l  >S s224  P



. zAL.A OU  1  S  o1  v  -
r4tJ  AS j 9~iy 41;NJIJ ovU   4s~<  1;.i � .Ap a1W C   -
J k -Jl,o S9L J 1   91 J f� 
j JeJ 9 -;L1 Cui       > tl
4> ry AC; #   - J}J~- L Jl     +)       I
s! .,1 91 ,225jL<l K   la.1 j-
*1994 � f!1985 �ki Lg- J  ;111 
-s  J S 100 3s?GS 
~~~1996  UWl Jj,!.  .(1995 JL-;j  wl  31 4 1.7 ie
J .(2000   9)z A1.5   H-   IJ       Wi  Wg9,J 
S  z Wi GdJi 31  i .<, IznI ,-  ,,,4 ,w,, L ?,5 a  JtjI- 
S1 sLL2~J1 w 9  21  L ^1,}L Jail -)L.1
,;a1 -4 ,-  0S il2 ;^i  ._  JI, j    2 J   s2I,J9  L  ,
,1,9i >Jxe 11 �-! J>E JXJ 22,5 IAs



1KA  eL   >1-A J4 aS1- Q,� Ug J3L  .C 9
.(1995 j�) w  i   1 L 1 JL1
-I b S S ;\yl o4l , 1)1 r1,   l S1 ;
s~�L; ;  ;k J9l L L. ~ - LyW 4.i 9194I  J-  M
U 4AjSJI JJll U-- LWJ1j1 J zA S tJa J -JU u  iu
,JI! Lj , l bJU, jzluI ,226
4zpIJIl Ji a- 1  i: .. I-K)I SCWS_)-iu lj~ vl~
UL,Js~~~ ~ ~~~~~ .:>1, .Jl R,3<:Xpl 1_ Jj-) L5L XJjJMIl;
, :AJY  40cS Hy
~~~~l;4C8J0               L)  :L-, � 1   9,1P J 9 I)(0z- yii<,!tl
, ,:l ,<1 oOJi Y ,414,b,AP S1H! JLXH
v  biE3XUzi<SNJ J l> *s J,,3Jljl 226Ll 



i_,yUI AojlAA a  iLA3 AtiU 1 ,4_y. L)j .(1995  i '1992
l v, - WKA &1,31 &,J�Y;A6 tllS,j , 
4sX fL  i f                >s i5? L,1Coy
"  "  22i i! -J i  4 sl   4 L.�  . -1 3j   JJi 21 z
,U9    Xl  .,nI 4J%Al J~~ o1    J W 1 -A
.Gsl,l i LLJsl , 3 L..S95 1 J  -gjj
~~~~J' icl j t;- rUyl (fX u9I9iLr vgtN; 
L I  4 ;44JK~KY4J! Jf:JJjC y, Ij 1Jj  I
cL~~~$Jl~~~  ~~  ~~LJJ Lj "-JU
(a9F oL.U) LoL.X;i -;19  1  4 
jJl 3A 1   U ,ojL-)l J- U.iX v i Jy  S
,21 DIJYl Jlj  ni; .4L~Ju -j i5  Jj D1
A (JL) oil A   J  26 JLC- uL1l sy  p�- j i  K1} I
j .(1998 jj_)  o,      _ Q L)227
L9,6L-l j  .;Gi.)1  o  L-j  Z--J  91 J  9   ! 
<S 0J a.)                J 4,o 4i  l-JI oJI <JI A I JI L) L-AJ  i
227



21U(20)(U1_Jy     1   1
�-,-2 tn ie(> 6 o) s.400 -9   ;1 4  .
984 , , - -  ,J I - , I d I - JU--  S 1 j  .  L.L
cA 91 > 91~ -i1 *Si LIjs- 1J1W ' -  ;S-y ySU J 
-r jl ssl  ;L1j oti 92  .( 664 J  125  -  J  5 j 
L4A1 JL.s&J  )  c~ ~i-L i    JL L,JI 4jl3 4 SJy) y3 yJ 
C)9 J    yL~  ~JJ J610 11 9 ,r, -     JL C; -  _
984 .;  2 QiJXIJsJIJl "i yIil   Ij~ 228
*(1996 ,j)Gy   Ii5 
28-5  L-5 -LJLA  :sl;Ji     -7 Ylj 41w!vl:p
2L  4,JI 9UI W3j (1994 9C3 t4R5  i
,sY! 'oJv 1988 -  >X   ,LJJ     J, i uc_
"L-JI J.-.  , L-Su ;s  J _ U 3  ll JaE; 4b  i A  ,  .(1999  s?
1'--  p,1  .j-,  L,.Jl  C-L,-  Jtt   E.:,LS9l  L. D  i;  J  oI,   Jl 
228



4&W                   61 mi^5lq AMi                 -1l 34 jptj
800
600
400
200
0
*    . A 400 -                     * oi_ 30 o     - 2  -,
.(I 996) .i.:,-L1i
0L~~~~U~
jl L.5 -       R     -     op                   ji ;-,, fi
J                 1ij Ji )j .  ow IJ zlj L) OiL-   M    S l ! Lyj -i i
.(1994    4     ;z9Y (j;i.L) 4,1i s9I;viJii
229



s--j    4-1-8 t>a j 3  t; tj -y i .X 2  j
L)~~~~~L
iLW Ur ouSJ cA6Wl ! e,1 oz  - Aj LjJ s-j4yV  a
A~~ iS  A l ayi ,9 ,yl .zyu ,, J41~
j J- . ) .19188 1 u9,y (sL 9U J ;u  J. 1  1
230



'?~'~+% 'KKI d\  !   J Ui yl-4 JG - yl    LJ ).  1   -
-(1999 Cif id (199 )     1
.m,  ,  -' &       A1 xJs o   , ,- ,,J )J L   -4
j .1  ,j J  j U  - t         a~ Ji s .J-, j
.(;1,1l~~ <  y JtJ 1 5         5 1o LP ;L ~j-dlJ
4 J-,   '(1981   1999) 2Y1! (1995) J)yL- a1 )6' -3
jL    iAl ,zy J_s~ 2,96  (1993) L
,A )jtI                      Aal _J 4b  , ,LI J4L- ;1-l A (,L -4
;i~U Z�Ui j ~  i i  J1U .(199  1992 L+   '   1992 -7"
C,> 8 J',- -       ,         500 JL },1
..Ul Jj-1JI j _pSl oj-JI ,J  .(1995  79-l 1977 lvA  l  J I  J
iL J       JL; ZL 4 -, K   -  i231
j   4l ;-j  L J (1981   L 1974) r L! (1956) jj--L_y   L  _,Ii  -5
H9J SLAI <JI,SJI 2J fjs5 t'YU'>JJ .(1986)  I<
.(1986) ,r,;  594
J~~~l             j  j~JW   -J l   -J. JI.SI  ~ JL-.4L,, lJ  !,U1  -6
*(1999)         9  t   >   J            4
jll All W!LL11911 C, OS1977          J J , ;-7
Jj, Lsz aAL8               3          -i w 1500 Lj1 J
is:; , JiJ KliJI i  Si1979-1977 _Hj;JI ~j>!r
231



.(1997 ,~  ,1 1997 ", eu, Jyja       91t
1tsl J1 S;JL<I4 jL5 aJJ  kL~  rI    elja,        j   -8
j-                       jK 'll L  uSs;JY 1-8JL
o121 u~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~:7Y JAUJ < Jl L s)
i1998  :i  <l      7         1   ,            '  -
.(1999 Ov 1998 fii
4(1994) L? (1994) ,4,   -                         I191  y, N   l> -10
J_x~ .(2000) U1z i(1999)   n,- (1999) ,> sJjgy
.(1999)         6!X   L-J 4,i o As J
;z5t>! ;<! (1994) > rzG Lza 
.;Ls sS 9i ::y �Xl J ojw  j   19    i(1997) ;L,!
,AcUl ,, i. 8 aLs\,XI 9- zi (1999)         l<Tj L, 
J; Jl 1;l al;(1997) ,5I1J  gAx)r Jl '(I994)  J) 
-6j .(1996 z~  aj ;j) .Jl 3;xJjd :j ~l'Jl  i  vLJs -,35Ip
<)f X3l 5Js JUall av1 i IyA.i a, _,s1 b- -xi L5_,-)
'1996 L,)J J5j;,ez)J   , visl ;Aco i\             ;tp,I  !,3o L
.(1998 _tS '1996 L:)_t)_i )_p
232



,,U J>1  a25 cvy , o+sI +- -ii c l < 1,~ z- -13
Wi LLi yHi  u 391  L%J1i ; 1  i - j  --T  K.L3 -1
.(1999 +4>      L5 C.
J J.(00) Y~9%,e4
"- gI " 21, �1L                  -J:16W W1 GlP
. 968 i-~ Ji ~   0 1999-
(1994) a1>80 2n  s, ,, ,       -13
(1999) ~ ~  ,+=Y J1 198
J~~~~~~ J, -18.kjA  lL  1,y,!
L 9  JbyJl  i- 9  -1 ,y  t 1  (1993)
,(200 i(2000) Y,>5j, j  L;1980)   '( jj988)1  -19
,l l"K4  1(99)  9j,j> 3-_5 .(2000)  'j E
,Uii!6              Jj-L 0 se Z4y 50  -20j A 'S
.(200 t !Jt~ U-I zk, ) I j.20)X,!; !
233



I



tI  -Olv ,i .It Q -,Up, 4La1l' I *JI



1 -I 1 ~~~~~~5 o1 O a 
2 y  l --0 01 Ii0        1G  I  zF-- ji
.(~ 2000 X;jJ1' 41L1i  }-W  9JJ  Jj  .:.1 fiii ;11J A
~~~j  ~~~~~  y~~~~~    L~  
'i ZIf y~  t ,ii! t, A  JX >1J-. 1 WI
j , C~-l<I?,Xl1 J,Ij.~       .LJI~ ,jj.,,l
2 ,lj'; JI S- JW Oyl ThI J X3-I O1  iJo�u1i;
* (47-46  o  ,Jo l  1 1
J OS 4S~~~~~~~J  J 19 0Lj,, 1J
ji JjYI JSl ? -Gj cal  --LjI JLJ 3 5YIJ)l#S
-_p,Lj            j               JL- )I' J91J4Jv  JJI 'L-J
jL                            L) J 11  J L3)i
236



-ij si  1  L 9! *�Jy - 8 s1 91  ij L
*K*N, iA j~ 16 Ji 4! X4j,I o;@ �    06
JLp -,J   JjzA . . 5 i        0
9L~~Wl>   ,c& J_jIl J >L-S  ,  l  -  J-s' -'
2378  4J,  GaJ;ll J>sl ;<? O .ju;l
4=--J , <  >iz �Z 4y J, j~ 41- 41--
472Lrilj 3  A , lL s> 3j:
-'y~~~~~.,a
237



,:51 ~ ~~~~.~J ,J, S ,14L,S S? 1  )l,l 
P,il 1.                   I91 ,   J  U4,  L2U J.p 2j WU
4,>iyl 1 rCJ as olJlll �-4 ji.) j
91 -_ e6) oyl 491 >1 2D > 4;l 'j L l 3L _JJ
LA p9y L1 z o 4I jl; (<M1 SiJ.loU
JVJI 4J1 nP Al  ji:9l         >-z ji238
ov1 (D LB! sz;SilJLIX l 9 J �g iE1W lJl
J4 ,-l;  O   2 y  g
238I"   .      " 



~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4J 9,) ,2 as 1 --)L 6ot t -,y
if~~~~~~~~~~~ JLI              I 4J L  p  o 'LL8  3oJl  li? _ 
JI~ ~ ~ jLl Jl>c- Xl AII~,     Lj
2 0          jaiWy>ly  J11L3- aii _l Z C  -<S  WI  wvuz.>  I  :>L
l a3Hi J- IJ,-) L4 i_! JI J,JE i:APL L_t-- ifL-iJ, -d1 rj -,d
'~~~~; 1 ~     c-LlIj oll.t t1 <  J4L C(2000 ,2l Lc J  ;i
pi J    otcl .b . 2;jl,~ -Jl a b yJc 3-11 jo.JJI JL<i
.(1993 wz&r1988 ---j;i) JL-A 4Js ;\J Z  (9iil su
L3 oJlQj  CjL i rU s  ls ?i .1<Jl 1A Lj aL--IzJ-I S s -8A
:JsJ eY!) I  i ;L-- IJ  S LL-  Ls i,-- jij av?  l
;,~~~L~      1,e  I L6Ll J-j  - u (1999 L;A ) LAS!  ' !. o
J ij  <ayolJll 2  LUiz .)t>l <-LU   l JJlt 
239



9W~ 9,i 4U>Yt J9A dUl J  419X  -L 9i12 > 
i,- i2 -;Js 9 9 okb C tj, 23 r o  k  A .(1-5 j )
p-  ~-~'-) * ' 5000  M    - ,  .i  J Ul J-  y  i 
w3            49' ,LItf~~~~~~~~~~Ji  f> l JJ  4z2JoW c i1995
43 *  X  a l  o+I obJ.Al-  oj. iJL  J-LiJI  1995e5 gJ
jiA  J, j J,jljl s l ~> & 1 5W  '  
( z y     L, JL)I 41  e-JoI   y
l  jJIlW  JI~ #A~ p- ;.S1I sUa'd S1 E; Z1 JIJi 
? A!~~~~ jJ  9 C ayl sJ Zs  1 , i N 0. U)
~~~  ~ ~ _4   "L-J )l:
aL,$1 ;2,1 -Ly ;,s a5COJI JU  5l;l, YJ!W
J- JJ JAJJIJ(A  ZS  1 ! ? Lij 4
Y 91 ~~~~~~-J1J W3- JL)1r  S !G21i?J!2l  jj3J 'O1
Y YI 31 J- CU;,Y- 0 .(2000 S-L 1: eY1) Z4614   OLp jjLa: 
240



. - %.- Yl   '     A   izaiw      Xl :15 'WIl
9jlf
700 
600
500                  I
400
300
5.5      6.5        7.5       8.5      9.5       10.5
500
soo
400
300                              U   U a 
5.5        6.5        7.5        8.5        9.5       10.5
*JLE,k61~
.(,1999) 1j-dl  ia,1   ,L      (1995) aWYs ;oL  rE  z    9sL
241



L o-JI A z LS-  J->  ;   ;),,.I .)  1W 
LLJIeg>J G  ez C11 9  43taji S.PvLAAJoxbJI oGajb 5a
LA~J1 ~~i1l f  Ul j   1y La t yL--2l  J A J ,i 
4, -il 4U1d 4a L J ig s !  A'i  -4L:
~~~~-> ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -j -L--ja
JA!  4 . dL. 1  ,}!�  > Ul  UJ l j   A1 J. 4L E  1 
L-j~~~~~~ 4o>lJ  j
s +! JJ  ti! .s @2y  4  2
242



I' iDi;L1 1W, D1 I Ij,-U JL-)l .(1970      Zs) JI 
L--. I                  u  :&S  j L -  I j   II
:    l (ji ,L-          O  u 90 Jy -
j- yl D-9J~~~JI 7U yl <L4 Jl,I LUJ WI. Jy oLJ1J
iz j C  J 9  y sa ~1.3 Li)Dg  9  o 
L)      1     .| (1998    oL+, a.) I, 90     31l
JiD 191 H J tG-;l '! 'vJ S  sl L<
.(2000 Aj ~jL  -J 2000 _pY) ip'
U" 4     ?. 9wSL 4LJ >- *(1999 l:UIS) ^A41 ; i o
iDLj! ii,jfll i,zu1 S J+J1 o-u L
-, *I'-J')l z~ >l e      ~    J19974 1992  i  i
J J D 1 1 J y ,,j  T   L S-J 
as L  :1 - 2I  5.Z   1     - JI 
eL-J L+-J1 J,  s -z l ji  i .i ,+u  JuL 4
243



J~~,- ~ -JQ       ,s LWy ,2 11          >
JL.S,l aA z4 s D  .(1999 p A '999 i9OX    1    l
si G ouAz -ys zi gJzi + .:.A L 'a  o   0-.  I   4
.(2000  t  91-5 d1 J    pij  J ; 9 jJ, 1 
W39   1                   !2 Jj ?OCIie1000 . ; i 
4Ai :29J ,3!.1998-1988 Wo;e J  -kjl,.Jl J 30! SlW 15 1
i- J 6 <  4 36 j22       jUj L !S  s 94t1s;  -)ap
L  W3 olo loSe 1;oAl SSJ <<I o!.:1999 ;J1ll olJ)w)u L
~~~~~~-J          -J  1 ]l, 1$WCI;;l j  aJ
) 9I iL! tl  L,!jSJ
244



JKJ-JJ         s Ii i U)L"
sL  uJ IO     L    ; s1S         yvSj1
J - l  j.1 52l a;L  Aii 2�9U.   2! cA, *  o
196 ;gI j1y K9 p521l 9LbWi  '~ ,Y iL -
a;-- 65, 4---. 64-55  L ejL-ii   j   JL -ji 1960 eUJ
, JLUT .(2 -5s 4)  ALl .* 
,,<J~ 664-55ssj JL,U)J         wWJ Ls 
ji -j- Liv 65     JI,< ?JU at:l- y; u
65                                     j -A z J  4  yl  2  <   , JK 
*     60 s-. ,-i C_ d s  N        u2 Li \    -L
:- j Z'du 60  o }sl <  64-60  Ju-j M �9L1i y1
'      - L�~ jrj '.      3 S J s1 . .-51fJiL40-15  L- U  c-ll i
_.j #21 JL-)l 2:, -  S >: (1998 jJ  Js  L1 U1 Li
x Ci) - v ;4 t1e  '1930 6Ul L }lyA j.-% -_ 60  e _,
aj 4_ 55 j_ oA 4i.I sl J JLJXl Z_:  .(1997 Z-j) cL-
.1990 aL- :UdU 39.4 311970 �Lc ZidU 52.7 3j 1940 �`u; a-4 61.4 Ds i^
jk 9- 64-55 gJ;)l u ~L  C)S i aL l JL J6  
~~~~~~~~~J-)l J   L:            3, stt,   ' Il > 2 jy s  r 
J}! itui ii,  sl -e 65yf J, J i~5 . 57 jl- J- SIL JL -i
oilntil J a JQ  1994 ~j-Ul U-1 iJj 4A.s-jYE sjjuI j. 
>3 oisl i 64-55  - ;ei lJ1 <>iJI JLril  e    I>J
i 65 9U    i . i   j 64-55 ;   .LJI i    J l l )i
245



-;"I         olLiL  :tIt1   1-5 3_,0w
jjyy Oj           .9J <11 j 1 S 1 
1993 j5       L S,j 1989 cLa;     L W jS 1984 cj L,
,$_, +  sj J  ;1  o1a    -   U   .(2000 t.1
.i<siJ  (1993  Z;)     ? JJI         ZdL 1P  5  I  5-10  p
7-2 S,JIX cW L Js   aUdl 40 -l1 i Jj 1 1
. 1989-1984 n
~,p J-  .-,   ,.;W      loI v;   joll<Su9I
,WJI -6J   - b  J;JI  JL- J\ jL5  1993  CWl L  !J J   JUA  .JL-)
_,laA>   .(2000           t_91 9) 3J 3;        9 ,1 ; L53 
I  I -   ,j Jt   LZAP,cJl  L- e3iruJI Clli  sLI  F   Jl
.1993, 1984,r  ,
j>                                   Zduae tylJsl 50 ji  J
jyl ,LJI j  a.iZL 6,    '     2- ojll 37-35  , L-
a asA1 si+- w ~~ji     , .(2000 y l1
, \Ju_-J JL- :, 1 -L<J ZiJjtl''- L"9
4 < vS8 W 2$- Ji<J! e S5x  i >g (2000 1ijb 919 Cdlt)UU
j.-1 L, -Jf-W      J  TID    1    (1993  )41 ol
,LJX  JL - )< 3 jS5 L.53JI  ofi\ts%?sble
246



.is�iw i;esisl;S8l.il      ":L2_5 fiQsL
100         64-55 _                  100            64-55 
60�                                  80
60                                   60
40                                   40--
20                                   20       .
0                                    0
1960   1970   1980   1990 2000        1960   1970   1980   1990 2000
toU1     65t JJ  faj                        j 4u 65 
80                         ~~~~~~~~80
60                                  60
40                         ~~~~~~40 
'-"- 20-
O. ..                                        '*- .   ..........  i. .....
0                          ~~~~~~~~~0
1960   1970   1980   1990 2000        1960   1970   1980   1990 2000
t j,,,,i ~~~~~~~~...1.f.....
J-J9I  L-4-t .1*----'L1
247:s  toy9o12000
(2000) i2Jj-dl J-JI l  :  1
247



)yl > 6 ; ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~J Is& l 
<11 ? i LS1 uJii ,li ,,il NJI (1997 j4 6997  .Jl- Jl)
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~Z 1 tI:I         - JL  v<-  9 1 2X 
JJ, ~~1, 15                   j_5 -u L1, ,3 JvA6 Ll
a_)~~~~~~~- I2J              --J 3e4bS1  1ojDi1  DE  M
~~~~~~)~      jl-tl L,. jl   SL1 -  65 j 55  LTr L 9 9a at4
.(2) (1997             &J3Jla)L'1 3<w lsz,Y
j uI j,l '1   c5pl 49 L) 
Jl   <   1,    l!L-S       ii> 1Y ij1             6
-J9i L  S-        j-      "LiS <  ,, L :JJ) i  jS
u! Sii 9 o1 , M~~~'.y 991c j < Y 
2~~~_J            ;3         r   gL   4S Ja.l, ssl0J<W
248



L,  L-AY 6ItL Ii ai Lt+  
j" JLU                      - )SU
-   s  < J ,ff atyL ,si  -  i l t Ul
I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ euJ JbIJ "!u  1
&J >uI L3 Lri -"
G <  - I , ,1!  5, Sc.S >1uZi c,k1L .:A- uLl
249



-t*J1 j1  3L .eL M5,  L)  o 1 9 J
M  >l js1  :,lz  ,1jt.!A Jj L >s  L
,11 ,"jut -,   ,11 Ju jzyl j Ll
.-il  j , ,  SlLU  - iJ  j ,
L) ~ ~ .20  ;-9p  LLSiS9 
-j ~ oI).-f -Lc J9J LLc J SI- I 5
Z,JI t:P-  J 6 3j  ~ e  s>1 c(1985  ,YI J'18 s
f yyl 2 ~~~~~~~. 199   21998  J - ,!,E - 21+
250i16J     oJ



i -u1 2L&- ,J- .  JU.l JL,) ,   -4 ;       4,
i_,;X1sizi ! .1 ,;aF Jj  L) iip9 i
LA A1 9LJ u W  i  j1 ,1  4.M t -t j  L.  J.- 
LJyJ ull   - c3 vLS 91 W<y ZW Yl W
LJ l ,3<L8,> IJ2 e51JiLI 3!~L  ,,u~k c1� s+
a1,    JLtA) Jti JL.iJ 2I 3  4s G> 91 ,x. *ci9^N ji-
L Usl S   I~J~ -j- ;1 tz,>t j\S ll t2. - yU  J   J1  j i K   : ,'1 vdI
I~~~~~~~~.19 Jull L            AlJW2
jL----j,D                 Iudl jL~j
~ -j.~i ~  W ~ ;)L  U> I.A~ iP~Wf
821~~-5  ,LyL   -AL          .4.N1xj L,1 1 Oy - I 
- C5,1  JbxL) JJI ,   J  L f   .l)P :ji 
JU _,  (,S jlj 5aI1 ii,-Jl Jlmi, --Lj   c,9:-JUI 1'+i
ji J  j _  ;-   3 L)         j
i <U LJJ LJ 21     -1       JI
251



,�1d1 o   DA 91 ;LU1 J  W  i 4   yl S 11D
L F   uELJ1       ow1  9           .
J) (4) (1997 z-pJ >LJ) J  5,41 J_IAlZ 4, 9  ilulj
j11 oL-, gJ  it >yl JYJJI us25
J~~~~~~~~~~~- L IA I- IJ Jb J e1GLZ1,.5- $)4J -
- ; Jgjsi JEyl nSJ(Zwil2ii18-20 vuSl +L
.(1988 ij g 4J  7  6-5 v
ollgJli,eYlU;ll,  L- ojJS !vL jy 9- .(1996 1998 z3P
50                                         gsoisXSJ AvJwjgJ >lw; x> Al5
11~~~~-8 ,lSt L, 20-15   Z-;   Z12l  L)   ;A,  a,-   ob dl1 w
*(1997 -c  O)8  y Jil
252



O-Wi 311 C. L      d J'U                6i: 1i  1 J-   I
5199
L ,5i urc  ?  Lc Jji J-UI                  198J 4 i, US
J' L   3       ,     1; Lj-   1, tvz s.i 
.JSJ99 , t5i iJ 8 J S12000
,.iJI,< ,i t;  aiLz 1  a,lt 48-36 u         1997
i;J8! 'Ulj~L-JI        -,,S ZX1eL ,4iil 50 z   1996
; g1 - .51 ,illlyl<      lsSJ1,              1988 DSI
.oLzxiI < ,fi iAlU 5 jLit.    - ,Jl
1-97   -- Jl  _9 ,U          i I  iiI           9
1.02j~H
4            tpJ     0.08,j 1.01 9  ,
i LZ 7 9UA.J z    ,p ;   13-9 ,l.i.8L             1999
i 22,e                                            , 1999
405 ,, i    L  j'                    j W 6  . j, ,
1-5 J,-' U
253



IL UL4 <,..JiuL 3w;I  IS J3, I juK; .lL s W;  1998 j-A
(0.36-9 1.10) ,51YI  sL5-Il LL 4c; 
.(0.69j 1.13) 4-5UjI t (0.86i 1.00)   1988 YI 
Le  4, J '41 JJ   S  ^EliJa  S  , L.sL,S;  L.sl-   -  
.J1;,NL < i16 1  4 lo S        1996
. 1 WI ;,LII  U    ..W1.05 ,l, yiui s,   W  I,
JG (2000 1j) JYI 11 6J ;J3.92 >N   � L  3I!
- Z 0.899
O1 i-2 6I xjL-l ZjL<,  -L  -I oj a-Il  Is  1988 J!  JL
zA -JI jL^--J i JL.- 40.60 SL~ 0.50 ,.,L
.0.20-0. 1 8 
0.24  ,   s,1 0.43 Le  ,,-a-6 kS > ,? j  J,,  1985 -~-
>5eS1s+1 90.30,ialU  + 
i;USI a2t J 1     0.50 j 0.28-
,,S~~~~          L-J I 1 -klJ I  ' jL J   U-Dy S I 
1J1 J se u,j     - OSS.J21 Z Wij OIGQl   '-
j;-kd Jj 91  (2000 L5L-S' jFe  ;N zL5.  4J -I 3 JIi-C.
LJ I%!    jl     ;1<1      CjeJ 
Ip)    254      j Ll    I     ij �L1
Ju j yL   o   r1,       l      jiJ CzLuJ  a-o  -+(1988
254



mi~~~~~~~~~     rE  _ t.  K.  %K  VX  fL f  - W 



U> tJ A4LJ JJWi M tAULI O;JI j -0  Z
, \ 11jli 1 993 j1987  olJ jA_,E 
Y�l          ylj .L-�1 UA jW 0Ji
.(2000    i->  oJ 
W        I J ALW s-         ..lJu  a,1j 2  -
*>j~ o+JIa3'  -:.! *(1999 j y 3t - )JSL '1993  4)  j   jg u
U }zuJWI 2o% ee9l JS 16  ; \JI g- <5UU 1   . >1
(6) ay  ; 1  pl ;256
yl J -S1 si  J 1 J,6     ULJ1,1d  e5X
u a; s J, 6, .(7)( 2000  O>) < Xi:
~~-Ul ~      ' HjCy C d      19
256



ALJI MS g :1  S oAbUY I M 1
_r1 J21 L- %  s1 
C L I 21 --  1 5 1  .i  I   -! I  X--  y- aI 
-si 5 jy~~~~~~- *~J~A  ..-jl -.L
L  WS ~AJ I  ji o-s.JI  4  -Jl L3  199 '   -
() j 93-5 AsJ 
La--Y~            1 
,BJ> ,$JI aL jSA JJ-L  2    Js ,j 1, 25I
.~~~ ~~~~    Z-.YI -JIDI !J 5lWJ  LD  1995 _+iWY 
~~~~~~~J,,2Jl  UL-k     (      JI<2_ )1-LI j  l
257



ii ;c2  JjaJI@ li  z*J1  i 1,Wi :3-5  1~~
1995 s~4L&Yl       jL-J'D          1995          -,.;Jb 4 L,26 
150                                   1.25
125
0.75
50 
25                                    0.5
5.5   6.5   7.5  8.5  9.5  10.5       5.5   6.5   7.5  8.5   9.5  10.5
1995 ij    4J�     k                 1995 j4s    o,6uaL-D
160                                   1.50
120                                   1.25            .
80                                   0.75 
40                   .               0.50sN
0                                  0.25     _ _  _   _ _  _   _ _  _
5.5   6.5   7.5  8.5  9.5   10.5 0.25 5.5    6.5   7.5   8.5  9.5  10.5
3-5 JJ, &A3
258



4  -ii                         0  A.
4    .  f~-3 _,                   to :?, b   " 
-1 ~ ~ ,  *,  oR? -l  q  3j  A-~- 2 1  to  n 4 
iJ           I  - ) t  ? qj ' ;  9n 3 )q8  Z+ 
>~~~        ~~~ #. ?  -J *~  %      ? 
~~~~4             -          -;Z     .-  nX - gz
(N  -  -  0  0          t: t1.,,~   -n   N.  1 - 4 j
-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
ON  .4~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~3
ON   _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _~~~~~k
0N



.iJ  31 \  Jy-l 911  ! -+- 3<1>- Jll 
u-- ~        s-    X,    t; 4  \ J-bS 'L;J
%4U   L,,9,J1 jS  -5J1 Zj-iL: 9j~c Jj~ j,1  4,  ;i L I1-C! :.)L!
-3 JF  ? . J2! Wi , ,J <- W l  Ji   J!,s wil;+ .
9- .:_;JI 4J- 2/aj  &L JI.J-LI  lhw U   J1 432i LS 
*EJI ? SAJLih",ls 1  I (I (-2) Oj t 4
. w9 jjul JM   4;.@ji 5WJ Z<I @ Xla 4-5 JS:
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0.04
5.5  6.5  7.5  8.5  9.5  10.5
.   2 L   ,   L.2I aL   I ,   p
l;I   ULj WISTAT (1998) _ i  ,sLcL JIG26
.(,1999)  ,
260



YF .l(9)uzca 1e-\-11 l
A  '~~   j~ Zi-~p  }�i  J <J  ~i-~ :-Li 
lj a diA oG UG,-l 61 -11 Sk w- aLI)1 IL L- *
if N1 J ,1 29G -S1(1999) 9 Y 1 
-I .                  A 4  9  e iM -Jewi + tv  1A
4 w5 -5t , 127 a aUY  L    i    1 i
j3 _j1  _ j�F ; L1 Ji  92 f; US IL J S  Ui,
-(10)
- ;, s- Ji J --si  -i A  g    j >S  L  I
j~~~~j
~-     -'          I-   j   - IJ,O s;JJll
j~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~4
i (1970) ,     j; e 4  y f  >      A iy
K IWy<>19~ J19 J j         p t
* L42-Ja jlj- L) ~7-jji )L 26 j1jL j1  p y
261



1  4JT 11 ;vS1 11! ;ULJI JK,l i;  aJ W  1
&r~  j~ ~4 -~ zj~, ktn4   ~ A ~UI-L
J~~~~~~~  ~ ~ ~ ~~~ 
j Is e)i <u   -laqj1 ,;H . oL,l ,11   S  ay  J l  1  W\J 
262~~~~~~6
L..    __- X1   .)Y  Z-+  -6  1 947-1 ,,  j ,F 
-,, l  j .  ".54
H1 ,.lxJ -iJJi  -5,  eI 4;OLJIj   41  u,rJ ,
LI~~~~~~~~oY 'IJ , jydtbll
1,l ajl J) z J) ^= 4: dt j  J
JL- P:ii "-Jl              1 4 !.-  Joll !iJ 
~~~~~~~~-j j      ;1Wlo1Gjl2 L 5 
.(99 1~dj  980  4970  y) 17  j8  )DAL  ^
262



~~~jiz L>)v       L561 L-,-L   o Sj  ,1  Ltyl,ji O > 2L
y.wS 9   A ji   1  9 41  J 19   J9}3, (JUA,) sLJ
J51 ~L4  i        -J-J I 4   ~ -a ; AL-J ,l~
i-S +  J  i    t1SJJY~d' L -Y j J  &&  6X Gj L, L J _U-
91 i.U~ A 1 21 ? Si OU 3  j ,
.(2 -5         yj.,- l a4.JL  ->Ji   < ,Ji  ,  WKX-
JU0 ,Cji~ 56S9  k4     1u     sS   L      i
J -, f x18J9 , 9i -U7  7 41  j LI-
* 1t;Y46 -l _-x ~j'. LA iJJ 2  2    >
.1ylJ 4-JI ol ,3L              I ,L-,,
.(2-   1               jLi263
2~~~~~~~3          - > 1  kxAJ 5rrl:l Zs,XL- il.:--YJI
1S5 i1 a91S-  2 i  l    9   i212631 



j J~W3 49  i- J       c2i 1880 1850 ,jH U o;il) J -'
4� Za2l Jj-&  j .(1977 'A3 tj1) 1920Q 1905 H U
CIWYI 1 ,>  YI!  L1 ;I ,! ,u  1   J}1  Z-21
174   Le ? 21-, 15 Jj; _  ,-d@1iI !lj       lJI
174 j~~A ~~ ~ is j~~ ~ ~jm  .J- i~J j L-w i- jLU
.(2000 eLEY     C7 os 4tSi H) ol  YI j ;SLlasi XJj
,J 21  1^  L4Lt  -< l _E-!l  fl# 12eSe  l;:>t,E  J
p51 1_-j.)     W . 19 J s Xy) 1  s I y4 j 96
~ El *x;^,- -Jl ,>LuJu4i ., I  ;1  
. )9 �  1 j LJ1 .2    -5jc 1r Q   Lz2 
z-lL 29u  ZI WsA ,<5:J  a b jlj .J(1995 fDjg)  blJtJ  <5j9  J
VI.LZ<:J.t,>  .(  1999 ;3-JJ  !, W-) 1998 CL,, iflu 48 j11960 CL,-
,_521 aLeyy jl-U,l  1 -Le iSj L 1 I1 i< au1! :. y LJ  -
t-Si 9S y 1! ,j'i  L ,<L  +  5 X  1r4
i  ec 1X 1J1 L3J---sy ,Li- _y Xi,  .&LJI a_j.  1j-)  , i L J  :v5-J
1  ? J<YI  S  liA  (  te! .>a'LS- - &   -,L   i jX  -, l
,       ! lLl      -u:l vclyl (1992) <.olj ilu+
2-5 ajLLall Lu6
264



91 ? 1An 5f s lj JL )l _5 WJI!+~ 491 t-1
L_~~LiL<-il ~  oL ,i~ uall A   J 9! Llui  oAc sl
-i .(1992     - + U41 ; 2 JU
a- tg      wouillJ JLAi 4J  s l - t; ceJu1948 L1 i o$1
a 57 w  LW -A J 4    16 
1 J S ~~~~~~49i 4UL kl1 Jy 
10 y f N  -&1975 CWl J i>! *41- 2J-J IILI JCl_ L,> 56U- Liv;4W
.(0995 iJJ)Cj  J3  J  St<,GzJS _L&     ai
_iJI<,:Ll ls9J 4- 4><;1 NJI o�1996 j 1994
Jj~~
J1 uSAJ JyMJ y ElJ rG^ Jij gw2biJ lc  K1t F 
.(1999 i> 1 = I !L fS?1 
5Li 4       ;I X-L U   9     . 4;1� 96 JK1 9Nl
265,, -   LI   .3   1  5L  D
"Yil !,3 jil<:Sjj < 
j                                  as _P~ A aI >S.11 m28!a  l 5bJYL 
~~~~~~~~~~l5            I!9 L<     j    I! 1Xy!aL1Se lL
.(3-5        Z_68 49eJ 
265



.J~w~>L7 J�z   A ~     3 jU lg  l
L4              , - J4 4JI JKS 'J,Z JL l  J
1990 >11965 it  J   i.T        1,'    5
4r~ A e G j!AI   ?Fr Jj     LT    . il , 23 O2
i     JZ 1960 -     .1 ,  (1993 SJdII =1 4) ASj kYj%-
~Ji-                                            j y~~jt 
:-, L,   L- (S1 T
; Zy~J -   y;S Q         ciKS WS .!  1 1 <LAI &AW O
>1~~~,      Lg       j,       ai)y  Htjb  XG oly
j ;    1990 1   il 18, 1980 CLp Z,4 13 JL 1965 �;- ial 8 U
10  � ,y 6 A jS- j .(1996 &. ji: '1993 JJJI ZL>) 53 I
1975 k> 11 JI J2' , sL) 1975 CA  Ji I fL WJ  
L*L - oj>p 1995 CLp 10 J  . 2 H oI (CI j 1- ,Y!, .U1
.(1997  ,JI j3 USi- i  L- I L; ,26
266



Lwi " jwiGs3-5S. .,
aM, - Iw 
I I, .                 He G         , j 1O>L5L 
4iL   4i -i &9-,  C 3L  Z,
1j   i, ?  jl5   ,    1    -- L11i  LS- I  L- g C9
as A >J .4o jZ- 4o i j. sS j2 Ij.J 5  ~JU-
~~~~~~~ ,S 2, W~  - 8x U 2._,-J L,|o UU S Jl
j                  I-L, LiL ' U A  C-  1   - U  1 :- o 5
j4s      _",p(:   s  I, 
J S~~~~~~-y 4J+;J DIy -iy i vSj4,; .oii J pi 1
9           oDJ - i LA Z _Jf- -i:'T
,z.L,UJ i j .3 a   .. l .u   1    U
L 5
,  Fji,   jL    LL?j a4<� �e --  O. 
-L-.41 zL4 L,Oj uE  :;hLJI _1  ;gJ olj <c o989
,c  -  Lz '!-J :-j i                 L-- o5   LIavr  <J  (98  jP
JLljJ eJ;7 U, >Jb JS aJo JXL-JI ZL-WI 5>l591p  aDlj
-. .(2000 -'L4J) s JJ 41J51 t l JI ?. ?
267



,-  ,.J�1 9  SI :>91 a  ;y,I - J  J    L -" i -
jL .(2-5 JJ+1-4-l y3aiLJ   a   iW.~, ,  jLsj  iL3-26 jI L2 ,i 
ji * i: � JSyl Ji- ' < j  5LP> 
39  ~~~~.1970      Jj -L 0.68 J, 0.37
S 19W A; JI~L2I H - ^O>E>I41O& 1
1 OLij)6 -(2-5                      4  b31z  ,k G268  L. lL
L -    JL 41 jl~JI ,L1l1 ZL-I. jv "L-.l        1995 >1bWj<  .
~Jj.)yl L,4 -3   J.U
,1~     ~ 91  196 J LS Z41 65YI,   ;,1;J J v,
-i yl ZKt    > 0-)c  au S Jl ZL-L--JI Ls1       <- u
-_U1-J >L    39Xj. ,:17 ul j   .2ya)� JL
!  (- Jl#) S!      8   GuSw      63-2 ej!>U 
J t_AL 41 ~~~~~~~~~~~-         3 1 J_ 1- Jl>lJ;_l<>-195   �
<_Xi <>X-^ G,>e J,>y dil 21  03 68



L1S                                                   aJl sf6>19 w jj
.(1993 ,,196                  JL1I -g,  48 1
jDYL ,3LW l   E        ,J.LS- IS j.;T JJ j    S SL    G J  4,7$ ~LL
,L--.i      l x       C 2 Jl ZL-W       z         -rj I)XJ 3 oA 
U-- L)    (14)Jl
D%Djl 69  : .(1996 OJ)1988      4- ll 59 S11968 CALp  48 
51    L-di, 42    1988-1984   -0,: ouJllS J9vSl ,N1 sl_ 4
1995     1980    1970                           L4 J
37       34      35                              J    f
40       35      30                                  1.
41       38      39                                     ju1 l
40       39      32                               YSf K9--M
37       34      31
37       35      33                                     lWl
39       35      26
46       47      48                                      -- 
1 999)
269



jL - ' 4jwfX >J 
L..Lj, i  -, -4JI   zr IJ1      L._Ji           :
34.2      61.2       4.7        1970
42.8      56.1       1.2        1980
66.3      33.0       0.7        1990
83.4      16.4       0.2       1997
24.8      10.0       65.3       1970            Y- Ui
31.8      12.4       55.8       1980
31.1      12.5       56.4       1990
39.4      15.4       39.6      1997
57.0      27.9       13.0       1980              6l
62.2      26.8       8.3        1990
67.0      23.3       5.8        1997
35.9      23.1       37.5       1980
48.7      29.5       20.0       1990
23.7       9.9       66.4       1970              UjL
33.0      17.7      49.3        1980
51.8      22.7       25.6       1990
56.0      29.8       14.2       1997
22.0      11.9       62.8       1990              1U
31.2      16.6       50.8       1997
._e1 SO i at  O i, . L 100 ,  t  V y
1999)
Lx---li aiA-ii 5i SUt M! i   J :L  -l L" L 1 t Q270
270



~~~~~ri      t    -),   * &  --' OfL l- .I  ,L  J4 1 .oIj - Ji --j  *UC   b. 61~
1 ic)Si      JLtL- jL5 . ~- ji <, -k2 -01    W aS
j . S iAL 479 .(1996 JCjY# )  c L Aj}i1 i
1-1 U,  9'li1                -,A y i's   s;H1 ULP  A+,P .
~~j  ~   ~~:Ui  -LYj (L) ,  ~ 9 .3 
;,>Wt! i,tylys sIjSylj G>yl 91  2i S J U. '  UDi
..1997   J 5 1995.4g1 2i Ji)
S L5. ifL4 sy jiSuj2  JGJ -y       jl L>
<:110    ;   ;11997  < 1970 ,? ie J :;1z  J e9 >
J~~~~~~ -t) x+ -yY~ I 11  .AS 9J j 11 4
4+1 ,otjl j !.+     yI,j 9t JL-'LJ Js!CI e
1 H 3 .JX      l>l 1  8  e 1970  CSJI Wi  2.1 <iLJI! G jULJ(19
5.4  1-  JiLAiJ2l !   J-S   1-7  4-3 271
. 1.7 L;1 5.4 - LIUj 2-8 
31o1s_5 -   C           S.Xl 1di 9
<!~~"LJ J L  6jSS,e -X )  Y:Y sL slJj z jI 9iliJ
J 41u OJJ.(1981 j"J-)         4vL Pi 91yJ 
JlJ ) 4 1 JaE ~l                         _5  3  oAl lL >5>
. (1997
271



-M~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~U       4   1 SGL-J I  L-,J'So9 sX S
L xl   1.)    1 > ,5  J lellAtJj 5! (1985 as  j-
:,L   5 4,j U L2JI - c1990 ; UJ X j J  j   j
.A  toj 37 4Jut U L   Jrl~l  1JUSyl 4Ac _jI Juidi J 5N
U.o 5 w%liJi n  JjAL .tJI CAi 1986 c JL21 L) j>_I J
'LW 7 L5               sJ >y-        26, jLPL-
.(1998 L)jwa 43 p3)
j -     ,   JA  1 j  Jll JIt li s 1- ,jWl
-   -I J > L I  La I i   ' L  i,1 LW   I
CA 3JJI W:) 19~U 3  l Ll j Ji  J  S -,  19 U
JFj 1k     -d I,4oi   5A11   o J iL<k I1y L;)1  11  , Jlj L I <.a I
J1                           _ 't 1,b  r ,j X- 1
C ~ ~   :dl JLW  01>   4j 
JL~rU iWU 1, ,9 ,3JI CJI� pi) JU rjlu UiJ j A
18.2 ! i  18-1998 J; 1995 > 1W1 J> Ly3 .  sl5
7.9A  ) 8.9 ,1998-1999 r o .iI JU-A  -,-yl CAS Us  -A du
272



o; J> U L1 JM >    oJl9 }^Y :+ J4
1997   - J-L   �PJ~~-
si 4S.-4 iJ-El -'-  .(1999  , L.99 j�j) J .) J
J        L-J iLJ- j  jLj. iy   j a  W9f ji  
Uai J   J9 )i J  U  L.,  LA 4   .(199 y j
21997  1997 4199 .r 3Al JLA- .     *-.
ziSL_L ;LJI _4z 9 j  1998 CW1 J 94Wl JL,Xl Z-_- 'vS:
l C U~L_z20 J� ,_l JI 45   1LWJI 4__ ;
a_,j32) U L_t  J  z  1998 :Lk; Zid 24.9 31 1994
1  s>91  ; +> b? jU 4e_m zZil S!.(1999 j j
u9 , .' -d L'iL jLl3  Rl ,L  ;  .(1999 O,T
i lJigl  j syl ,3 sl;ll! 4Jl1i y-. >A F4  -'j. 12 LJ 7 jr e
:)y) 1998 CL^j, 4 (1999 J16  LL+A sJ -> 13-9 @
iJL) jz ISl L Jg  Z-L<~ ijI b j tJ(1999 7
1! ~1997 41998 J:-A, Y    ,i i\I<sJ
,, 5 l;,5 sIS iSjY ,iJL- j   '.- @?ju  l J-L"  iJU 'jia
'D j_^=U  j5 L-,_.U Li  *: u Lii l -ju i i_,5  12 L31 7  J
c  7 & LI~jj .!(1999 J4LJJ tAl)i_1-9W . .
273



yt+LeJ -l  J-        4�J JL L4 1!   Wi Ju kjlJ I 
.(1999 i;q6) SU~~~~L5_ l L5Lc1 :sLJ   9 1 k1 1J i
iU  1   a. Iy  S jl     U >  Ll) 
9 .(' 2000  9 Ls  � ie Ij ,  J-a  i(9 ;,JI  J1
g<, i1  SJ $L;J  ?  J$  JlS  \ C JX -0 9
1 1-J         -u-I   jj Z <   y l .:,L   IjJI :,- s  - ji 1-l
iy >j1 Jx L+,  1  su L1 u AU
1 #w
-i ~ ~ -t
: .,L                ,-)24l
- slal_ jj *(1996 3 J8glll)1<-IL 9>
-  LAju,  iLIJ  IJI 5L-W l j, 'i  Z- JIj I D Ll,5!
274



yl + 'g1 1A1 ir4 31 > S 9 31 1 sE
a         jL5- t.i L. iJL - i
L4    4 i� J  l JI  -  J8 Al ,  jWl U  lij L
)  , y <I  jv  A  JS: .'-  *y 1 -91 Cr  3   ~9
- ji   LJ,y W J, ) <,0>i oi Yl .U1.1987
S  >n1  ll<_a-_i_         P L o6lS25 e jl 
-G  J_ , -u  *;uyl  -  -b ~i 
7.,' 19 +- ,k ,LA 9 J<
275



oJLcl sY5-j .(1999  P~-. A1996  ij4 -)) >      JLl
(1 L)-=J  L- '  ,  l  D,g} 
;~~~, ,1S L- ,J       o     1tw U2~1 , a 
cu1 r1 Jn su1XL  >, lp    (1999 JL"-Xg,;55JJ D
k-,- ~  -G-Y                L  -- 
L5   I ~                                  jU 
4a . LUS ;L i 
JI Jil L1 >! 4.Jyl -" j   Jj             L1  I
Ujj! .(1988->-5   1J1            I-,Jl eby    y 
+ MX1 P  j F e12Y Ji4Z1sJJ1-5k l-JI ,i  s I - < (1994
Ji  '  L  4yl  S  b.  MS i, 91 J iyl okX1~l LL, L-~j 
.(1995 ~)gytTi ~LLP) a,;sL Xj          J-i, 9
2000     jLL     y ,1996 Jjl             .:., J 1   1L 
276



,;-~   .(1999  ,>!-U~ ULj  JL-.-J   JL-9l a< gA 
.1991 Lc- Z-6 8,6 311987 Lc- a- 19  UU ja 5.l .taUyj  -3
>3 JJJ i  ,!191 L WiH ,JI eSl  L3 11 -,J.41>e8L~
,+JI L3ilO i L1996-1992  iJJ cljp_'li
.(1999 *Ji  +)S     ij <8 r
;\,1 i v ,gl 3 Y,i ,,1 i,2iLb       LS, 1,4  J:
-,1 ,p,111t sg1 u-J 1990, 1 9 85 5  ilJ;9
(3- ,$1                                  --j 1i vA  1fa+1o  H!Bl;
'v4sl Auz  +  1S  zi ,  i <, -141> 311980 
A8)  1  ,1  i? Js ;1,l e  u v1: ~~-%  C>5 Ju ,
277



18~~~~~~-      JJ   !-   1,  :U L   N -   Jj  (3  J$
-4< ~  ~    ,921 n-4  C-1  1  e
j~~.5 j       << 
. _ lyl! ,SJ1Jz t;yleglS alUF11 >1980
jj Jul i e LL-  j.Jl > i>
. (5-5
;, sJi \ <>inI OU inL s (1 >l L  J
3!l,    1970 c      JJ2l, t9tA HI 
i e! L) 1997 c  -< 1,x 
.-sl Ji-d fuL  - 1?a    >J    3
278



t.&,s%%ai14                                " '- ^l >s ilOI Jt@- iL   5j- @ 5  5 �
;wl-L"D  )Wl UL-?P
80                  .                1.0.
60                                   0  6.8*; .......      -- ' ...............
t _o---------------- 0~~~~~~~~~~~.4. ........ ...... .
0.8
0.4
0.2
01970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995        0 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995
25                                     1.0
20                                    0.8
15                                    0.6
1004
0.2
0                                     0    _    _   _    _    _    _
1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995           1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995
,,fj _4, f,~~~~~~~. ........... ...,4
iL! _ ~~~~~~~~~........... ....,v
-         ,f.,
iazu - o.
5-5 JJ &q-
279



55                      1.15
50                ~~~~~~~~~1.10
45)  >< '   0    �             <   ' .~~~~~~~........
1970  1980  1990  1997   1970  1980  1990  1997
f i   s,  .            ............ ............
ot!  -         ~~~~~~~~~........... . . 
JL, -4               j
~J.Uv J,sW, oL.Y aUi,g&1 JS t)k  1 j@1~ )1 :s'~
jj-L-JI ~ ~ ~ ~   ~   ~    .(199 j2  1JJ  :,1J
vLyl S I  Jis 0 v  J o,5 J,s aWJ 6
&--J jj -L 1  j  I. I -d IJi L5 ,L   11 JGj 4-LJ Ld<
L.                   4,!U JyUW .QT 1994 ,11 Ji o,_)
280



.s�tl~~~~~~6 _.  & J  G  i  ;A 1        i      5A
r!                 'DUS eA~~~~~~L<1 )L  '9 Y
O1e_                 ,,fSl 31 DBYC14__'~l L
60                            1.1
55                            1.08
50                            1.06
45                             1.04_
1970    1980   1990   1997    1970    1980    1990   1997
.2   .A<  Q (T1994) J,W  LY )M .1991-1987j 1986-1981  ? a>.
.41J5W J21! j SU5UY6') (1) j1 i JaU
(1 999) !  1:1
J    >   9 J~Ji~U 9     8  4dJ 14L  .(6 -5 J.<.-.�Ji) L< L ^ii
"YJ                                             LQ L. L"-, iJ  4  j  3  1
;     t ! (1980                   L)JI L. zUbk  J 9 1* W) o  - J
281



,F a,1 , u S > ,yl z a1, jF(1999)
1               E- tsF ~~~(2000)  J  jW          >
s   y11! ;F-lJI H F  <y ;1  >vy ol_lli oTl jtL  L:t LJ
9; ! JzEl 441 J8+YL oj~~~~ i
,11 F 1- 1-llJ         1             %Ll 59>SJ
aj~k     LJI 3 ~ j. -Jl Ai > \P :,;SN t IjJJ F
iS ,kI <  J  EJI 22j1J;11 'I VJIL) o  l  1  bl5
;SLi       aLll<y ,ll , - j 4;oi>282l 



� ,a1 , . - ,  j3 bi Jr. j> y t  G
- vilS uiI 9-   L:,  J,i a 2  27  _ J j
-ui o1,- J,s'l: 9-j u1,  >  Ji A ,<
j~Wi  j 1.L LLI.~  jt -i  L 
-(L99 I -L  Jj Lx* 1  Ul L oJI Z jL  J�1 I  c Ip �
J
JL,.  4,j>  i jj-:! 5Xi  : ,  sYI 3 :  lUNl
L)           - JJI -      -LJI iJAP SI  i J- .o
-($4L~JI ;3LEl 9,I  3  JW 1"; kLJI  Ji  I  LZ.ASI U! ;JW b
L    X J9 U ! ^j>I i>U JjI A,-;l J_1 -Ji
L11 DF- L8   L+Ji A  34  J , L4Jyl C 4L1J ;v: G  .CaJ~ JL-)j 
Jo JI  SJ.-  +RLI Ji l:jy,L   1 l J .l
(20) ~ ~ 28
.4+i,Ye  L5 -ju   L1!  aJ  L-;l Z.Wi  alJ
>L-JJ ;ij  ou L-A j9J Jll,1 EIziJ  otlO
*-~~~~~~   J llj  1 O   1   1   y  -I
(26)lyl ol283sX,i, v,EiJ l



ie   ;L61  ,  -jIu1            c  :., L. J-,l j   4a- -S!   GRl oMs 
- r>  (4-5 Jj_;U42,gl        26J      Jj;        i 40
_>jja_Ji 11L- Oe a4L.JI  ,L1J z_C 1970  1J  O     1
1995     1980     1970
41       36       34                              U
3 5      25       3 1                     z_1 
48       47       46
37       39       33                      "i j
40       37       34
51       48       46
40       40       41
38       3 1      24                            L
45       46       47 7y
41       44       46                            YK,
47       50       47
49       44       36                     y�-A i  ,&  e
45       45       33
46       48       45       (Jz)                i L-T  s - L ' 
40       35       32           },      Q Y#')   -
.1980, 1970 u  j        A        Y- , J,,S -s
L< -JI'1 L- OL u       L     Abp  ,Yl zUL �Uij' o -i L _L
. y  _z   1980, 1970 >ALJv
2(8999)
284



i' 91 ~J -iJ :-L5 >JL J;j! u  <llSt 
jk  tL1 i at992  -y~  - -2l 4 s_4Z
;S1 l,iAJ (992 9  a+> i J;9l CH O AJI! (yl 9
36-,L -J sl2 JI5LC )j  lJ? Si i-)U j -Jl 96~l ;S J j  ~lj s;L;J2J 4X1s a
3  A W3 sll 7                 23 A  IQ -  11�cW
i ;llJSsl;$!Jl i! 4J1aJll v164-25l g A1JJ
_,gl!1< nl!<1 ,cl4Fv Sj y4:  197 28590>



J~~~~~ s1 oy X .>1 Jj�t 4. 1s +1iI 
J            J9  C-  OJI ~~~~~~~~j,6jl 9,,   5 O5 u,- 1
,,, , <r,1 ,, -jj .1990 L*J I+ LA L,_,Z3Lj-l A:ZY
1990 \L-.Wl -u 4U 'Y ;1989 Jl 1980      L oii  J L  ULJ', JU6l
J1980 0L-i -I L- a    80 Sj 40 J),  U-U; L- C S-
<4  <J- Gg o pL15- ->ja1 9l  ,!L~  i(7-5 J<,g1l) :uJ ..  s
.(2000 ;j0)  joy  ,, JlJ E ;oipl  a      > ,, 2I4
!~-� (LW� 15 k Juyi aJ&~ yri ~Ll -           ,r L-Jl J�3 L.
LcI 7 J! I     Jl    J -aL 25 JW U L1985 CIJI , O1JJI Uj
AS�! OLEJI j3  !    L     Jx~  ;LJI    I! U i)-j .1990
4L 68.9  :~ 1   4
9  oL ,,W ,vus �11 e 5J:i,l, IrjJI 23! *,�
? Xi!  g1! D+1! ;osJ,ky Jx ,31d.j . l  L   !
tJyl tuA1  1  31J-l  si                       ZL)l1  > J v^  4
*(1997 ,ssUl kI Jlj)XJ\I J OW286
286



L8Z
1  w  S�  I> ,r  Irm(tR' lClf  S)(6661)
9661 b7661 Z661  0661  8861 9861 b7861 Z861 0861
uc
w4y1*  '-----------                             ~~~~~~~09
......... . ''''''''''-'  *                             001
O-71
9661 b7661 Z661  0661  8861 9861 b7861 Z861 0861
OZ
..........                      \*09
001
4> sr (ncrlSqnC(0861 =001)
1 { f  L: C1   r   W  �Avr    1       IfOE IM fz
4�fC er rier(q:iN  >f^  [  661)-
l7=te)� ~ ~  ~   ~    l~g C1'v4T(n: -F8  #   6660) [SIfe   1[i> :



z    Jll  zJI (2000 AA * 3j) '1999 sA) Lk,51  jlj l j( 2000 .'  _irjJ p ol;J5
(H1Aj 73 J 54) xJ~JI n   ~L 66J J2J' 37 ,Jiy) 45k 9pG  K l,J J
JXYl L LC L p1 DYI WXG<1 Ep ngaY ,! oll Jj8 J (999 3j+ g
J oX141t a99 o1 sYIl aJlj .(2000 Jj Tjg
(2 1 )l999&  _ 2A) y W SG   .9 Ji 198  j
WIJ 10    -  4  ,   ,A'    10  1995 1LU J-5   .;1985
L5_  :J G5G      ag       Jio LS1ols;
S til ~jL--5   .(1998  )bJJ;sU,J3X J ;i  W -j1
,-   lj L        W3 I ,              40 .
;1 1 673JC J YI  L-11  73  5G|'  Jj~l  DIUil! J  5I  L
1 990 \ pG 4G| 7|  +  J9,l    , 7
L I  64  j  I9   I1  1   G 1!>- Jy  JLi-l jil
1  E  Le-Nl sS ,.Ll - I Z! JI ,3 J ! o--J  , I ; i
41      1   isl 120 .|1996 �G, a-51al ZJ2 J 
(   73 w 54) jL-JI  (Udl,J 66 LI! 3 7 y  i<Zgll _Jk
:1-11 L3                  jjl2E s  3 .1996 L1 1980 j?oil,
i  1  -\ t 1 ,FJ -(SSSI J-di S  U6 40 ?X
288YI JXl CD,
288



-~~~j 9v z&J1 >SaosA9Jl!eS1 g
, yli  -JI &-3 �f J l } ;Ji 5L o  .(2000 Ai IjT
i 289     L  L i I
a-2cj   JLies,+  ;L1    v  !1999 j 1i
*;S,9 dyl Ss I ? i~~~~JL  L1 1eD}
J  1  w 1JLl � jIj 91 499 t21 <  jL.aXi
L~~-vJI J-aa1 ,gltDlb!J
,:X! VSl J :>1 5,iEl 91 1y ? ;S~~~~~~~~~~ir vX
iSi  J1 CeXl  i l  J1 4-ylj%Dy  X 1 tji428999 



,~~~~~~~j~~~      L-i X151' >L  JA    L59 Jp  -s,-,, 9,
- ~  ~   j j,4-11sA  aH 
- -8 t-.t1 S J  myl! j;1 91 jp j-41 si 2,j 
k,v L,9 JU.4,1 ,, olJLLI �4JF,,,1C       <> 
JS~~~~~~~~~~L--       at  ,,  c  9Jl j> JL-_.,   L-9
4i>J *J9yl i! SJ-,                zJI -J       1>;UNsJ
L--j~~~~~~~~~~~ IJ 4L II =o Ill;~
tJw e; 41 JbF9l o6 -au1 ozgl ,w~L         oj 
-(i  >J1) 5Jl i/X  U G_^.JI JS290       4



}W3 1                   > - ,
W J a- 'AY U  : L J   -  -l
~~�LU ~AyJLJ; ~LW *L _! ; ,   JL4-5 Jj XL11) X,
8-W~ yl  L1 osJ  3 1p 9'Y J 
\j,l OJSI  J !2l91
}j-,-J  u-,  j);i L>Y  <  I ,IJ j W;1OS 1 
2 _ S 4I 91 



L } )Li ,  -L
4lJ ,1;zY3       5>
j L5- 1995 <JY J -l < -   iW    U1     i
j) ii J -  L-J I it 1997  sc  :L  -Lj
. 80     JW9 $i      3 3 o t _
3sS 9f1 Jd _S L 1 uLJ a   ;4 2 -i jj
-w  d,986  - t L.   9 9 .  ,  JL  
3   g   Ji SI            3sy 14ef a 1sg- silj
', jL~W *~~iu99 it 1988 
.(1991  LlJ -  9. L,)
292



/J .(1999 L1  i  jL1 "2-j-M15 i)Li 1997 2
UA i US -i     W 2'   -a
j .}WI C-  ~  ~fL-J J  I J1YJ  L L-JI
3o s9j t,Y         J~ Al 41 4   j,i g86 .,!  K4ry z 3
W? LS ~-jlS _e4,yl ol j_9   -1 1 a
<0j                                   -45I 4  4-3S<x  g 5l- sJ uilJ9;
:  *$J jQ
,= J ~~~~~9          ,2       1 ayi ;V n ,, 2 X 
w1!~~~l tj LJ  1  rb  s  t1   y5e y-
1tl 3 1  Z,4& 81                     -4 S   _
293



;-,tAi  A$,uyiI .,U.R3  ,   l   l (1999) ,,L&K, S �  -'  -5
L~UW! t. J-  Ai,,         4 1977 ,U r
�--A C�3        J - j 1A J 9 ' j:  L J.L j 5 ,  - 6
-19L ~2~ J+1 31W 41  ;1ODi }�  O 9 Orj 
>~~ O u,    -jj j y j   jr J 6   91 -  4J J e1  H Jij
liJzl UbLz ji ,  5 .(1999 3j bjj -))JL4)   (19 9 9JI  JIp   ; 9
-L-J                     -
H;1 1 J ,rli JI ,;L1 *A,
1 Jl ( ,1998) oa z�jL >   , > .   -7
<71  * +  <J Lc-  laA1   L,3 ..j al Jl --,JI ol; J   XJLtJ .:Ai1 W  -8
J 1 J olLlJ 921 y  ' - 1    cA (1999)  -u j -9
j6--JI Lll :.,LJl jL>J ; Zij  i   I 0>29
4s',J- oei.-1L (2000)  i   _1,.al11oJX
L-,, <1 .~J  :    S , U  l : i 1995 f11975 WI c fi
Lj J 41(1998); J< i< 9S ,iJ 
_? >lci L Di(2000) 1: ,jX 92<u
.(1994) ol  U  J  -J
.GS1 a>S1 a-! ?  aSS1Si a-(1999) a
294



,;  Jl; jl~ Lwa L.5_L s! Al LLyjI-dilJ;  1e
Kt).~~~~~~~LL
.,5,4;iEl trLill ~Ai9 Ws 3-5 J�J) S  ,  -L -
30 1 9 } Luc- Li -J I j -L19 U_I z y 1 c  J'L-12
47 1975 41997 J 1992 :  joWl1987 J 1982 (1 
u1 -~ J_E t 65 yJ .(1999 jjY  > Ij LjZ -_j1 a 1 <Aj;9 1
~~K. ~~  ~LJ ~~  J j W; 4Q-AL j;
.(1994 jI :A <LA-JI L'Iji
a!                 >5J@1 ausI S1 3 >1 ._ <  a  J-  JJi -13
47 41975 �21wl j S  t!21 J 9 J. ii  (IL bl:>(997) -.e,j~
51  i1990 :WI ij ill 47 i1985 �Ll Jj  45 c1980 'WI  '
J +1x il >1 Otg  1  <Jj4>i U >1;JNJ-14
5 iI J> v 65 J)I Jll,- OlJ4,25 
5ji~~~ 11 jl  D 4iy .(1997  i3yr)'jJj *)1992j 1978 s
L v s J; CE jUdl-JtisJi               C17 :5 i_
J,~~~~~~z+_ LGI Zibk1 J9L-,  ,MJI
.(2000Ja)9=I;~S
Q  g(1996) J!SI JL-j-J  -,ulgyJ (19)SSS!5  -16
gw2l J-uI ; A J2l j Y S Cj  g (1999) ez
295



JJI X J js� ,3  t uL:-l _jU ;ADy 63l  L,- C-1
.,1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~)   ukL> Y   j21 -Ol  JI  _L-21
ki o     8 L,-'~fI  jj ), 6  1991-1987 , 1986-1981
LLps J~ eU :li   J I 4 9JI y - J   (T 1994 J J�AJl)
i  >; J! :~s~,�IlU >I JS ab Ij J1 a   Jj-x (1994)
I~l- -j LL<i' -  'JL  45J   J�I  Li Y
1986- 2: JS <JI , 4L z.JL, i   J
J,;  jg ll , Lk o t,::cI 4sbk wa   iJIl WU  J6  .1991-1987i 1981
jJ;>l,11                  _J i S5  sILJIl L-J  sL jl
:1990-1975 ~~-          Y       J~~
1 j    il JjU UJI          QJ J 1 >   -U , i1L-
)5  I  1  JU  -
LaY 11i_1!LlI  J   X>,Ji L5JJU  l, 1 L  9
y~~L  Zl  U ~LLr .z-  s~j ~ ~     ' -20
~~L6J-i ~ ~ ~  J7  OS- !I- ,YJIz JJ1  ilL
296



J iS, S -S 5 J9 cS jr, 1    il )UL A- tUS-
'N ,tl J  *t _jz LcLi zz   -l  - 1  Js- 2,NI c2j U -21
ji~~~~~~~~~~~''        XJy _, J   eual ,J, J-1j  :iAl +i  ,
tSSaiti   ~   ~   Uz jJ H 1 1j$Gy   A
J ,yL~ J iAl ji S1 O ;(1999 3j. Nj -YJ  A) 4J1
297






,:6"'~ ~ ~ ~  >X " 



i~ ~~~~~~K    K- 2:kSk ;  ;c  oQ (tett  'Ztt(
K. ':t W i' ; :       (. .   t
C  �   "  t 't-.  i  %'C.  '" '- '   t <C 
F-. 1;        - ,-s -  ,^X t<S i-
| ~ ~~~~~~~           Ti W wtt  t***  tbE' t. 
0O           *2
_ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~,K~~~~~~~~C.



X,YI o . ( 1995  o j 1995  6u 1
Vzl~~~~ ~  C  JJ  -iE   L- u  -  ,l 2 1 j - lIji. I1
ci L 191 sv  l      v ii!Ll -yl a, lyl J .L.
-~~~j       ,1 jris j~4JI ,,- J9 - y�O1  >eOIO
3ll a      i,IU vs      J:LU �a L42i I j 1 yI
yxJ~-J  -l -W i. _I            1 S  LA .Jl,
v~ . v~l  oI~~ ;,ILl,   -oJIfC iv R _  vLW  ~zS 4iSl 3 J,   KII
-l;3yl,3: 49lu1 ,1 . Vss 2 i> 1 Ul o  .(1-6
--  ,  -  I  L
<3>   l< j uilJL  - iil "!'-S       I X   f
WaJ~~L p1 _IslJ         a i> i 2J i  j9 ;p ~jJL 
A  I;mJ i  I       iL -
30JI n iNl J ^11 ! 4ffiy L jj O.
te.,_-1 - I ,5  4,_i ,9La 301 fqJ;,ct 1JSl? ? 1



,5 ', J.-  G ;�')   �, fc. YA<~U >  -d� 1i > j
*1K~    1 Ly4 sL4 L91J ol- CLJ 2s M , .I 
~~~c.                >  US iSL.f 'JL   01@gy 14+ 11l 
:;l.j-I i jEl             JI,.I. .:LI J ; JD2G L,I 4L   A
19 oU
302 ~.J
s o 7- N J  E r J J C  A  1 AJ O~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~0-  -I,JEi
.v9 J5L1)I ;,L1- Of + 
-$~~~~-U- i a  i1 o        g   !1.
Ji-, 1--'  '1! @eL-liJ  y     1OL>-
L-,J Jy   A1  H  .i,Ji i-Jl L) a-_)U;: ::i9I  ,zAA-L'L JL.4Y
t5i!                  aU ,/Cyl! ~~~~~~~~~'-  1   F1uiJ.>;1
302



1995 z'luYl Lxl,vja JWhl     1995     Lau , L-- l
199                        199  3! Jil J..i.j,
1.0                        1.0
0.0  -           -        0.0      =    
1997~ ~   ~~ e9 >1    199 ,
k4t    Ji-di :-i   .(1 ,S1986) 1!J t l A l 
303. L3 4Xa *   'n4   j  00 ?
I 998 WITA         ^    iI 992) uuj 
i5s4J2l -I i+e ;nJf Doij w t21s  9 19 �L oU1 999J) 
I RI<3JA  ?  lW.1XeJ (;tflLS $) asJ21 i3031 lY



': U ZjfaZX >l Z2  JiL     jr!    K12 -
-,~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-,
.5 A iJ I,  -ra^I lFjsse  6 9  -   9j
- i,-5al J,Wl > a,1b1j   -9 
Art1 Zs&KD ~       - Z   ' f2 .o *.  J z 41r
L 5-          jH1!     > EJI  L j ,- jL 
i , jly.L  2L- 1 ssl Y  j 1 SiD
JL~y ^ JI JS F1 OLJY4-  ? D! 4):  LA z   4�i M1~~
304 > ,       j , J )
.1 4lJI D SS: OLi~.~Ji S
LJ 1          sJI Zdf, oJl Mr ;i iLYuJ < J
4r ilJl lI i1 .ld pI L4 11e iJl! IoL W4,4 illw I? 5A A 
304



JU~j  j- Jj  WU
U~~ lj~
'P   p10:ly i4I XJl  p 11 
.(2-6    ~LL
tiy -  401^+3  <1 js-  oll J oWi  si A-  -
1 ~-Y ll5 >S ,J AY ii >! 98 _ ! iX i  -'j U 
-I  1  /  ,,;tel 9  ,,21!,,Q ,,<1,, l  J L  >  
*(\JI~l I 2 ,-11
lj>3  yA 4,j1:t+ <   j 
305



us,jwi  Z~494 Qj j U 1 Zf. E1ID  0;i�1a164 L"L:2-6 ISgiJ
1995 64x'1UsY: a41J-J jLJ
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6  _
y1! JT LA      _-i
1995 c;4_UW \ j L J~
1.2
U1 L-T L! )k J  i ju?j@! 1 
E ;a j S Iya
306



1997                                2-6 jQi
1.2
1.1
1.0
0.9
0.8 -               1gl     J  J 
1995 Q11
1.0 
0.8
0.6
0.4
0.0
a1~  L1 X       <  _   j .j  
m > 2           I j -W 8 ), 5
: ASS  jU ,Ll w si b 10 s 
.(1999)  ! i(1998) WISTAT    q 3992)07
307



ys J 21 ,< 6 ;w sysl J osyl st 2-6 J-< rJI
J ,  . I L4 6   I,  ui. I I  xi J U I  U
4-1 .! W i5u1  ) .1! 5J 1 j i 
J1 J .Y& i~ 1 tz jJ1 ,s   >JU a-~ -J j,
9  Jf by .(1  u   Z--j j 4 y   jA  j;l, 5y  5
~~~~~~~~~  ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~L 
L<9g i 6P ,J! ->I 1Ju! z1 JJ  4J   8 >xi- AJ~  �W
1  I               5 -  -JlI  oJ l  j  , iL; 5  J
2l W3 9WJJI ,jo;l4j  jo i4
i xi, 91 ~~J, L- -I ,,l jalv-j ~j jj ji_x 
308



-%* I   . I  19 9L 1 3 o19>  L
.jcZ J I -:-i   1  *t'9 y-  j --  - j  .  , 
U WX- ,L2 _  -  -4  v   jL3  I  j
~-i KJ �W1 ycl         Li GoP  a
L~~~~
W3 ;  11, J >J   -,U - D  JI j39J 
'Uj,Jl! GJy  5 6K!G>J!;1>1  i, uG>IO
j         L)J 4J<  2  l,k  JI Ji> l  Jiy 4J1j 45 
vl~~~~~~~- v l 1  1 +i  ,  LJ5 vJIv
91 ,S 11V 4siri U  y JIv: :  1
>~~IAI 9 Ji t1 H-,; 9 is  JJ,  e,
309



Cv?~~~~~~~~~4
Ft
ii  ~~~t-Ct1  E  ' -Mveof 9  ):
r  e  G  s~K  c-  *F  k  1>  _ Et > C tc
~KI(~r        C r st\r c . i:&S. 
L  t tX fW 8t Y   &-
t~  &~�7 .c       _    _ tLL<c  9\[c  ;Ct 
r  \\ t  O   <   E k  t   C, -'s-OI i, t Ot t   O 



jliSl                     al)' eNl 1~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~j, I  s; j, J
__1J                               .L.W t;JDL  D!.y  u1,v  UW 
__ li           IY ig-' -v  &             - +Mj2
;1             4sS~~~~~(j   1-            oltyls J1av4E
i=1~~~~L.- ij~ ,LJI,               :., v$  X1D 9  i1 i9  vL5
.,.:AA-ULIJ AW J
311. Llj  L-J I           X  -
Ve_~~~~~~~~~L6~I ,LY                 ,Ajixll jlV>, 
i7 -GL                            a? J 4k L1 al S1u 
.45 v,Li LS ,xjL.  S J, v7 l s    . 
311



9<   31   )j   j3  7 13  > A :   3 > . 
9  X)   a                     -o)n j ggq< 
01     :1)              '4 2   '$ 03 '   9 
') )   05      .'   2    9, ]u l 
:5~~~~~~~~~~i
~~~~~~~T3 ~ ~ ~ C
Th ~~~~~~~~~Q*            El?~~~~~~~~;1



>  ~   S   8 LJlu>1 S     Uiog  1
- U. 1� O-     ,_ ,S>LLSI ob 14y 
*, sI ,JII  ILU
<~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~J~   a  oic YlD Z-  ,y  is  w
L--j I  L---,L  I Z--ilAl*J I9 L)  -.L-
j~~~~~~~j~OS      +,  ,_,! 1_...1
191 LW .ss  -            AX       >2' X  U 3 S
Lj  w:SLJ8 sLJW jli isllJl!  G1  aJl UlJ ,   JI  .c Wil
,)-JI a-b  5S efUiNl I,j eooy  ,JoljCiS  I  $  s l
jL-11 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~   ~  ~  ., Z-1  L.
.(3-6 ,l    W
JJ  I -'l -11 J5; JS G -di  -L;lj  -u"S1  ,5 1Y P
I 6l J 1  , lLl<1$IJ      JI19,-.J
~~~~~~J   IJ LJE L9AI J IJ 4;-UJ 51 l  !lJ
(2)  +1  ,  lJI \iJ  8  8 ~  -'S  1
313



1995 a4lxvI    OLJWU jW
1.2
0.8
0.6
1995 (SJ      J   LJUO<
1.2
1.0
0.8
0.6
314



1997 e w
1.20
1.14-  . 
1.08,
102 
0.96
I 1, >r  bJi  N  s>LYI, JI     <    Lj
1995 iu 
1.0  .
0.8
0.6
0.4      -
0.2
~ l4pY .aw1 L! ,AId  i     J .@, ~LU  {1,1~1
1~~~~~- j;1             C X l9JL; ay  t  t JLyl< - J i--
,SS)$I j3     --ul Nu  >l >(
L5,<El   M- '(1998) WISTAT ,,  ;ULJ  '(1992) 1   , Jil ouu
315



JU~ ~J~W 2u  4  j  Uj Uj
i J}SLh Ji AL 66u  91 >~Li  ?! ,9  A
L+a~ ~~~~~9l
aAb 16 a jsI yi I j jY 11 j jeJI jal I
2sLW i~2 ^; ^  y9, L? ,        W./ 3sl<
.< Li S aiU 26 ,+ -,j lb ^4 bG 1! ,
y Yl ;iJ N  e >gtn  3  X3 1 <sol  JiL-  JJ
>3~ ~~L- L5_~ pB  @  oJ  J IIjI  JI.L
li~ j, 4iI~  -xi -   -  J J
<@ i-i -s  l   A J
J      -
* 3).,1 < ;1y -j O9LIJ y ,-1 5uu 9 9
o:Us JC  isL;- .., l i~ 4! ,, ];JlI 4c  L,,  12
.   olJ ll ; y Ji 3 HJ  QSy >L. jl 1
3Il1 ': j . u, 16  I
,,, , ' lsg < j$,- jY, k] ,y  5-! 9Zl!
~~~~j~: JJ        .6A1  C
316



4~~~~~
4>1JJU >9<yl E3Vl vxO1!L1zsk 4lS sS v.>!(4-6 SI
&-3'$  d+ ;J L)~Li ;Sv l-J\L � !>
,Jjj       ju, J y  !Ljyl j_1!,<1: N l
(4)Li,y1 J  L ,Yl uA J. L �i ) ,+ 
k,Ul 4J }y1> JJ-, L:E uA   j Gvu  +  J  UI 0
--..
o1>L~~~~~~~j-SJl XL - '11 a Gl J191 i
i      u1  91 S o+1 91 >21 slj cA AL Sj
7 y  $ J - JIil jW  -L. - v    j-  j5u   ,Xu
iJ-9 Y SA Vi :> ! .-(4-6  9  )sS  iaxl+
Pi J  ! e1 yUJ , JI9191 317
3 17



-A"-           zG iVGWw        �i#fjfJ Qu �j:4 
1995 4Lx2,- 4i 
1.2 iC
1.0
0.8
0.6
1995 A,i_9.  yjLD uJ
1.2                                                            i
1.0
0.8
0.6-
U1!  uT X,,  u<,   LiJ J@,j    LA 
v   SJI     *   J.Ll      6     jj  O1Jl
318



1 997 -CA J I                       4-6 ASIM 14
1.20 , 
1.14
1.08
1.02
0.96
i1 Y- , , ,1      y 2,   --1      ,
1995 ;jUTh
1.0
0.8   i   ;, c
0.6
0.4
0211
,~~L J           d     j tJ!i  - 1 > 9 ijA 
i1 <r91 '2 jUi Wj1 J,.&J o  Wi-  9  I 1  >A ) S
:S A ! o j 4i ,i L 10 LA 5-  u  .L9U,W
'-l 11, '(1998)WISTAT z- 2UAJ :uYJ i(1992) UUv a  L u :,LA
1999)9
319



sel +1       o; Ao ***    * + l 
O-~ fi Wy 1 2J~ 14 Zy>C g�<1 o\U Jy
1J  *i W1 ceysl J -Z "-  _4z1 L4 3  >6A
jL 4-A JK~A J, IW;- I      jJI 1
4~~~~~j~ ~---4 JLi JJ- 31 J0!o+ez8L<JL
Jl > 1 44 't 9.4 J1 J;YI Ji >W X>~ 
j/i i~~~J
'SLz  'Wi ,l jS     -a1  )< 1  
320



I _,51 _, bL-,5,  j ,;1 91    " ,- o'j
JoLz- si +1 J< .J;IJ L-jI L. S il L1a   HJs  !
4_1LI jj.1    9 1 Ji 4>1J1SjJ 1
+ > (Cz.yL~l J~, --1 Jvl 4  > iS J 9
j           ,7L  I  J j A J J J S H 3 S ; fj I L Y
,vJ  i  @JI i.S%6-lJ (4S  C @)I< ~l'P 1-6j lj >
<>JI OSS1 < 4-L        _ P 4Urj ' lX Dj 
i.i 4~ 1�i .(,&A J> -lj-_l' &� ',_' -9-t1 i K&9 
321



_,WI~ ~  ~   S  -g.L1 
i  qt-yl j:1 ^
:4,1IJ L-Ji JLJ) J-S;  lZ;l jw   L"i-
(SX J ) L51YI -k8 H
J O: 5i ji o: JiL. e- 9 ej,,,I ,.>
L) ~    (/ L     J
Jb- .|A!  J'i'\   ZU I' 'S  )tYj      I-
j-', J W) I,
322



1-6 jLtj  U
ajlgJl J fL  l
~i J~W  .A5-y3  Jul)  ~j  --il,
J) L. J21JI W19 ; zW  Gi-
iz.Ji ;Wi      iowS    9 ;,-
j4i Z-W
jj. _ty  2Ol  4 132
.z  j>l  t.u e t  \-.j  o ylo1Jt3231 



1-6J=F
L>.J I O1~L~.- 1oLIZ JI
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ 91i -Wu1 9  4i
.J!, W,u 11 JeL-J @g, sLdl tj
,zjL-Ji~~~ to~L 4Ji6 ,-L- L.)
2,1~~~-~    ->Dj - I?lq , --  i a-1 l
J J.-4C  61   ~       ~    Workfare programs
324



~-'~ -~ -~ ~W  c~W  ~J~  ~   ~I -6 - Lu O
45>1 JA1~ y, I~ <, G !   4  L-J 1
L.
-   I  - ,  4L
r>Wz :.A _)-6'   J,'  o; ;XW-
->y, by w S-Jy 21! 1XitS P  LL-J
'J''A) 9 'j ' )  L,
J ~ L~2~j  L-J
325



I{~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~.~~~~c
4j.  r  F  .  .  .  T.  ,  X  ,  L   Dt- e-
|~~~~~~:~c         .             * b c-  i, l
C,-~~~~~~C



-roL2   7  J f:2~ I  LJ5 j Lc  ti  ~j.~ IJW   ~ J
,j J.,i.- 3,WI *i~j zN~1 LI sJi  J- -   - s
s~~  � -  -                 i LA 2S >a i -i y�  4  - 
v P+ J vgl t S1 oI  uI  a I i  I o LJ. 9i  4
Li~~~~~~L
i    vML Z-1 JI  -, Lg  j,, J- f
.1-6 J-Up-  1  e L1   - 9   i  Ii hv
L'  i J JI U5 JL        >  JW  A
Jjj      a,4$  ><�5L  327
4:CvL  4i  < 1 Ca1L 1 aX- 1  V327  1



Y-> &w9n~   Jol J, ii jCL D D kLb JI AS - �,J .cl
.SS aJI J, 1   ,   1
A~~~~U *j 6;> 9yJy 4sIL -s  y  l>
!76 -L5    QLA jt'  -' ,Q
LJL"  9Ljl J   'L,       L. IJ
1-; iS :. LI J i L,-Jl  e -.) , L 1 1  ?.  -L1 L) zLLa 
y ~~~~~- j               a      L.^v !t; ; ,-U,51 o;l Js~
~~~~~~-7L    Ij -Ji   :-   J-i  ,:,L l   jL1 ,)1sa sI!  L,-JIsl
328 J  L  L,i LL LDi
328



1 G      R > 3 S1 1  t11 J:Slj z   J L2jj L-�, j  J zj
.') (1993                rL,-J =1  'xl  ,9 ll +   1
1    919 9 1J9 9  LJ 1997 ~3Jy t ,i  :AL --a
Le  I J  yw }l -l J S            ,
j. .(1994 199299 j,j   329
-! .A1 1 J AsE syl L) ;.-JjL)  i; JA,J  j jlyl?
~~~~~~~~~L-I       L;-j I  IJ K   y  -kaI-l+:1 Ss
L3 9 4 o J lJ j E5~~~~~~~-  ;Yl *I  5  JI  J
.(16 f  zL) J  3,lYlpJ4X   >j
8 < F >i fi;l < sl 329ll 5S $1-loJ



* t>. ;IJAigL22$U  LSptz1 -  .~ Jpjg39, 
~~ jW~~ j ~U9 5.UJI JWA~~~~ ~~  jW~~~ ~ j
_L;I 4 W K  -1987       -,,2LI  :-3Jl j6, JI   L
4>:JIJI j,1y  l      u ( WI) 3i 4  41  ? zjl 
- 2 ~y~- Jl   3 t   yy. z v ;   ii ' +- Cl Qk(1993   . L1)
-Wl >UYl L  o jL   jLi Q I 
Ht    20 ,_J'- ,jF iv5ij Ly\  6 3U ,,W 3jjxl I
jujSy j o;j.)L.  o  j- ;   u   il xy
JSL YI jui jI vl3X       ju:,sJl9 lyl 1  L- I
Okyl sY Lk2! i,5,1rl +1l L, ;~iJ>yl oS1 uii 1I
,  jkl- yl  j AJ-J  A   (TA  1 ,JIy :JBii L  :U --
JL-z ejL,-l L9p J-~.~ JJ  Sk1y,33
M 2 j,l S 3 ?e r--J"j 1?i 99  1iJF ) 
216 20 S1n ,;1 alJLi , I >5  jLl,  .l  J: jd
>5l;~2 oUSJ oAl          3 !  -PIi  JD lsl ISIj
.P,15  L  .,9 ,34   o lj ,
.p ll5 jlS   1i;l .,5JJJI !. U-1  5lf4OJ1-  1
330



;91 jK   v efz ; tt1  i1 1--' 4' u  ji
Li)-A -� J9    y 1      1 f1 J1  J   2 M C L3 1
4J   I              l Jas L   I   I  IA� )21 .Jl C
.7A.iJ Ld ,P.J Sclz .,L;KU, jS  C9  J1J  Llo
j!  :-,L I-).;, 1 l  l 
.(S1999 ,,y  -a-4L 70 L5 9- Y (1  )*
)-J a~L e_&1I_;pu1 .(1999 DJL* 41998 p 1998  t  y
4-A -~~~ ~~  j~ JLU k~~~  ~~ .u~x ~   9-J 
L.S-z s1 ; *(2 jj l 431) ;1illij   j 
.,1y - i l, JL5l  -  ;jiW >3 J- l
.(3 3(1998
wS_r9 9 C Cl_28 ~J~ 4 I Le JI OJHI  U1 J, -
j .S-5 ,1  S ;  1  e 1+    -,L-i I L~  4 ..i l  JI>L
,  T, 6s 9'L,J      Z-'L           41cl   I Cc9;1  g 
OA A ;J~~I        I LI JUI L9YJlU!GH~1 S 
-  .!t:Ui Sc o - (2000  -.)"  Jj  1999  -, 6:a I)
-,j,; 1 ,-1 J �_L _t iSP ?~ -, E, AL-JI 5 
33 1



S 9 -SQ1s -!1 91 8w i, - ,= M i  5 wz:2-6 5 9; .'n
tu -- -, o  S a  -ul iz,xJ j, (1998  ,  ,l 
t-. a,ilk- > ee> J 91 ? su1 4- t>J2;
?         j1  fikLb 1 ,? ti~  -Ljl 2 S < 
Ji-1j J+ L1                Ja Li j -o,,>) ,,WslJ
'IoJLcll         63rl Z  iLJI 3Y 8 1, Cllo Ii
Z9 J ,19              ,, 1> 1S-  a I
.JUL u;  Zl<!      , -6         "L-  I S
ji 1  JX>3JIC-  J  lfgJ<y 1 > 1111a332   L



s�A,~l =;. wyL.1 bju a1il ^c 
1.48  0.91   0.116    0.189     0.172
3.55  2.58    0.125   0.172     0.444             -<
4.87          0.030          0.146       -,
3.27          0.030          0.098
j.DJ '
-I.65   il.54  - 153   '164     252      -b            A      
:2.02   1.71   -128    '151     258
2.62            114         299
J ZL                    J-   91)�1  J ,1-   E jz+s<1 11Jd S
.(1998)  J e 1  1 :Da1  1998 )  >L    ?>
333I  4YI  ap vH C--
333



(vff XfT ~8661)
6R  vC! ) Izrn  Z Sn,,>v If  C 1l 'F'PY <m
f5r ~~~~Q  ~~7 11 ir,Q
W(c161 <  - Z 8661'666 ; t 1  1<  -
17-r   j5 1+   j7n-IVr -- !7   ji< 5
9 861 '0661'  '  9661'  re4fol(r 8661'666t) .
r7- 
[n cS f 1  19 <       \   n  '



C! 1t,  I.  t                L L C  r! 
-;  <,L Sz '-'  L't  1,�  '  r,  L  >h,L,i 
OX *c>v  F , t lX 0 < .   '1  .; s   c 



i@n 1991 ;J  s    1241!   1j    1   1
.(2000 WiL, i1999  i1999 4J)Lij  4  yY1 ' 1994  ' i1999  ;
0S2   -   J1  f   c , 2~LJ  J~  i '  '  i  i  S  '
,#L~ j1  1  J~ 912 31 O'- -i A  1s  j91- 
'j xJ  l    c    i, t  :  .a. - Z,9 :Jl
~~~~~~~(983ilk 4  U5 ii1 9 J-~ 3
o .5   S*^  rJk Jj! �ji (2000 li  S-jI -)U   ~J  i, Jl
ji- J I 5. Gyl L-s j S jjl - JDi +1 p
-~  ~  h- 16 jI  - 8 ~~~J
.(2000 Y5>j U- 4SJ
336



i,kl, ~~?- il~JL J~ fb j;S 91 4'  4- Lii
sj L--aj  4  yl 4j  41L51i J I WI L   -i ;
z,i ,<A zkl             ZS  l  U'21Jg 9 4 ,  I,
iWJ -(       CU1995  -  UJ   jlii
4 ,L;-)I e r 1998   SUj . )(199 s337
b  i la, 1i ,  iJ1t a1 k1  A s9I337tu



~~) ,jL~~ y0 ~~  4W "L~,Sk --AJ b  >~ -,uLl
) !> sJ L5 , -  -2        . {  jla  14J
11JI ZL ss  91     Il     L- OLL
- yJJ Z s       1   os!;J 4JW ,>y 4; o;� jS J
oLJ yl .ZJ,11 i ,S v 11 L-j j4l i  JJ  ,,
-1    L<EJ   E JI .S' liJ  giOW  Iy  OJ  !>
.Wi~~~LL ;,;;1 J  Uii 1  LJy ,   k
i 1 s ;;L5  ~ ~ 7J'j l A d OL4 J-   911  11ou   Jul
j~~~~~~~~j~,
4_4~~~~~~~~~j      -,.jKj -jUsl  :< g  a 
338w  E v J        LI
E_!?  5X  F U C1;1A F WJI, rN338 J



i 91Ji! 41 ,  W WS iJ Aiv;, 19 O Jir
I2l
C- ., -1! ;yl,< vxy ,>  .J.i J ,., j =,-!>S1 y_U.J,
L~U   L Y Z-,-I  ~jI  :i iA  .1 1j)L -t   oS O1:
> 1 s - L-Jy -lz  LQj 1-
J l e3 <a>~~~~~~~~1  aS oJIl + s1twI.,s i4; 5el
oW U1 -~~u z1 - jj1~   :--- Ijl .6,yl 1,11 
IS  J  i  9  J; ,JI!- ;L-- - J- I J Id-<  L
L)
339



,,1Ll aWJ 9 JI sf  ; JL J sS   9r~ -L  L,a
j ':< 1 1 S1e g;lj- sL.
-'  ~~~~~~~  -     - U L-   .
L~~ ~LJ~ ~~i  WI ~i4.j Lj, IJL  OL J; 
4_L1 J 1 ;yl ,99 9 J1  S   j I
jJo~   (340  j J
4_>1  1,!   l 4 -1 a2C  Y: 41   lj
lL W)<D~~~~~~-    i t CI! S Y ,1 Y y
S f fips ~~~~4J>I<1HeJiJ ta0J f- IS



A O                              ~J I J .zsj &  - J- I 
.j_Ji  L -I P    J i  ( ,:L .i ,  J I, ; 
i g?  1Z ff 4>  L J             -i,   J
:-L-il4 9i@JI j4 Ljj j   8JI 151 W
*J i             i    S                     LA
U_ A  >)i f J2l ? L>JI3 J45I UWj  I y,A
.(41
Y jLi..:2jl <jbJ 5d31  j
J \, e-11, b v :Aiu .j   s    l s  5 >
1 < T~~~~~~l Jll<!*J9  9  u i;
L >l SSJ  >  12:;L AllsLoI i341lY



lYS -l;JII Jl.i aoQl;;AI *  ?wQ1 lw.L-l QIwWl:3-6 31 11
J�J ~LL1  ~  ~IJ-A j 5WI Li          L~ i
LAJI L:   y1 -JL-- L,gJIjy            I j51  '.S1I
a yJ 4~~~~u. 4oEWl                   Lt1Sj JL1G+>-Jl < X-i
lj-c~ ;A   . L.  JI         f-l JI  :d Jl ;  4
iS     ,S;  -      aiJl 4^eJy, 4JI <:<  C5L! JS
~~~~~~~oj-I Ltco         ;-,6-  jlj 4J!.SL-i)lr,IsIs ujJ ,61
-W  JaI H  sA.J1  4LR  J;)AAJI; W.i  o,  9!iJ;l ,I  .J>AU  i~
9l�JI .31uX L,Jl JX ,i) +X ;JI - cLA l OWJI ,?  UJ ZJI 4A 4 - 
J3.) JI i               j  JU z4lLi
-;            J      - ,Jl LJ 9j A Jj -3l42
j =  !.)           a-ZI  ,S1 L)UJIr1jJ 
.3,1 I zJ  L  JJ  ;  L-  L-, ,rji
4><1 4,j1 -%yl-4syl  L-YI aJLiS' L1  4+LdS
.(1999 1+  >   p    loypJe.1       1    1J;JI
Wi1 uk1 J <Ji 4r4       6;ol      U 54 jl 
Se rDi ;% JJI! 4t\JI C?i sljoi W2ese *@ w ;,rui ;LljI
342



jA  #,       A1         sw
- _.29          Q - i Sl Xj lj 1 1L"l 
yA            _;Jj7   41j .-l  _S -Sl  -   - y 1>oL 2
jo         Llij               L) s 1  e  1  Al J-I 45-LAj  J*
~~~~~~j.Ji :rA!O\,UJ1 L           si So1oiS 1j 
u    ~~~J~, ea -Pu8J28SJ   (zU Y9   AAi,  e l-z,, 2-
ji 1  t591 as, -L, l:A _Sj (-Lz ;u     ll oi J
46 S        6                            _JUJ
-,,5 5' J   j~JI J    65OEl Ou2) w>S�34
J;)lJ ;JI vo JgJ ,$JI <:JS ~~~-(2000iJ4Elocll
cl               es  J,n,; e , �ty we a6 J~~~~~L;  A;I  IusX
zd  29-a,H i,-a   S)  -  3  1 2  -S
4-6 3_.,.P  1, !=    J!IY    I)_     J 
L5,;1 JJI 2 atlL 36 r jYS ,, 43LL ;U ~2 +



(?~~  ~~~   L- I L-J iLt     LoL-i)     L,      U- 
JL,A   xla __                            (0.89)
gm1 =S- ,i  _           ~~~~~~(0.60,
(k- 65 -L- U-D               (0.43)
(0.35)
60; -L -U-J          (0.29,
0      20    40    60     80    100   120  140
- e --- 60 < j ~L45 ;65 .r 3  z  JL'-A ji si-  zA>   s
, zA 5 39u1 z 1,.. > OLJ2 ;a ,,<    51    iy) ,<U >  >9
;(65 >, ,    L) a- 15                           2 j., cA S  1  2  ,,u 2LI
60 J<,;1     -li 1rl?u 60 ,,     ,,6 ;-d ,     - AJl
.- 19     ,; .A j, 65       ; aL- !  ,  23 ,;- i  p ,   4>
J<- al  Y,  1        1   Js344
.(2000) ,l, ,f , :, l
344
.                       .   ,  .  .  ..... .... ..~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-   - - - -   _, -  - -



4-6 ajiLall IiL
5...U LXA3 LL  Ja a L- JU  l ,- L1 19   l
160             Z g139 j, 4 35  a-1 U 29  e-,
4WU  J       65 z   j 60            65
43 J, L, 1r-  4+Jv1  ..5LrU   ~-l,  JJ1  1l ..A1 J2 
345~~~~~j
,5,VJI i 1 a1 ?  60 J~,; UA-s L-1, Li  -G tW1 I,-9L1~ ,i
u~~~~L  L.-LLi  L5L" -;SS 1  9 s, ISlj  "Laj,U1  ju< C  si
.zl1u 89       a1 -i 1 ls 
(PASIS)      J-G        41d> t ,11 >
eM       a - 9 1 & J j a:-65  Ij jLZ  y,  jL-lJ)Ij ;L1.
.(1999    jl        J     9    )18  3 4  jj-L,S  ; j
a  1  3>1 ,? itldL 13 Jl12 >S i," �S y - jJ < 
Y11SiL5          L-JWS1  YIS iel- X;i,i 
345



Ji L 1J 1<998 J  s - L1       uS
J-11 ~ ~ ~  ~    .1  bi1 J1
J,-(20 i 4.,J  I E  ;-e  J  ,!.20  )
.(99  iia            ij Im AJI w.vsil 'iz,,1`S e;,Y5LSI
,, 1  z~~~O~ , L L,,-- JJI'- L'? Isy  JL lC   e 
J  ;Hyl S  f  ;1fl< ' 1  Xy- L~ 'l1 -aS i.
as" ~ ~ ~ ~ .�vl JIjUll1
11~~~~~~~~~L -il i  ,Lrrl   Wl ~> 
346



Cl .i j.-!       ' 1  1  JU 1     1      _
Li1 oijl J bo!  WJI jj--i-lj jU ; Y  s el j --jl_ t
I  .   ~~,~i  .(199
347-6 j            o 1 Z p I
,_, v X ! ~~~Zi-J I  j,-J I4- J I  D %JJ3   L-,IiS  JI15
i.UI!~~L as-4_$1 d c ,H1i  :.i-L -GjS .F : JI  I z, ujk
,1998 ~ ~     .(-311 ,LJI)jl  4sL L*c 4s1;1 Jl:
'_    1JJ 4LJI o l a op+ is-
4_jas~-u  "LJ                                 -(v>  t+S1 3iL3Iw 4j
*(99  Wy 1995 :;)I 1
-_I~~~~~a   L>   oJ L -1           IL--I I  oiUl   l  -SI OA.
<;s l 91,3ifJLlltisLIJ ;S1! !  >i9 347LiJ



gi"aS�utdl'@XQfi :~~>X - Swi@Xwjv :5-62 a
-G;y  'Uaa39              -_pL- L-  JL-4 141   1  l  YuDu Z-js'
i1~~4J - i 'UJI !. 1  Lcje  1S x�  i ! -4j1--!
ZjI- ~ ~   .4I                  J<SL J   G91,ly
�9~~ ~~                    LLJO  tD  4  11oD 1997 +1 Wl
pfc iLizW5zJ ilolJIGg Ia <54 elzJ, L3Q1J ;1   .L 19
lJJI J>}> oJlil  o  <; Lii _  < j uX   LLc 2 L P  !.Jl
4L oM f!;J91 J  l1 91 CJI-I .S1j J-v LLc  ? u1
u-i                   4 i1   s1 i  Z~jlW > 11?,9G
g; J 4)yl 9 ~~~~~~.~   Ijl 2  L)1 JL- I   L-.1J 4 l1s
.(5999 qy t  H l+       199  q11999)O !  sL 
.<vIJIsi 5l ag l :S,M}>-J-<S 348S5I-



i 1! -  i? y~~l JI LL- (!~~ isi1a~
ilJlll 4 ysLJ Si ,5 5, J,1. SJ) tJ >1 >XX o5W J
., 1. i! 19$ _-S       1 J  a st  )Y12l jSL--
ULP a-,ilL        (  t ,- 1  SIJ 
1ilI 1 L      Uy  ,I  .   ii
1e JJJ L1  a  a j-349
a. 1  L IJp L 1J 91  D Ijy  I9 -Ll
+ ! , ? Q .kXl JA!  4w6.1 5:n1 > 
* H si, ;J 4I _D1 iJ ,ill
a-�       Jb;>o349I



I   W )JJ oL_.L  ziwl ~-  S
;,ISI sl <:JI! ;,591 O)j,1 l  J ! 
,S1 d,l 4i9 L  a-l) ;&L  l .  3 i  i
--   L4i -  U >o ~.LAJJl ' A li  a
1  L4  ZJI 4, l ;L>l  ,,2 9  H  OJ
yi-b +-? Ji M9 S! ,SJ i 1;S J :SL_I < si
3,U  ~ ~~ L.-  )2J  L5  aL-lLL. A--  J -~}Lj,  L .-Jl
zli.4   l U.,1--  J1- 11  ui oP,3 l350
t1~~~~~Ll   4 -L-J  L 1 131s(U s1 1
.O:31 uL _4>1., 1; !* Ji ^  L<-j 
llen  1  JI/ 1  s  1 .8lJ ;WI j6<- e3 a>  65
~~~~~~~~~~JL CIA- U1 4 JI C >?  1   5 J i V >;ili
A5~ ~ L. 9JI, 1 9LJI  5;1W   jlJ iv i,, yl s wl-;
350



i4tWJ ,Ai Js- 4.Ui J,Wl J 4 J� .sj .si . /9411 y
* t_.L      Le ,A 1-X    yl1L
L uG1 EUyLtLl  i-�~ jLX,Jl 1,J  ~   Li jS  j C  0
L-j I L:~~i Py.      I 
L - J�_ <U 1J     L   1    2 AU2U
_UJI j_>J
35W?y + e u t91  a 31 .l  Zy
~~~~~~~~~~~Jil c Ua4 -p   9A1 IS 1 _ _Jl L ,  .5-0
351 ~    i140; 



,J,-, ;-1 ' S   e! L1   W J J 1  I J U-- -
4 _JI~ -oiL ?IL! .XW ;}1 -Ji v;;,L vf oldl i J w -! 1 
~ 4 ~ -~ ~W~ ~  ~ j ~4#l ~  L- j -2L
UJ~  ~     ~  ~iW  olA.z l  i U -  Ul  L. >  jj S3 L
J o1             ,5  ,s,-,  .r191, szu1 >U- J  _  e
J~     
jj-0 A< 11ZL-L1 :  J  1 352
L.Z  - ;;I jj_LcUJ L1 J   a;1 s+-Di   -  I  y"
"ez; JJ _2uco1J  J v>Un 2J -5  L< . oLD 5H  ucl;u 4JLe) .-
A1  1 s& >N v Jwi21DOS11 JJ H 352? 



i}S fi- -~z 22 js 49  9  >   j   i 3Ji S)J #y , -4
p (J)iL~ j~) }~U 4  i 6     (ylW~ uL L9- 
aj (JYI Ji Ji  OW J1 AL 'j'a (91J)      )      i
* ~~      - - J L� y-W y JW j1  2 ilu S
�t,>l sIJyJ, <  Y  <Ji ~16 ,cj!  9  i,9a 
O-j +1 -+1  , (1995
jd-J J vj '  353 -oY J- Z   (3.6
>JL   L2@(91) .>9t-J l                     jj. l  4 !1j
t , 1995 �wl    l     YjJ j-,J 600_ ,s J ,
e  !.(2-8 i    jj,1,^P      i %aJ yli 
'Ij,U -                              -6g  j  A 
i1 .Ao-S L6o1~U.4 kZLo1.j 1989 H_%  Li  i
iJ  +t;s Y4_c:>-I <U1  s  a^x. Ll j ViSIuI lli  eJ.(1995
353



J  ojr 4i W, J JX  .zS oi) o  fi A oL   %l   J
U Giw .�1 CW ?U 1L  ? OW 4   - S L
, Uw   zGCu1 Js .5 6- ,. 
.(1996 e (19 fi ) lJI IJlx�
-        I  .Ab1  ,5lc ^LisEL, \ ,X1 k~i.,-  I,l _ Jt,nbJD  ji L5L,c iJ-i iZ -
.(1996 ,J*Y)  '1 l,-I,
u1 4SA1 ?  A 6.3 <y  9 1994 WlJI j :LUi jLJ -8
< j1 iU 4 S S   S J�a  e I 431  1  Lz .(1995 oLU;j  L;- 
ei;JS 9- ! ) w1.9               4;XWI Znl�-J-;  , L)iJ 
JA 4#  y4 CkJ)L A! . 1 �?  +  z,- 1.8t
Cl*JJI eS SJ rI, 1 < ,Y j ff 80.6 ,1-4SXJ  )S
Jj! .(2-6 dj1;w112J '1999 , kij Lj5) Za1J ,lf  J.)  x  1 ^
J Gl  jjli� 1 .     I    J C   <41 yJ.& 1 ),?9
j! -Jl JS  5 J - Ls,~ J-aJi XI  c I - ,35
o b 4u 1I ji -- Zv a2,L -  9 ~
.(2000 ,  Os , 1998 L)V, LU-jo A) 3. 1 b!1.7
354



.Cy Lx -~ j1L o; OLJ  1 9u1 LE21 ]
j5   JuL,JI  A A>i  ,J -j.  -3 -y (1999
Y  ;  5 -   .1985 )   ) eJii Z  1 1 ,a S   A l ziI -1 1c.
JzUI j  l!I,-) i  71 S!   _ 4L1 UL I ;t_3I55
-iSl~ ~~~~~~~~1 -ili S   i  ; jI jJl _r
(,-J994  <_ o1_ 5, U-I  ( 1985 bQj :)ij JJI 4,,1
,uz  :'! L -.   - J9-  16uelz -LS  li-3 -1AU
355






(I )S PjL '  l
C4 0         C;All jqo :~Q Wuaopt4



#+f  nfr --     - pR y'-An ' rn{' S8-1' 1' \- '
F-\C-7  -t-r  Wn 11+'  -c  l   1661' 1' {  rj c 
aX 1661' WP4 1 c-~-  -   Im )%-"T" l:  Yrf lr-,
-: rI  IY Se) 17U' I
ir    1<' 4+C? i-tleflii   ( I^16601f
:Cs ~~~~~472l'7C+crF5 ,   _5r--r I7T
ICIT1661), 1--X-5 1  rt tr:97      5
1   r                        161
I H K r' 1--  I7--r1



IJL__-j.J oj ,-JI cLL-Ji  c,MLUI l_UaiZ y  4 1 JX
O-_  byS -1  j1 Ig c1       1 6LL1
29JI
- J.jIY3 4 , j L'J'
jij  O  'JL~~ ~. l  o3    JlJ
*  .L2f I 2 -JWWi    1 LKi 5uu ij
~~~ ~y~
j ,                             I>  ~  4j�  y U   LjL I:J~Jl
.<J~~~~~'ujJ _1' O_L-_' L1   .51419  L_U1 ->28 
,512_CzWl i>Al 1eS '>G iX1 'A2j_ lLju L-l 'lai
-,,KL 'YWy t4J,L.I %, ~4  ;5LW !y i -y e  cL+! �-L
359



A~~LL           _<W 5y  1 J--ly I       1 C LLd1
G, iO1Sl tLyl s1j! 4  'L' 'SjY _'j'-)Ul 1 
- 91 e  b!9 GlLy :X>1 IyL 91 421  GJy~~~~~~~~~~~_~ GLS
,;ul I l9 UUI     461-.;i-,1L       819
wjY u 41-L-Jul                    JW , L  X1 4S
G jwl e2  i1X1Ju e~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~_J\  jL . \eu  Gni5
i,Yl i j~ljl-          Y.iU -   - 51-d!i-I    u
gfyersul  6,)jll ily     y  SJX360      i



*Lt~, C- _ - L1EGA  U,@l  X,L1  X4%l 4LJ  L,<~
;b~~~~~~~~L1~  YQ i1  LU$1 -5 -ul -? o(ly z1J'J tLI
,;1L-  c,-- LJ                L,9 ui  a   u216y1J  5j
(A I ;sxj :1i 1i 1  4  y A1(lU
L!LS44L9 Sylut 4Lf ; t1361C



44
y-J -4J+9 - - 9 Jl'j LwS LJrJI K!fr11! 'z5K)J-J I-KC'A-
4 Ju>a GrW uj is - t,u1 ay ~4I  ~JLsI'UA'1,
Ij   < iI  c)- Lg -I - I  1          S
5pJI
,S1 J jo 4)jlXl l1e  CJU ,6JI  k),wi- y 1-6j jlAl-~
-           ,j >     > JLAWY (Ja1 4J, - J
1;,,-J ,y  4  LJ  4,,, 4,L
362 ,  G+,  -i L ,  CL,
L~~~~ ~ ~ ~ JJILJI K -S  tJ I  1
362



J ia iuG1 ~~Ij+L57y1;914 jlWlxJ
I . ;!ljliS1 469 19J Ga G,  -'yl zj
GJlpU  4l;^1tLY     91-9       y   l 
Gill i1  iS GLiS GL6>1 ;GuX  9 i j,JO
8 J1JI
6 ~~~~~~iJ& -zj11-  iij,-1  4u   WI  ju4, GSJI L4i
j3_;e  iJL;L ~   C <JI~Aj   4a"Ji -a u  o UL.  1~ ly  L-S
I -,  -  es14  L j GQ_I  a S1Jj.,Jl4   5jj .l -  LZ_P
; P > s 11 eL-JI  ll,i l -  iwJLr,   iln  G51j  c l-
IL  iXWGy ;14             1G!vl4,;J
,L--  j+- )  1'W  C  jULll  L j- t ILw I I  @21
363



<~~~~~~~~~~~~~~j eJl  .,,J, I, 'U1 'Ju 'ts  ;J,s 
G  IjI \  tI _J  p  es , G L , -J 1  iljL- C91 4 51 iGy
,4j9 N s~~~~ 4 CK -) L,:,J5I ILLSo1 j_rA<l cLI A Wj
41  J!,lWyliS,@21 u <, Jy  I1  J1 OJ<  ;
91
ClJ jL,~ t1  -y  c1-   LJI -1 -k jl l 1 4.id 1   Lk  J
1 , Cf~~-t   i jUJlit L - -u,1J   e,914
i<_@11----L  yl ., 1 I I_y j l  , U Lu  ' (lU)
- gl ~~~~~. I J pX 1  l  <   l, JJ ;Ig 1
364



l~~~~~~~~~~~
j ~ ~    ~    ~    l j.
Gt   od1 4Uy2 - ?-y  I -LhJ  -\ :A3 Lj3  S  k
bu eK~ jUX ,t       )iy -1e@1;J  - -W i1i
ij_H,?-  LLJI vLa-I,  _4~J-   Jjjt  j,+J'L 6
I  i 11 u!1l VYI -y  2>' x~j i jJ 3  Q J4
G   G 1S4S)2JI gEugg  >ngg 1 365zL



c ~ ~   ~   ~    � ;1~j.lczo-~ 
'J 11 JJjll cjl e 1e G ;; J  $'-+&  IS1  U
; 1  e<Le G-,,I y '6-4JI  4J'W'< W 'i
,Uit  "jJ  UL  -Lj_2 dLi- 'Q_L&  I-L,S L<--,   L-Jl UI SI -e
,;Ll .1 GJ-eI Jw -) ! ,I  Cl j I  IL e  zL 1  S  i X yl
2-1 SJf
i,~~~ ~~ ;5,,;L Lin b,  L.j I 9  L-T3 bj,ji  pG
366



bI~ ~ ~~~~~~~L           J-           4 Uf ;1J  f@    ;5;eeGX
_U-9    Atu                                    Li1 J!'FLiSA>l  19
4_  1  JWs G  ? e1 ;j~~~"j1 41j j.G I1 &'
Gzi,IJ LLJ ---8 L'l3 cg g~~   i  e9 -U  e4   JI)  I  I  
~~~~~~~~_+         l J- L.  j,    G     9  1 ->p JuhWS
T~~~~~~4% -JI 'U- JL;L7jj 'ZSJJ U-ly  II F 4,1X,14  j
4J         ll -, -z: asl<s, J367 



5-1 jLWI
;1989  1v _   199012  I 9901  ,21.J  I990  LJI_ - 41 i -Z.-IJ3
d1990      I 1991 ,     41981 yItU  1990 ILL4 1989 u
JjlJI '1991 o-L_:<A sbil 1991 deJ   1990 LI 1990  -"!J
42>L_Nl JI_=I ZJPM  1986 1AJ 9- JP  194  -,-J - LaLJ i
,1986    41982 jl 1989 s,J 1985 o  11979 JYI 41986
L~jU 41983 LJJ$f 4_>E w1990 CI _198 195l  91991  86
.1988 JX:1981 412L-Il J-SY 921990
6-1 J5AJ
4 1  AW21 L~Jug 4   4R  i -U yL U
~+~Jp2   4L~3y 4~ 9L~ L 4j~Z~- ) .  -   ,   L) I < 3'j  L �JMI  4UL~,j
443~~~~ jl>4.. I^9�  .�  4t�UJg 4)JgR 4.)KLlgW 4KrJ 9L.t
8_*g  L_J 1G_ <,j' SUMG;I >1- Y SJ J S glji
- _9   J9j L39 QJAJ 44 Jg g      4 ))< 4zjg l ;eI;Jy 4%J,J
4-l4UySl 49trsl 4 'Z yL~jj h1 $j Z.4g B  ' 4k1  r 4zW.�Ji
4Gy 4JWJ1 >tig (3   -"T             -Yj U il4 4LL -rJgI 4
4jZL_Ll 44lJ /yl 4-'))�l 41..L 4kUgiI 4LJA 4UWS 4.QL2I 4Lu
IJIj _y~~~~~~~ <''jllsJg
368



8-1 J5AJG
91 G    'I -  '- L  L   'S L 
Ii-     JI;l  2I  aIy-l uIj  Iw jL 
<J I  Izs C;ijf2 i  Iy41i5sN 
2-2 JlSJI
L;U1 4J    bLilW >t       - JJ WLJ M
369



Cl - - - - - -- - - -
3~~~- .Jc 3l  ) 3 00j  x\, 
,0. - 1  I        ' *i0X X3&^ 
]  .3  -J1                     kJl 00 , g 3 g n0>0q J' 
|  0  nE-~~~~~~~~1i  .,,,'  i-  i  A



~~        o4j'  '  4W  .j  4~4.U  6U0~
LL-j_)  JL;G_r,al  o-Uj  C)
i1 4J91fr~ 4>Jw9l  .4  4L 'yLY 1 .U
4UjrL ,W 'jy 491  J1 iLyf .1 ;j22       4LLGgL  i
44 4�jJ       4Ld 4JE %5Y- e9< bUal414J9  L 
4U9W.c !,J(3IglyU) ej~ v J t%&je  4,C) y 4U1yS 4A  4lL
>J~IJ 44~l91)rJI 4LL 4O A)l�..J 4Ji)5 J 4I&Je 4j4LL.-JI I-lLJ
.(J<yl 91 /L,) iJI9SI UN  X, -UJI L1
4- L?y  i--~  1       4YK2 44)91.~ 4uu9 431 4W b1
C~~~~~~~~~~~~
\ J 6  . 2  - Ijy e 1 6SS @1 e~~ gL 1J
ie  < nCeGA eL> 499 uSy4J+1 ij,A 4Ul1
371



~~~  ~~~~ 
~~cFrp
,~~~~~~~~~~~~Fi .71, ,
Kin,f' '<h' 1n'eir' trl a' Si ? # -v' i7mTh' K
1R5R1C' 1  n' snn:15n '1 f rc,l 4 '  l-tri,
6C<)  C-  gE   c   : f  C7: trrnfi~~I



1-4 l4AJI
41992 99x2 41977 NiK-ie 41983 W9,i           1990 +,SsW
>,Ais41g 978 -lx JK   1978 ,k1 JKz c1986     -1' L.� 41988 X9
X,     4161992 LL5� 41992 L--.i .I41992 1y1  1983 �kjja 41977-1975
JUl,_l 41992-1991 LtLU i1986/1985 LJ       1988/1987 LiuL I1987
Lt�1l 41991-1990 w       i1987 -J_z 41989-1988 S4=4 41992-1991
.1985 ox-   ubY'8 1985 ox5   W
1- 5   i.5.  
~ 41992 4-X5I jj  41977 D-l   41983      >   41990 2
aslI41978 eL    l   1978 _XlJ~ c1986 uL L2       1988 .;i
Su@1 41992 I-L-5�1992 L-J 4- 1992 LJIy.2 41983 �Lj-3 1977-1975
1992-1991  IU 41986-1985 LSJ_ ;1988-1987 1I-i 41987
_ 1991-1990 e     1987 LLJA c1989-1988 iULW '1992-1991
.1985 oxlaY        1985   &
3-5 J.r,4f
fiI 1~   I L-- il_ ;yL I KDscXl4
,_,,>J~-L 4Wwl 4L 1,ifL 4b, 4J1NA 4U1 4<W �
I _ J L 3 c7L3l c   cUSl
373



uji e4JJi 4XRJI eLi5Ju GI&J9C G!J;1 lje I _r.JI  I >L ly1e1
-  21  -_ygJ  L--.1   U I_ I1  -A4S  R SI Z ljd   jL-  ;1;1J
ji~  ~   .5    j! LIj) .1  LI %js '-Ll di U-, Oy-
46 L 1 -  S 1  1   jlql --H+i 1S    j
"Sul L-.L 11i   L 5j'L-              juLjl ;1  6  lu l
a  ':W-  -L;   IU9 LLt1                     I'yi x1,14
io>l l G l 7CLJ G jj1 ^C Jl  i|jeD-l -jjJ JI)j-J '1? k j
iGpI < i-J-iIeD%4-I U  GSJ 11 WI L-jJ"JI
_41C-L -Jj,   J L 1> Lj ZI  -141  - , J1   Lr9 Gj'l,A b % ju
,A +t;Q              L51 I4Q  JJI  IFX4
,J G JI GLJI I G<XYI eY<l fl ' jAl -iE9p;1j J
GI iz),? KJIIJJH JJL jiSjuJ 1l7srZ  iZ
:,lJI L$ 'lSL, 'L2lf�Jl-eAJl ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~9h3t >JW JI G1j -'j 
lLi ,LilJI ~~34U ,JXlL1JIZS2J



4 -5 sJS-
4u;yl  Ng  t,1iSll 9tj. JX  .1995 �  u
i ,~~~~~~~~~~' LJ<,iS  -1  - 'S  '. I. -I iUI--
'U    L 2  6ju1 i. 21 sL  i )'L A -
e11~~~~~~~~~~~~I. 'jjjJl J,IY CLIl,4_G )Jli).)Jll
' 'L JL1'  119'-    1f J Iy9
X1,;5, ejLre- -S  G JI4I;  e+J-JI j oA l  11DG;
65- JSJI
. lg l  ; X p < P;,375l 



LJ .y -                l LLj 
.J~RJK, ;gJ 'YWyY ;JL Ge YS
1-6 J.JI
J1 bLU? 11 LL ;LLL Xf 1S     1 U1 
o cGL--yJI  v 'L JI  -1  kJr  iI4j X'L-   :U   W- I Z4i)d   6,LJ 
J=I 4J>JI sllJJI ;XLAJ Il L;X1L _+sSL , ,j `-E _2 L
9 )LL1LX I u.    Li
376



4&xiJ y 4, _+W 4(C)1y) >1 '6  -^iG   -p3 9J-,  >
>-'1~~~ '6J 'L<11      :  >I    9
jp. ~ ~ ~ ~   ~   J -I
~~~~~~J;       _yqL $1, - 1-61
4_c I . I  *u ! 'LL1j ij- IJ L< U-9 9X   J
(jI ~ .5elj  gl_Xc) -,2j  -
U 1l U1l i�I2._ -   L- , L5  y,3 L
-  Y&7  ~~-&Y'  ~   IJL ~  jj.)UL-J
GJJjlJI L1 H f ~~~~~~~~~-4r4jI: Z,_i  o ; t ,WI Gg
L--J I i91 U ZJy I,4 I41S  JI,  ^4lS
377



Fr5C' S'i1 �' 1r'.  -4,1' i 1 pr"4  1CID
i       -n? : r4jl    '5      r     17[-@' m'17t1' [141  1-5
4-1 I- ) rr: rrc,  r:l>   Hw l     ?l 
fSC7' 1&f1c(' 1c[' +1-m&' <'  1~~~~r-, rrv



I~~~~~~~~~~~~~j
J9 LgSl zA\ '6,ji  -1,ij&4JI G5-J9y L +Gk Lj L
(<;JAI~~~J i_lbl         JIs jlal X,i,1,4,il-l -a_,91
0ILj  ILAJ-) iLL-JI y  d2jy  9 1g9  1q)  i}   ij
-_1 O ~Lyij Io ju' J2-,Jk  i-rt1 i!
1  i<>  i~~,,L-.  yL- .J i,,ly - j21
IJ;  JJ  gejjy  be  e gW -0I 9U o--5  iI9
G~~~~~~~~~~~jAlrlu UI 4 ell J--> Jij- sj, y9
|   * - i4 NJI G9379\  4H  ,1G 



t- j;      ,         : -  7 
Ko     i  I
~ a      I~    U a ' . { ik  ' t, ti
IT.*                    iK



(2)o pi~ui
,9Q  w2>" - 9 *I1Aw   oww^ w 1 y.   i



JvWI Jg 4  c o1A1 , zL)i~'  191 ci.1995 j�1 1 Uy9
L~~(1992 '1986) LL~~~cUJ .I~;9~~
l~~~~' -~~~~~~~-  ~~~~I   U
ga  + 3yi,  + Xy2 + 6t + OT, +
-, �J,I 8l ot :t39 U
j 1 W' 2S1  4               JcU  j *Y   1995 ClJI
o~~'~.QL.U S J.t{ oy 4! .) 4m J! s1 O+ 1!S
jAjI (1992 ,1986)1  Ip,s  "4j=NI jij-ll  _tAi :Riti  I
I -i   L) a5l  j,1~      L)  L- D4JssJ  u t,bJ 
;_Ala^ -JI it Y  a  4  4  ji I
382



t~~~ iS � ,rl~
~~~oiJy jAlo 4...W            j-J    1S d 
41J-JI, j    l Z,Jl.      >
QLJsJpUl ~ ~   ~   ~   -d jLJ1,d      -d    ; L>Jy   r
-0.3163       0.0597         0.9787         0.4176
(-4.086)      (2.643)        (7.296)        (5.461)
0.0191       -0.0031        -0.0528        -0.0224           '  J-,
(3.897)      (-2.387)       (-6.535)       (-5.013)             6Y
0.0970        0.0177         0.0934        0.0641       v       i-y
(7.745)       (6.730)        (5.673)       (5.262)
0.28          0.38          0.57           0.51                R2
287           265            286           277          ,       ,
'1985'1970    '1985 '1980   '1985 '1980     1985'1980
1995 1990     1997 1990      1995 1990     1995 1990
Pi           Lo ,L
20 '9                       - v<W- 1  S  1  Vs olJLI 38
383



2i  90   ,      a.  100 "   j      j J      L5   -L �, u410 o LUVi
Sj  ~     6    10 -     i L     Jy   J, aL 
J)fW  45L,J-'yi .                    -1 ~        Jl jrS .jL1
,,'U t2J1W~ j          J-U    J Jl   ak ? 90 J     tvp        A yj
I "i" J 0.5 9     ,       1   N J         }iA >  o
."" t2J51 J 0.90
;      W1 Jil 1          S            L~,y.i A1 Gj  L; i  o    l\
d, Suy I Lr C S X r,                                 ;i5     a.,),oyl1o
.6W 1 'Y UA-         ,       6 91j                    -. jW cz S  .
IJJxJU OK1 jL> J JJ jW   J
-4.238       4.8793        12.2932       28.2619          ,ji
(-4.155)      (4.357)       (1.982)        (3.794)
0.0253       -0.2399       -0.5476        -1.4343         ,,g' �i
(3.945)      (-3.592)      (-1.446)       (-3.284)            Wy.
0.1411        1.322         4.204         4.7352      uei    6 l +
(8.431)      (8.359)       (5.194)        (4.899)
0.30         0.62           0.35          0.44               R 2
287          265            286           277
'1985'1975   '1985'1980    '1985 '1980    '1985'1980
1995 '1990   1997 '1990     1995 '1990    1995 '1990
384



l~~~~~~~~LJj j |~-j                   9 
,?  j;l      ;    -L t  4   ij fi*P 
91 -1J21 1 <vH ~~~~- p             Z I   OL  8J 
I4   J a   I
~~~~ZA,                        1-3X .JAs ilJIl io 
~~~ ~~~  0    S~ 41 DI jpJ-I 3p. <:tN 8bE J.KW  199
~,ATh }yUu  ~  ~ ~    U   Yl i A 9 ZL  y
7>f~Q~L J5o?oJg 7yi)L
9--
385



-,ijJL<15j  -,,p   syS'-ul -!   u )J o  JJI ?e  z Li
QAIhLikJI Jua sJ
2-6 JI L� o ;       4-6 j 3-6 ! 2-6 jKY  -
3-6 <I:!J\I?i           4    ;D    crl
J; 4-6 J     .s#- i J             - 
386



(3) pg-ij,~l
4j!Jl1 JkI>1 LA WAY ; @ VI 6 &.. P 



4#uL1aJ Jj2l
LJI ,wi          1991          68        85              1985 Lir
1991
ea! *>t;- ...... 1 9Agj t 1986'1987 rl
1999          87        74       -1994'1991,1990
1994 1Y        64        87               1989 LJr
Lu. et       1995 J            61        85              1990 UYy-
1989 '87-1985 LU-Jl
1999          87        75         -1994 '92-1991
,ti eJJ2 Jlou-    jj,wTj rAw     74        60                1970 u�
64        63                1970 w�
1998
- 2u;         j>-9XJi        45        60                1972 u-s
1975
>"> jUJ,l   ,lX73        64                1980 1Ls
1995
67        67                1980 Wu.
1998
,ei  '-5       75        66                1985 LL-�
1995
79        64                1986 usw
1995
75        75                1989 ULS
1996
,7x1 gjL    E       I J o- -) Js  71        72                1990 Lus
1998
388



,fi i1    1A    199853             62            1990 uf
4 J~~-   1998
-iJ<,15 X 84    67            1991 S-
1995
- -8 49!  -  1999      8 5     7 5       -94-19921S
stclJI    1 999
",1996     68      80          1980 0,Ud
,'ij ' .1J1  75   72           1980 ,
,'~~~      1996
,ei i , <:  r 88  68          1983 �,ji
1998   4
,ti iaSj, C-_f1.1 ziF  91   68          1989
1998 &- 
ia 1       ^1     -           e-J77  74  1990  -,i2
1996
't J  J   1996   81  83        1990 S
">'         1996
77      74          1990 !JWS
1996
xUlc
88      67          1994
- tJI   1998   3
389



isS1 jeM'1  1999 l     55   87          1995 ,1
;sS1 reyl  1999 l,   61     82           1995 S
;sS1,tyl  2ACj999   88      73        -93-1985 LCd1
Jv1,>'1  ~~1999 vz,  83     70            1995 LLll
431y '9j ,  I 999 l,  59     80          1995 z9
1y ;9x __  2C! b1996         8            94- 1993
z>1,>91~,r.5- PAC    83     80      1988, 1986, S>1W
oWLU14a1y  ~1999                   -1994-1992 1990
GSSULI ,LU1  961998  104    79           9  S1
LU1,ti  ~~1999 J ,  94     84           1995 L1)LW
4cPLJI ,i  1996 CJ     5      511968 sUUI
4CL28 i  ~1996 ,,   5       571978 iLUU
431/ it5! '~- 1996 >,  4     591988 UU
431/ i9! 6  2 : J '  93  43    -94-1993 U
oLr,L-I    I 999933
-31 ;9^ ->  J< ^>  ~~~62  76        89 -1988 Lujj>
otclJI   1 999
431/ ;9! z  -o<! 'k  104    83      -94-1991 11Ljf
sa 18   ~1999
isA1,ayl  s*<! Pb   93     76       -94-1989 :X
i,;\, 1143y1 999
390



i5,4221 8yl  1999  ,     73        84              1995 J;-9
1999            83        82               1995 yy2
-~6 :--     -                71       76               1974  >
oLPLJI         1999
61        67              1974 r
~LJI           1981
J-        juLa2Jj         64        83              1981 e
1999
431? ;Lz! :--  je_,:,!         64        83              1991 -EJI
1999
1   iaSj ~o     J, ,>t         103       81              1994
aWL,2L-       1999
> S ,        _@S! >)         50        62             1987    ,
oWL' J I      1999
8j ;J$ULI LULLI  >6, e*+ 7 5      7 9             19911    <
1998
4A-JI a          1999         102       69 994-1985
zA1,eNl   ~jj,---Tj-<       93        84         1991 osa  4.Ll
1999
+K xt I        53        83         1994 o       L
1998   y
4jl?  @zv  _>    1999 ,  lj9     64        76         1995;oJv4�i
391



LAJI                    (i)6     >           JJ   S
1988           57      61       1980
J< ^ >6 ow;sJl s
as ,i                     97       67
1999        9                        94-1985
okuJI        J~J44                 70       1987 o-xAl 4d
~~L~AJ     1994
iC.j- L
2LJI ,Ai 2J �1      -^ i73          69       1987 ;-sA a
1992
iJLJ1 J2Ul
4' ,ry      1 992           62      65           1985    j'D
5 g,'     1992 J=J 
oLJI ,ei                    *       89           1989 s9
2000 \ iS
as,L-J*                             98           1995    'D
20007            6              18
J;Y    EY    19Q-            76      63             1989 yLiE
1992   K
KK Jl :1-,
1991           113      30            1970
,TYI J,>   1991      ~10      50             1970S4l
1991
1999   L       *        50            1981 �-iW'
zr, L-J I ,Ai 199 S  !     89       70            1989 yjijl
1992   L
's-' uti      * 200063               1989 4iW'
2000
392



LJ,t i        1999 J,L         *        54             1990   j
ZPLJI    ~,9                *        67              1995 k
2000
o ~'           :~-                  1999121  84  93 -1992 6,L4
1999
sL.JI ,ei     1999 ?4L,        *        68             1980 J0 J
ZPLJI         1999 , -         *        71             1987 JXJ
jse_         1992  +   ,     114       71              1987  L
2~LJI ,-&  1999 ,           *        89              1990 L4AJ1
oL:,i  99, y *  101      1996JLz6
1999             95       101             1996 L-J
a OJi &c4J1       199716                 80              1985 j~JI
1997
rw91 ot_JI   9--! '   ~~~112     80               1985 ~
1995
tjj-js JL-;    1992           47        88               1987 s~i
2;LJI ,>i     1999 _,jL.       *        67            1984 Lo Jf
<5s,i'l ,>yl   1992    L        85       84             1988 yirf
1992
2A;Jl ,>i     1999 ,           *        70            1990 Y-yf
~AsLI ,>i     1999 ,           *        90           1980   L-r
aL.JI I       1999 ,           *        97           1989 JLr
93        81           1989
1992 
;L.JI ,>i       2000                  88           1989 L<jLz_f
393



LJI    U,.) - 200091                     1995     ,
i~L.J~ ~     2000
GLJI r'i      1999 ?f          *        76           1985 -U1 9L
UIi J,a       1999  ,          *        81           1988  WI
431/ .9! :r  >  J J      97        731 jv
1999                                  -1994' 1992
43        66            1987 j
1992    -
119       78               1990 'j
1999
t31y itSx C - -  J>Sj >W       97        84        9-9 p
1992  ~ ~  ~   ~    ~   ~   9-19
1992 r>z!    45        77             1989     :l
~aI  i  J>LJ z1;k    58        45                1990   k
1997
~L~Ji ,.'-i  1999 wr*                 65            1986   r
147       81             1989   r
1992 ~,---
~UJI i '      1999 Wr*                  68             1990 r
1999 '        95       75           94-1988 u9
;,u1       ~1 999
1999   l        77        80              1994 L
.xxI JL.-     1996 >           74       56            88 - 1987  1
_ Ju;-    1996 ,yJ,       66        51             88-1987-l.W
j-d1 JL-"     1996  J          66       39             1980 K    1
394



_X91 Jus  ~1996 be,      78       39            1980   ;S
JI uti  ~1999 ,-        *56                   1986    ,x
,)-d JL-C   1996 e,>        6         41990               ,x
X   JL-   1996 Je         81       50            1990   ,xPl
Jp ,el      1999 L,,2j              60            1992   ,x1~~
,j c-__      1998 :         48       71           1992 L --;ju
C7 _      9fi->         109      73       -94 - 1993 JW<_
oWLJI~1 999
;9-  '8   1992 ae,   ~~~119    58             1989 SL<e
,LJI ,91  1992S,Xj~~~~7        78             1991 ,9
j-di JL-r     1999 L_,sl    60       63               1986 ;
-  :~~~~~~-        3~~33     44       1980 6,    j#
a-L.J I     1997 jt
ZL.J ,i      1999 ,4*42                        1984 6,   ,P
L21 Ju;   ~~1996 js      49        42       1984 L,    JP
LUI ,Fi  ~1999 SHZ        *51               1988 L,   JP
FLAI JL;  ~1996 J9        53       51       1988   ,5J#
29       54        1991 L,   JP
Z7L.JI      1997 Dt
_LLi JuL-i    1984 i-       66       59              1973  S
ZPL-I ,I     1999 5aL        *        7              1973  S
SA1 W_2z1  ~1996 De@      88       57              1973 LSSA
JI ,;    ~~1999 ?         *69                     1984  S
SA11_JXI  ~1996 O,        93       69              1984 _JLSS
3;9 - 9 '?\  1999 ?LLS!  ~80   85            1984 L_A
395



du) -rz       i) ;)L
67       43             1978   ,
19921                     431-~I- <
SALJ--        1991 -+      71       43             1991  i
oLclJI~1 99 1
sSU1JiSl '     992 su,         85       80                1989 
1992 
asI j        J}e!JBLZ         85       84               1990
1992      ,
1999 ?yL         *        71              1978 94ii
1996   ,        137       75              1978 D4JI
CtJ I        1999 ?           *        80              1988 >4J
1996   ,        127       76              1988 �iU
>31^ t9!                              _>        2A&, t 118  75  94 -1991hJn
1999
aI vai                        84       79              1994 YL.y
1999 ,LZ
a L-j 7I                    84        79             1994   i,
1999 _0L!
ts1y 9J:~~~-  s<! !>6 ~ 99        69             2Jl,
1999                                   94-1991
aLL           j i!?! bL_A;   118       72         1994  _
1996
104       78         94 - 1991  L
1999
'r tJi     ~~~1997 2S      85       73        1989 L    l,w
9jx       1986   &'        56       64         1982 C,-I ;JIy
396



(uS)  H       O~~~;ULJ tbJUV
,tyl iS :__  iL1JYe, i, 84    62       1989 c---,J Gjly
sasU1    1994 G,
L~~~~                    ~~      ~~ 17  7 5  1971 Lj>
isAl      ~1991
,8E1 i, 21  t999  X   ~4     86             1980 1
i5>1    199
GLJI ,ai  1999 ?jL      *74                    1980 -LU;
jeLbil  ~1996 j,       70      84             1980 -Ll
j+;l    ~~1996 j,      85      90             1989 -LL
ouz1,ei  ~1999 z        *       80             1990 <-Ly
jLl Jui   9X- ^!   ~~74     72            1992 L-sil
1999
oaSU1,eNl~  Y j99      77       74         1989 se,U
LJI ,ei  ~1999 e        *       87            1981 rt,;jj
jse_Nl ,eNl  t999  X  ~95    77            1989 ?:
a- LJ  i    1999 z         *       93            1990 -)t,jj
aS, cro  ~1998 ss;     65      74                  Ll
.((Oaxaca) 1973) 6-LSlJl 3 J J _t s  L-J  tJ)  y  J .y
JL-E) 4lgI,  :i j   (  L    lJI  i  iLL6 100  -A>  j <,I X y 
397






ii$~(t~)



Ij
~~b ~4  1999 Jiu
J~~J -~   4L           91-1 U J*  IK       1
{ 9)-i 1 kLJ t      14 _- L  owj  -           199lpj8l 81l
*JW      9    ~   -, . K %1   Jfi  u Y a  1997 3.19
*~~~o *s 919~-  9i &J,ic
4 00 sl
.juj-p~ ~ ~~~,L 4LX1i 4-a
~~~1a@3J91 14& ; es.JI ,l Jf,51        1997 j
,LJ                 j   j)19  A 
o1 o;J91! cIjjS S Fi~~~~J-
uryl JlLi 5400



lOt,
f-T  -~'�r~ fC-~  c-jo  ~  ,-=Wr~ ^-f- Ir-5 Vf
* ? �  ;  -      -v - If l  r 
L661~ ~ ~                 mi- I:S f  I'  75- ,<m
L661                   ~      ~ 
- ~  lc   f6 .i-q  S  r 10   - S '
L661                         Tcr ' *n-, V lFrn'  > m   ? e  eF -
*'e          err rc  -
yE,~~  I  F>r  CI< WI<e  frm sr{s' snT r+' 
c' >Hf l,qr  ;  l -? :  q  -i p 
[S1<?~~ L61 r +r e F,- I�4  5^ u,mfl f\frlF 
E%~~L66l  '< jeff l<'  1K1.  f&I  A7Vcr'
I~~f?11 T'1-r~ 
~~~- Cr%         r' rfFrcw



j _ , ji1 .L51.    P: jtl +  9  1   -j
J
1~l    _  '  -..
jLS-j 4jUY  ,a 311994
J-01~ ~   40
ZtS'l -J  L-_I,    k-LD    ial 'Sipt  3LYI
~~~~ j! vLisl,i  v d  I jui           io; 1994
>  e8J=lvH9W1b     V-   ! + >12j>
v C1 S ~~~~402L1y ^y



j -             J jL-I                3j 
Jj           1til t f21 ^, A S o1 1 9Jaf, , 
2iiJl. 1ljlS   L5- tb J     I Ll,6 j    1  9 94
J3~ A U      -    a      9, j   y , W 
j'l_ _1 ;JjJ ji JJ  jrj Jil 1 9ll  ^,__t
I    z   i:jJrl 4.L>J i,JZ  , 1 4-f l  ;
~~~ j~~~~ ~~~~sw        j ju,~
; 91 z!JI 3 ;K+il 1 9f Jb sL; ill z" i; _F 1993 l
LJi~~~L,
403



J-L~ ~ ~j                          1990~U
JL~~~~~~6~~~~o11 ujJL 'J
Z-A>Lb JIj -~U-  4  -  -u~  ~J
~9~20 J ~J
-~~j 'Z,'
~~~~~~JL   tLLj9l ks  J4-l           1y 2,a997l
L~~~~~ ~~~~<
zi ;LJ5  ,-y  i ,     yi  Ai J       199
404



-u-  '9i ___9                        W: i j _  -
,iaJl _, ,u ji J%- 16 a,> iz, 14
i;Ivx.,i_! i91 ;,jL J 121 \1 _   juLy
o  e  Y! .i~~_,                          1 999 .  .t 1 91a
,.a_u1  a  .e ll Lif y ,'u1  ..  ~~iy Y-
y! oLll 3 21 1 H40



Wi -                       J L ~ (~�~b  1998 98
.j     ,i
jl26 aSI  J L:�W  zI i;t (uU
40l 6L-L
jbl  k!l eJl Lgu)ij  ;E -J JL-   1> -Lj ;"
i0- ~~~~~L,              jL..Jl :s 95 4A-J jLsl 199
J~~~~~~L        _j  "! '1S 9  lSA  J
- ~~~~J1 ~~~,u         8Lj     -6 ki1LJ!X k
a.JS  OL iSk p o LaW DJ W;
406 JHlJ;



'91lLj-  ],Jl   9         1i>
Jj~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~..
zfi .4;U>S 9Ll , 1 jJ  -',i J  >  1996  86
,>  LI.� >,i& L: S   ri  p
,,UW  Jl y<i ;J-v%  ;7,~Lit  l   ii4
43~~~ J  l J <j  lI.tl4JJ 
9~~~~ Ir >          3 >      (1, lsg y ,y l986
ol ~ ~ ~~4~j NJI
JSJI J! )J21C  ?   IJ407 uyl<;i8il  F -18)p



Opt UW                       L LJ 
> #   ;D J <5iiJI2000  )'J
,gJ=-~  J~ -J  y  LilJ,sl1
,~4  L   l 3 1   F
J; > jlJ jJf S1 > je, ssl - ~~1999
408



(5) to-i  1~
IEo tl I    6ii 



J1 ,WW -AI   O2   1   _ijJ :WKW - 1-6 j-UaJI C
:tjj sa-fJlI i es
1990 �Ls
Ya1 40                           < J  LjyL   )   0
j~~~~~                  -~~~~L- I 1 j <  ;y L  yl
,j ey,  1 Ko1j. d- i - j N U?;     a+-t S  L -J
OJe- ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. (5) J2 .Z i .-LSJ 41vL
I Okyl       ;.,y a UL3 .1 19 1. l
1:A                                       -\!4114?J Ul(19879 Slwi
~~~J-i y) r OL A S1Ji 1j-4 L? -L;
oz~~~~~~~_            L          jsl  s u iJ lX i.18
L5r          _Ujil Xw1i 6e,)S1 , ;ti5Io6:S Z__JU i.(1997,1996  1
-L  JJ   I C U -, *(1994  ,. LjI
410



ji ~ ~    ~    *jJ @4:S,y              G
JU..uI       WjL        J-1,    JL&�I   8Lly~i Jf.L    I
1.1        25.7     79.8     91.4    44.0     66.2         J
0.8        15.9     84.0     106.8    39.4    61.0 
3.8        9.8      66.4     81.3     46.3    52.4
(1 999,1997) 1j-dl ~lJ >~ :,L-i S; -L. - L+19uS->   lyl
(1997) Jjjxj iJ j     1 -   & #- ,j -=- -   rp .:-L�    :_ -l
4()1999,1977) 1j-dl  '(1999)
411



b~  bc  tL         L     't  tQ , %  G.
r� bL5   1                 [ rr ~       I 
e  t-  'e  :S   00   '.-, ' ..  Z t [ t   F  _
K~~~Qt )  G                Y6u1 ;5;vvtt
>   X  '  t-D  >  'W' (L Z h- Y k c, Y C f a- 1 W W; [P~~~~~~~~~~~~(
* L t V t -  A  k r Z vl 9 C kb W S r  r~I
Kkjk c1; t|                   ^k    | 
0~ ~~- c;(.1L.S X   rc
(2  E  a E t i _ F Ct   j f



j4      j yl S          y     juil
~~~~~  ~ ~ ~  ~   ~  ~    
2.0      3.3     180.7      306.0     73.7     53.6     Y~jt i
1.9     3.3      125.3      218.3     79.7     61.9 
15.1     30.6     630.1     1278.0    70.7     75.6
\5.i ~JUi .l.Ji  ,  f2i I~  ,  :2    JI  A3  OJI~ 'W3 
100              (1978 $$Y xIA -J (  (JL)  j 9
413
j            V                   v_w4JgaXl j1;vA uYI t8v t
oD6~~~j                             ;S1,1JvlOS9 S + ul 1_ iS
413



.JUb '' L^t2l        ' U  a�IU 
j4L, 1  L.p fj :zJaul jL3L,J1  L JZJLUFi
415
&S 19� A u1S i1f6 U-- sU 1                        10 izJ1!
+1~~~~~~~~~ij             a; -(-YU5 J~ L~,Ji L 1 H l Ldky
i,                         . ( 1 S1 < e 1 .(eL,  j  5eS iaLl+ 
*3 I, j ZL i + 1  Ld   si-
,jbAl  z  <   ];J JjJlil  3 ,<,1         zxi >S1  ;?
1 - ,c~~~~'lI        ji  ,, 9.3 86  1995  c; , Wl iy
1~~~~,l Z XZ >1 j J-l       1-6 j 5 &d5     j  .1997 Ca,J-&
.1995 �21       i        YJ 4000  -)Wi,,i1 ,;>-Yl 1a1Xj
u1 z 1 < 1!all ;(1992,1986) Dj.
_9 o8l 11 >   ;IJL-~ 1e kjL 44 1  as<1        v.l
414



j  ~~~  ~~ ~~Gj L4 'j    .L
u ;La    t-.K L Y  jiLU ;Ac,1  J Us  - J
.44' ;L-
.. 1LJI JL -21 Jyl �X 93 JWc j!  , J y11 I
9  5. 1 9   -  J lj'j-I 765c  4L �
4jJI   A 615  j5  j .1997
~~~~~~~~J Dl.1>, e1W9xiz ? alji 1
415~~~*z>1 X



s3� -LJl zCA -i J,Ji  c s3  J  j - :J.JW1  P
- ~~~1995 �2 J~ j,, 9385,  ,, 766  a   U -, l
1997 9Lp j1 L
- 1 iy 4j JLWC , .(1 JfJ     j   vc 4 Wj
X        c  31 l~~~~J jj L.-v  2z -i  - 2151a- Z-tH9 
J.,Sl Z-a   1i 1 . i(1998) $15l  -  ZS'l  J 2
,LSLzL 'J96 4LJb 4L1- 4-19  ojo  u1z
.JL l L , l
I 0 J3 -4  Jl j*  j1 O G   Ji  1
2 4 4-   s  \  -  91 i 6  3 ) ?   400 i   4J9
.(1996) ,? e   Ul W  .y A J3 1  30 
416



A 'o-~L5          ij i �  4L5)j  j  4 jy
IDJ           o Ji ? U+1 1 J 1 tAJ  L u vo
,8:JIugl~L                   Z. Z1tUa!9 Ja  1 
>XU o                  -) sJ ,U j  L) ,  J
I L.  4e-Utl <e     ~, o a J l 
J .1i  JLW i I      N          'JX1oWI z t , . 
JL0% 1 c~~UI ~ia { ilJ  L4 uIi9
1993 W  J.l    II92J2  18 :  1996  Y AH  A-
I  ;A  4 L)  3Jii Li ,
i j~~~~~~~~W
417



I
418



7  ................ ......................................................................................
9 ~
10  ............................................................... ...'.j   .iL .~   ~ L. . 
13 .......
17          ..Jj.  . . . .            JU lsiI Ial   -     iI.3 Li i�AiU 
21.I                                  Ji, oGLiU    6l L4aJI3 �IUd ~
28  s.......... . . . . . . . . . . ...........          jlj I  L
30  ...........................................   ....1.-
43.U! eLJI 1 UI -J1iJ e 
J5I JaiJI 1
547>J. ~~Ij -jUI ( ,I LL 1J --il� J I LLW;I
80.JSl~ij 3ilI v                              vli    v oI,LJI ^l vJ iLWi
83 ........................................................................................................................................... ;L ~
99.&..-j.JI                                       Jia~ ~j~WI V VLv il 
991  ........................................... ...........  i l ,   S ;
12   ............................................... .,  a ; Y 1:  -  I  
122.-                    -             -                       e    l�l5
131  ,ji c
14 1  ............................     I c - -IXnlj  1 1_{v UlJ.LY YIj
14 4  ........ ..............................................................  .: IjI   xJlj   . 1  Y I  I>  41
149..                                                       . " ll e9a1
161 ..................................................... .................. j I ^.YL
179 ..             ... :;L1 _,I- 1
419



195 ~  ~         ~         ~        ~         89 
1 9 1  ...........................  ............................. .............. ... ;  e YI  .,19 . j - ill  1
19 5  -- ----.................... .------... .. ........................................ ......... .......... ...I ...   SL A   L.
19 7  ....................... .................... ...... ............ . .; 11, I J I  4 .  VG)I
200 ................. SYIl JLW. t7nj:fl ypvi a  ^1>sjl 12             vL
213  .    ............................. .~ U  ZI I  "L..  I  :k  2II   j,ilj   k
235 ..... . ........ .... l... .............   ^  s-JJ &.VI          i   JA
238 ...J...             .Ji........................... JI1 i _.-
249 .        ......L.. J.il .. >...              1 l.....J.i    j:..ii.,i -
255 ...4........ Z                           Ui .1 aI iyJl & jy<)1 I a
257 99...-Y                       I .I .-.1L.J ....I SEJI 3 g V
262  ii iL.........................                                   1  gL  -  mJA
2 9 9  ..........................................
304 .      JL... IJ f JIJ..I v  y�I bL. .I J  y;i IJ.LI & J .L.JI Cfi 
320.   L.-JI J1y 1 i SIi s1 ~L~JI J .i 4tO ji~ i JA7 @;1 
320 5..  .1             1          SJ   i  L'iI *      L 2JI JydI O fL   0
3 4 9  ...............................  ................................................... & f i d bJ.'I 
357  . ... .... ..........................  Sj l_aJl I  l  _e~   Ls:;  J_qjI l  Y
381  ..........................................L I   J ssVX  _ ,L u YI ,1;1:
387 ... J..j. y; ..i.I                      -      JL?iIj fL      1WI  1�A
(t) eJ 
399  ...... ...................... ............. ..............  l I J    I
(o) e 
409.~~~~~~~~~~~~~~2
4 0 9  .............................................................................................................................
4   14  .. ........................................ ................. ...........  u ,L i*L,  ^, L 1 
420



Z                jJ~  ;<-  'j   j  a'  j  'ji;  '        )t 
,   j   ,   j   s  4       ,   s  ,  1 )  A
'I ''  �''a'   '   X  'S ,   ',;l-2   I   1 ,   X  ,)  :)  DJ   J'i
G  =      ,              *  t;  s  i      4)   5 -,  n  - 71 
Z-J  >                   A  o                                       LO
1i111~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~- 
z ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~  3  ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~c
K       I
$1                    1.                       z~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~L