N WTP54 )Q~$ • !'H{B~ .. ~fijlfi • 1*1¥~ ~?if MGC006751 \ ~OVc S' l d3S 83t,';~lV~~~~~~3l:f :1: ~ It!- 61il- 1818 H Street, N.W. Washington, D.C. 28433, U.S.A. ~t' t~ ~JT 1f , T :f~ ill Efi ~ T1 )> l~ '@1 00 ED $1J 19B7it- 2~ ~-'(~t;~ -/I:EDFriJIJ 19B7lf-1t -~ r:p x~&~ -/t:EDfilliJ *- :m rt x ?-Pf _. tit W. 1i iE If, ttl ~t> f1 J t?9 , ~ 1i tt*~#£~7B~M~~ff~,#~t!tWWfi~ I f!=lltW:'R·t~1'5:i!11J lE t±:ttt.nff- '-J? r.ifi § e-~:tt!!.rz iJI 0 ~#:fx f-t- F*J 'EB.t~ffltt:t:5z 14 ~ Jt ~ J:B¥1J Jt\[ !M tt.*7f-t-~~~~•m~•- M•~~~~~~ ~~~*A~~~ ~~tt~t!tW*ft~Jt~~m~ l--1.& tit1itttffl$*Dt.Rt Bf.tttl *?fftt~Er~OO Wag ~$.~r:j:l~ffi~~~~~~~~~~~~~~' l!lt:fJ rJT m;gtt~ft! f+~H~~~1'*-~tit w.~n&Jt ~-m~~-~~~BtlltMOO~fG~OOW.~± .•m~~~~•w*~~~~~~&~t$, ~ ~~~GW~W~~~OO~~~~t$. ~~*~~T•lE~x~.~~~7~~~ ->J _____._, 'fa J1_ 7-;- -i't· BB 1=" ~ En F.i! II --v· 1)t- 3= :w r.n d': EB ~ JJ<>IOJI JJX./'1<: • 1 -'t-•ll<;J /y:_-R 17..-,.-, ....__:r:, IJ 1'1 1• I - -- rr --111 .- '- -rr£ :.:~ ~~H~ ~E?, tit W~n Yix q. -i ¥~ T ~~ 1I 1CJ wtf , OllJ § u *-ff ~ f'.l' & if-~ fj: ~ ~ l±l JT~ ' i't ?B tit 0 WWrl'~·iJTtb~J;:iWt)J, lff1J "fjf1J'tiJI" ? 1 l~i':@ J-lf-_i-_~.&-'B §, 1:i-~.,-t~x~ffi1~~'HntJ §. th 1f ti?:~ § . if~, 00 5, ~[X -r,'<~-EfJ't' iJI. i~ ~l [1] -11 tg tu m ~ ~4J 1'5 U: ttt: 1J ~ • if- f1J .. tit -1l'H~ n ~ ffi iJ~ : § liifffi:+uro § m ~.. ~·r m~ m~lilHt 8, ~J 0 J:~ if~fiJ~tf.J~ iff --AA i:iJ luJ T ~~J tt!J.j:Jt ~.~·'$:If;'<' : Publications Sales Unit. Department F. The World Bank. 1818 H St1•eet, N. W., Washington, D.C. 28433, U.S.A .. Publications, The et World Bank, 66, avenue d' lena, 75116 Paris, France. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Bamberger, Michael. A manager's guide to Monitoring and evaluating urban development programs. (World Rank technical paper, ISSN 0253-7494 ; no. 54) 1. City planning--Developing countries--Evaluation-- Handbooks, manuals, etc. 2. City planning--Evaluation-- Handbooks, manuals, etc. I. Hewitt, Eleanor, 1950- • II. Bamberger, Michael. Monitoring and evaluating urban development programs. III. Title. IV. Series. HT169.5.B35 1987 351.8'18'091724 87-2188 ISBN 0-8213-0RR3-l .. iii fllfll! ~*<~mM*>~r<~~~~~~m ~-~~=~mAa,m~A•~•>~-•~ ··ft-~o (1) ( T:Jfft ) 'fL~P'Jtf.j II @tf-lrJ~ ~~~~~~I~~~~,~mA£~~~~w~ I~~A~•.<-T:JHt>~r~~~~,~~~ ~~N*~&m~~m~-~~7M~,*~I~ ~~. ~~~~~-~m~~~~W7A~~~~ ~~~.~r~~mr•~~~~~mr~~~* ~~~~-*~~~~~~~~~.~~~~7- ~.m~~~*<~mm•>~~~W¥~A~ ~~--~A~-~~~~-~~~~~#A~m~ s*~lf:r~1l-~*~~ < -r• > ~~m. ~~~-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~. ~mr~~~ff~~-TAAfuW~*~*.<-r•> ~N*£~M~~mAA~~~A~~:~~~m WM4~&~WM~~-~~~~m~~~~~­ ~~~-~~~;~~~~AM~•*m~~~' •a~~~~*ft~a.<-T:JHt>~~~~~~ ~4~~,ff~~~=-4£A*~~~,ff~~ f~, 1J-~ tt,*Xfiil *, mr1± 1AJI~ ~ • tt,*X~~; ~ *' -4J!:tt,*X~ ~~~!U, i.Sf'~-T¥~, .R lr*~it~ T::tJ!m. <-T:ftft>~M~~~M~~D~tt~~~ ~·**[~~~~J£~W~ft~~~-~~~ < -T:ftft > ~!RW~*~-f±r~~;;r-: ~o1AJAT~~± <) : ~*'~~*,A4*~~**-••~~•w~ ~~-~~*·m~-~~~~~~~~~,ff~ Qt~. c1> ~:1"< -TM >: iaJt~ · HI18~~~~- · 1* ~~~~• [ t9as J ; rtt.W.~ftlj:*xf-f:sa-5. J.&* -T:ftft~RR~-,~~~x*·£~~-~~*' iE:f±;t~~ 0 v ~~ I*Jt¥a.~ 1-~~~ff~~~v~~M~-~~ 2. ana.~~~~,w~~~~~~•B 3. N*~~~~rn~-~~~x~m~~-~ •. ~~~~ft •• ·1 l!tl~~ ~ ~N~tl •· 2 l!t51~~N~~ 5. i.Sf'~~rJJtm 5. 1 tf'ffi' rPl § tf3•DIAJ [ EJGPJT~ ~ J m 5. 2 ~*~~ft~~*-~§~trr 6. ~~~~ff~-~~~-+¥~~-~~ 7. ·l·J~l·~~i.f~$1JJl 1.1 ~~R~JIE1ftf31'CJ:Im 1. 2 tgt,q~ ~~~ ~ tstnr I 1~ 1. 3 J~Effml!~>*ll 1. • flJitf~ I 11= &oo ial"m::t .. ~ •~ "*itt * ,QI)J. --~ " 1. 5 l!l~a~mtf3~~ 8. ~D1AI .. tl~51~~~~ I ·f'f 8. 1 ~ § x~e~~~~~ff'ffl'cp ~11= m 8. 2 ~~~~~~, ff'ffi'~-ffJ~~f£m~ 8. a ~~lit~, ifffl' I ~ F t±L~ ~ ,~ ffBi ffJ 8. • ~~~~~, ifffl'F t:H11=~~tl1i.f~I ~ ·ti 9. <~ift> ~11- - 1 - •> 1. ~J~f¥1frtFr.J¥J!7AA,B'JI!·t1 r~·~•-• J (1) [ ~:R<-T . ~J~~fl''ffi':l:UI-., &PXr.J !l~¥JI$JJ ~~-~-~m~~~o~~~~~~-~~ ijJ, ~~T~t:~ootFf!:a :(a) ~ ~PJTRU [~ ~~~~~A~-Jlf~~~&~~~·~-~- . &~1lm; (b) ~it~t:..w. [jUl.@~~ ~,JB-iJJiffi~ ~~~A~~4-J£~~~~~~,--~~ !W,; (c) !Ji ~ Vlfi~-~jU)'fiiJ o ~ ~ ;s>~lf -~lf ~~P-J:e~••JJt, ~RTtmft~'JToo~I'QJJm : • ~tt1~BJGJtmtt:tJJ; • ~~"' ;E~~x:t~ilt~~'*BJGtt7~~ JOj ~tj ; • -~·~$tjlf fQ]:.fm; • lf~~*~~~~•;BJG£~rrm~ :<:fSJlf~ll, 11J~~Jt£tll.rrm~ISJ& ~~~Jf~:ZfBl~~~· 0 · ft.iit I tF eg ~~ ~ eg £n ftr:l: 1± 'fiirf+ t~Jt .1:. ~~tJ7~~F~~Wlfil [ ~till$, ~-1±~ ~·· ~Rf·~~:<:~lt~~~*ffi~~eg-~0~~ •~lf•l'fJffm~~,f~T~~~eg~re~~il ]' j(Dif:ill&.A, ~71=5~~ #-~t$X -1'!~ ~~X jJc: • ~~~RF~~~~~~~§~~~~ !~]!fi"; . • ~~*~~-~*~~·*l'fJ~$, ~ ffij~~~~!!! ; ~-~~~-~~~~§~~~-~m £fJI~D~ ~t$XffiQi o (1) <:ti~> ~ fifrititJ ~- -tp~p <-=f-Jlft-> ~ l'fJW* •;;-; TISJo - 2 - - 3 - ff~U}f~t:p}L' J ~11=JitftffJ-"''IPi §, .5<-ft!tft§~ ~WJi±iif1Fx ~, J!tt.JE, 8J*J:bc1Ffc n1ff~Jttn ffJ~~~~m~~~~~~ffJ~§~s~r~~~ ~~~§W~I~o~~~~*'t!tftE~WJJE~ , ~ ~ ~ffl :.fc ~ T ~ ~ffi- ~IE ~ ffJ &ff.f~ it fttl fl'l ~ E.~ ~~~~' ff~$1j}l; JttP~Xf"Nit~~[fJT(fJff~JJ~ ,~~~~~~m~~~tt,~~~r~~§~~ ~~~A~-~o*~~tp~&ffJ~~1J~fu~~ ~j&tl~tt~~' Jt.tp:;*:~7t [ ~~~~] £t!tftff ~ijt]Ijfi § ~~J5X$7to 3.·-N*:.ftl~--~~m~•~§,Jt.~*~m~ ~~ [ j:·<~~> Jff -·-B if~A"f#A] ~r~~*-~~~,ff~1J&*M~~m ~~~~'**~-~£R~~~m~~~§~~ •tt~~~-~~~o~~~~•m~W~A~~ ~•mRffJ*~~m,*~M~~~~m~--~ ~~-~~~oTOO~-~~~f~~-~~~' ~~m*~llifDm~G~~m~-~~ffJ~~~~ •mMo~~~~,~-£~m~~-~-~*~ rnt:p-~~-fi~~§ffJ~~~~ffiMo~§*~ ~T~·JJ,~a~~~fJ'I¥~: ~-ffiM:~~ffJm~3Ntlo~~~mM '-~~D-~$7t~-~~Jt.~~~--(fj~~ ~4~~(fJ~~(fJ~~--~~-~~-o -~ffiM:~§u~~7~~m~~[~~ ~~, ±:t&, tt*),~, m•*~• J :-- •~mM:~~~iffJ¥~-~rr~~~ 1t~~t1t~F lli [ I5Xd1 J o - 4 - ,_ \..- \("" '· ·~ :s ~ ·~ •f'·..J ~ ~ ~y ,'\4 ...! ~ -~ ~t) -~ t(~ .s~ ~· v ~'"1- ~~ '.Jis.t ~- ~ '< ..,~ -~ ~ . .::~...~~ ~ ~-~~ ~I L._:....;:_l 6" ~ , , ...... ~ I'(~ I h 14 ' ,.... ....\ v ..ti~ , ,.q .JN ~ '>' - ..__._ - 5 - ~E']ffif~ : ~~IJI 13 fJiJIHAfZ tHo -~ffiH=-~fJiM~~~ftfZ~~-~~ 1-Fm [ iif~••gg•-•~~~~1f:AJ 0 ~~ff.~~l!itJ.~ ~ $~*.B't~t£~*~a;:a;~:t ~~~~~~~-~~40~--+~13~~-~ ~~~~,~§~~~~~T~~-·*~W~= ~~~-~~4;~§*fi~~&~~~~~~o 4. ~~~~~Ij:)~ ~~~~§~-~~~' ~~~~~§~· ~·~~~ffi~ag§~~itJ~Jt~~m . £~~~ ffi~~Fllio~~·~~~W~~~~~~W~* ~~Jt:t-B'o 4. 1 '* ~~ ~~ll~ (~· "T-"flft" • -=-•) '*~~~~§~~~~~~§-~(fJ~ ffl~WM~~~k*~E~~~~~·~*~(fJ~ ~~,*~~·ffi~~Flli£~~a~ . ~u~w ~~~*fto~~~·ffiiJ"~*:~§~~~~~ E~~*~-~(fJmAoT~~~-~-lli7-+ ~·t~~~~~§~~~~~~~o~mB~= ~f~~F~~**~~~§~*ft~~-B'~~, ~~~*•~~u~~~m~**~~~o~~~ 7~~~m, ~§~m~~~~7~F•~m~, ~ ~~ *"10 m t-J ~ tt ~;1<~~ 0 - 6 - - 7 - ' &~§~~~~~~,~•~m~~~~~ 7-~~~~~~m, §~~·~~fr~am~­ +~~~~~~~~w3~~~o~ma~a~: ff~:*:~l}r~~~t~Nit~~*~~ . . ~~~' ~ ~~~~~-~~,ffi~~~~~~~-*~~~ ~o Ji.PX.J&-IW,·~~~£: (a) ·~~/J'-1±~~ fi&-Ti~~ ~; (h) lf ~ i:.llt/f' 7 !Wtitr~:*:-1±~ rrr~;. ~ ~J! m; (c) lf ~ J(Jlt>~~ l!~:tf"*{±~ ~ ~~,~tt~=~~-~~*~~,MFc~~m*; (d) 13]}-J'EJi'.-Ti~tl:t~, 1-f ~ ~~~ ~ ~:i:.lltA-itJ 7~-m~o~~~7~~,F~7fi~tr~,~ ~.b/f'"Y' ),J$-~~/J'tfJ~ ~, ~at F ~ if·?~ 7. . -T-o~ffl~~~-~I~,~~I-m7tt*~! WJ, ~~~~J!:/J'~~~fi]f{',7'EJi'tlt-Ti~o . I ~~~~~~~~~~~*ft+~~n, ~~ r I 11= ),* fti-ti£, Rm 7 1' iiJ .=:.+Fj ~at iaJ 1 -~~7,~m~i ~~~A~~- ~ )~EQ.¥jlaf:f1± 0 Ytt4*~Jt:: i.f16~, 1979 ~0 ai*J:tJJ~~ot~~ fi~1!~1.J,~j: : "~~~E~JI::t:t&f.B !WJ *-ff~~ I ~~ l¥J),rfT11=l¥l~ii .. o 4. 2 fi~ ~~~~ [ ~ .. "-Tiltt". -=-· ] fi~ ~~l~ tfJ ~ ~~ ~ftilf Ijli ~ ~ ~ - a- 5. fl''fft I fF~IjJft [ ~·- ~. J =~£~§~-~~~. §~~~--~­ ft~~§~~~.~~~~§~~£~M~·~~ §~--~-*off~~~~~§~-~/t'ffflt'f f!:l:~fiX*-~~'ll'~n- 0 5.1 t-f~~ § ~~IJIQIBJG11=ffl .~f+if'ffi'~ § ~£~f!}f-1'-I~ § ~~~~~~~~~mA~~~~~~.-~~• tt~~ '' ~ 12t = ~!Ji § ;t2 ~~ § f;fm~ it~, ~SJ ~ /f~~!Ji § i:iJ"fm~~~if;J(t'ftt~o "N*~*~aJf t~~·~~§·*~~fflA~~o~i:iJ"~£-~ F~~-~~~-~m~~~~-ili~~·~~* /j'~~~:l:f!~l~ o f'!Jjul*-"''I~ § ~T~Ji:l&A(f)~ ~=~i:if~~tt~~~~-~~~a**ft[~• tAT],ilii:if~~tt~aJf~~~-~*~-.~ "~-~~*~*~!Ji§~•AtF~a*~~ft~ ~+BJG~+v.J.. J:.~ f*atlaJ J:.~SJt.f*11=tt.~~x:t~m o 11J-f+~~ttf}<:4i'·-M, ili ~t,t~ ~, f.B /f:*:*·~ o~~*m•~~~-~~~+s~~~~(f)ffiA , t~ a:P'f Jt ), ftl * ~~J tit , 1' ttt: E8 aJf JL), .ro ~ ~ 0 • [ -~·--E']";i~i~~~Jtf:*:~~:l:tf~ft-tlf~~ Xftn~~J&m~~$o Pf112tB ~i~~~Jl&•~m~~ ~tt~.~~tt~i:iJ"ISJJ:.~~$#fflo] - 9 - -iit~-=.: ~~;4Jil~~ ~§)~~~-~ a T~~~~~~~~~il~~~l§)~~~~ ~tmww~= I •• -t±J~m ~ 1F ~miE~ 1F, rJi ~ ttt.fi • 1 ~£~tt7-~~~E~~~:ffi~~~~~~~~ **£~~~A±,~ft~n-t±~~~~~~~-~ ~~~"~-~~-t±tl~~-~~ma.~ft,~: ~tl~~a~~l§J~Wft~~(~,~~~~~*~ 1f~ff. •• -t±E:.es I esDHJ!ft~-1--~XEZt~l& ~~:~fi·~~~~~tl~~~E~~§~~- ~ftm*~*U~At ~~*·~--~~··~ £-t£~7-~~~~~E~~,*~~~~~*~ ~if~ iiJ ' ~ ~ }-) ~ JJ:t ' 't fl'l>?1 IJfi ~ ~1f it;i o •• 1±it*1FX ~ ~ ~~:F:ts),.fl'l~~if- ~ a~~,~~~~•a*~•·~~~~~~m@ ~~ ~ o J&£.~ )-] *m ~*A i~~ilifl. T- ¥~f5/f' t1J ~~~-~*' ~}-J~:r.~£ilttE!~, ·r~~~ ~i~:tl. iltt~-~~*ff~~~t :r.~£~*~~ iiJ ~ ~ f{. {± 'fRif~ till J:.& ~31t T IJfi § ~~ ~ ~ [ ~p ffi ~§"~I~~ .. J t *Off:tL'OE.J!Jt iiJ iR -t~Jtfo 7J ~~~~*· Too~1~PB~·J*7-~~m .. >t~~ ~uftlffl'~~~ljT' j;J..JJ:t~JfiJfi ~ ~~·.tli~ lli if ~~~•a*~*~-~1f'fRI•~o~~~-7~ wISJ t¥ t± ~!2 ~* 1~ ,~ ~ • a 11= ~ x:t cr,;g o 1± rJfi § * ~n~~~m~-~~, ?~•m•a~*~*~ - 10 - - 11 - ~+.~gg : ~it">$~~~~~i3f'11l'" ~-lid - m J;,l ff'ffi'iif / <~: J -Et~ t~! ~ f3 ~ t ~ Jl ~ tl~ ff jtr-J~~ -Et~ it ;f(:IJ ), ffii t§ {.' eg - -t-I'QJ :~m£ = 1! m~~ ~~-~~~~~~~m,~~m~~~~~~~ R~tr-Jff~tt~~~~o~-®~~~~X~-1-­ t ~~~JRJ;-r~ § *i1=7~Ji!~g, ~,$£~1±1977 if. ~§**fi~~*~ft~~~eg~aegt~ff~~ --t-tr.$X;.§. i'ftt.$5(' ~Fa )Z t± 1979 if. I~§ E*fi 71s 1-- Y:L<:Fa~i'f -~~tt.$X .PJT~~~:RoT : o A -f~-t o0o ~ lli [ tr. ~ J 1977 1979 ~(~) ~:tJD~~sg~~ 177.4 248.6 +35.6 tr.$X;.§. 155.2 241.5 +64.2 ;2T-~~, 1!t-n'-n4. 63 c ~ 356 §m.rt J , -?±e. 8885 ;;1<-Sf- _t:;- ~IIT::•·ti, -Dt~~4(;sgffj~£ w~~eg, ~*~~~c~~J~§~W~t~eg *~~0 tr.r;z;g_xtM_ -~i+*-Dt +'B':t ~' ~)g't ~n'to~1fx-~~1tUicJ~~7 ~~' :x:~tr.~ ~~-~tJg~~o~~-1'-~~iliW~~' ~~$-~ ~*~Hx~*$Xm~~£X~~Weg~~~~eg ~~~, j1 £ ~ )-) ~ :tJo 7 M_ 1-- I~ § 51~ sg o I .r_ro § ~~*~ wo~m meg~itf~Ff", : J&>t~ · Bfi8~<1982) : "iffJr I titWW:fi~l< ~~ffl ! i l~Ji?cJo 5. 2 i*-~~to~?F-~~/B'lfr [ ~--~~­ -- /\¥ J xt~*~~~=~~~, §~£n~ttFlli ~~~*' tt.$XJlf~I~ § JJ~o Too~ t~ ~fi'~B­ I~:*:~~*-~'~5-J'ffr' xt~£~00ki~·titt~ l~ ~~~oM.~~~~~~a~~m~~,~•~* §E~~tt-~o~~~*hl~=~~~$[~~ - 12 - ~i~~~~~M,~it\/ ~ n~bmJJi Iii!11:P&H1 ~ 1' g~ fi {! JJi ~~ BtJ if xtJ (EHAP) ~ .f£ ~~~ g ~:atm j:~:ttm:~m Ii ~~ BtJ ~w~ t1 : -a- ~i! L1f~J m~~Bt.l~*P&*~lfttm,fu~mtt~~~moA fl'l~§ rc : m~J ~f~ ~ $ n t~ EE &Jtt 1: tt m: & tt ~ * m ~~§i~~~~~fr~~~~?~r:;~~~~i~~ = C~~~_El ( *~1!J1~BtJ~j:~ J o ki~cpff -I~~)I >1t rCJ ~m 11= r ff- JJ!l EH , 9W. ~~&A tt :tJJ [ :ij5( ~ m Bk.~t±P~/y R~ffi.tt-~t~~J~mfa J ~-J-j:~~~ [ Wt!i J ~~~~o~>lt~mJJ!l§~~~~~~~~~~~ ' #-~JfJHt~iJj}~o C~$X~.§.~Jit~9:ff1~BtJ, f8fu~ >Jz1tnfl'l:ttm:~m~ ~, ttJ;J./J,I:?~IHI 0 ~*~~=*~~~~~~Rff7~~·~ to~§, $t·1~Wlo Rff27~ tf:J~~~~$1.7 m -~*~EttJ; i±~f~~mP~l&>--crRlf1a~-2s~ £.m-TB$< Jtt.1±m ~~J! tf:l 0 - 13 - ~ 1~ /\ 1l Efi.RofciJ~f¥3PX*-~~1ttr*tt:~ ·11r *X ~I \''f!:tl ~ •111'-tt ~ 1J'~t ~~f~ ~~~ ~* !& ~ I $.-~~~~~~~~~ze~,~~~~PX* ~~~D-ft7~·,~~~·~~~-~[~~ I ~~*Jo~~~~~~~R'~*~@~~~­ ~~~i{Q,'f.((NPV) • ~~~~=st1i~J;J.J5X*~~~, am ::t}t!t~JR,;. £r-J ~ ~ £r-J~*-~~ it1' ~ tt: i~~(fj ~&~ili#~M£r-J*~*-~·~ft~~~tr£r-JM m m i~£ =·:XI tt :tt: ::t ~~ JR 9§- £r-J 1~ ~ ~ tt 1!1 J: lilt! ~• ct.:iltt~@t£r-J• ~itx!J*-~~~~~~*i!t ~ o ~ 1~;, : tttx:Jl 'If~~~ m1± • it x'J £r-J AA* -~ b¢ §l. 1£iiF~x ~x:t/\t'fxWJ~t&A-~Jii~• £r-Jit ~m~~*~~§[XiOO~~~a~~~~WJ~ 7 tt*Xo ~*~!!t : Jt!Ji ·ti~Ji tfJJJ$ [ :t!i#st:ijfj, ~~~;~·~~~~~~~·],~~$~~· ~ 1£ 18~ ~1]33~ :;t fa] , ~ 1~@£ £r-J ~ &Jf.fi# &: ~. £r-J ~$[-~f·~~--~~£r-J-~],~~~~ §$ '*'1£9~-13~ :;tfa] o 1ttr:i-£r-J~~~1i-~*tt!t"r ttFo~rt~f.go ~~~~~/J', *iJi!~~**~·ti ~~rl~,~~*~~~ft*~,~~ft~~~A ~Jii$X~~~1±~. \ •"*~:~*~~-*~~-~~ffi~- (Marisa Fernandez-Palacios and Michael BaM- l berger) ~- (1984) "Xi~*X ~:tf:i#W11l'1±M ffl ~t!fl~~1'f~A~*ifffl'" rtt w~ni#;;J< ~~m~ • ,faJi1h:. x ~ i 0 55 -5. - 14 - 7. AAW~~~~®ffm~*[~~c~~~~­ +~~~~~~~fi~~lli~~~~,am7~~ >*.A-~51~ J *~M~~~A~~~-+~~~§~-~ ~~-~·~~~~~ff~~m~~~~~~~~ * ~~*~~~*fi~o~T~-~~7~~~~~ Il:t 1fli1 Elf~ JL +~ ~ FJI' f~ o - 15 - 1.1 li(A;ER~JiliJf~l'aJII ~W-~liJfRVRm·~~~I~A ~~"~.~~~~AM~~~~~~~ft~~~ff ~~~D~~~~olDfR-+~n~m~•~~­ ~~~~OOAT;ffir~~~~~~~~-,~~ ~~,"~~-m~oo~~-~.~ft¥.AMW ~~~X~RffiA~~~~~;Em~.~-~+~ I~ o· fthfl'lff ~~ ~~JtM" : -~' Ii.il~ft~~~~ ~~~~~I~JiliJf~$~~WM~~:i:~~.# ~;EjU]W~X fa] ~I:JiliJf~ ~ o 1. 2 ~ll~~ ~JU !::j ff~ I 11= [ *•. Ii._. ] ~~~~;E.~~~~ff~I~£m~ ~~rrm~srrm~~.XE~~-~~~~J~a~ ~~~-~ojU]~~·*ft,J:t~~~~~I~~­ ff§ ~mtq~~~S+Ek.•~• &~rr tt.~~ff~~;E 0 3uliAT~m~liJ),Ia.btiATa-t~m o 1. 3 JJEH~ml!~>*~-[ ~-~f-f:c -- t.3~J ~£~~I_ill ~ Jl~11t51f- ~~_pX~1j­ 'E:IG~~~E~~~~,~IM~~~~~~EHI~ o~~*~~+~~*ft~~+~~-~~AJI~ ,~~@•m•~·~RIM~~~*'~Jtt.,¥~ ~~~~~;E·~~PX~~~·~~~~·4o~ 00E~i~i1J, 10t~~~£-a ~ >jt~rM ~ PJri£-~11= -~~~·~*,ff£tt=+•~~~JIEH~tt~7 ' ~-~~+~:t!f 0 - 16 - •-:•~~•m$~~ff~I"~~n+*~M ~ 1f XJJ ~ ~~~ ~ i1'11t I 11= 1-•~•~•m~•A~~~~~~~~ ~:1¥ti: • l!+~lil~~it m::l ,.)ltJ 7";. -!o!o! * ~~~~Ijq ~ *fftl.fi * ~ I_Gi ~ ~ ~ 1-'fiSf'ffi' • i1'f"i!i.I5X.*£r-J~~ 2. l!l~~l~~i-1'~ I tF &~o'fAJ~ii~ -~~~~rrm~~c**rrff£~~ ~~J~-f~ -~~~ff~ItF&~m~m~~~+ if5 il ~ 71 :i *:t§ • ~~4;-~ [ %l~m J &~fcJi-Fm a. li ~ 11 UH £t-J mjj) ;ifc ~* .rt • ~:t; ~ jt!J,js(ffi ~ • ~ >It~ tm ii ;ifc ~- fi(i fiJt 4. & tif61~ JJ~ UHcm iciJ .. m ~ .. s. lll~~ffi.ijjffl ~ "Y ~ ~.l . • ~"Y I 11= ),~ • ~-}"~~ ~"r5t;t, 1J,~~oo~ . ~· o ~ t1f~$I ~ E1 MI * .lj~~- ~~~~~w~~~~~~E1~~~- =1-~ I -W--k1)St.$. t:P ~ • ~~~~~li~LJ ~~~~J ~m~w~~*~~,~~~~M~· -~~,r/~bb~~jw • ~~~~;~m~¥~~ ~m • ~Fif(·~· f3 ~r~+~Nottf¥~bk • ~~.It ~~~~mJ~•*m~M~~~~ ·e ~li*~~!ifil * ~~n~+~ot~~¥t:P • W'(r~~~-~w.~ W'(lt *f3 MI • * = ate~!l!~•~~uJ.:a,~-t; ~~a~~ww~~-W-~ot~5~~ ·z ~=~-~~Jt&f3~I~fl "l :~J I -w--s!~~~~~il:a - Ll - - 18 - i!J ~ffi~,~-~~-m*•'~MA~,ff m~~~~~~-~o~~A~~~~~-~~~ ~-~~~~~~rrm~~~Mm~~R~~~~ ~-~~~~~~ti~~~o~~~m~Ig~§ ~;ttt~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~m~ ~EHI1'F~o ~~~w~~~~~~mffmi~~,~~ ~W~*-~ft~~~o~£-~~~~~~,fu ~~~~~A~~~~,~~~M~m~~~~~ ~~~-F-~ff~,~~-~~·~~~~fu~ - 19 - a AT VJ. :*:: :*:: ~ ~~ PX* o 8. ~D 'fiiJ .. t.ll~ ff'ffi' I 11= rm ~ :t~~~~~~~i.~11l'9J ~11m [ ~ .Tilft·-·-A ,. ] 8.1 ~~~ff'ffi'£~~~~o~7~~~~~ ~~wm, ~~~•A~~~~tl~~m~•*~ •~~~m~If1=,#Atl~~~m•~n~~~ ~W~o~~~tt*~I~~£~mm~•wAA ~•G,~£~~~-A~~•m~m~~~•• #§·~~~¥~~~I~~~~~~~~~~M ~o~~~ru~W11l'I11=~WTI~~ft~-G~~ ~~~RA~,~~~~Af~¥*~~-,~~~ ~~m~1E£o [·li·-A 8. 2 lii~$~~~ i.Sf''ffi'~jR~~¥f£ffl:i ;1) ~7~hl~~~W11l'I~~-*~~~~ I11=Wffl~,·~~~~-£~R~~~~~f£m ~~~~~~@·-~~-*o-~W~:*::4.i¥ ~m:~-: Ijii § ifJI)-,Iq : fthfl'l~ffl~1St~t!* (a) ~~ll'lfff~jlt~I~ ~ ~~~Jttft ... t!l, VJ. f*}lEZ~IJ ~~,~~~~~m~~~"~~;~~~&~~ r+Fc~~~WTI~~~~~~mr~~o i§<;ffj~Ji~j(;IJ):Jq : fthll'l5f!Jffl1!S~ ~*~*~~~~ ~ oo~l~'fiii•~,#~~ - 20 - fth AT ~~-rf.Jt~~ ~~11=~*;c~ ~ 7jiiJ ~ ~t:,~' v J... ili:ii it fJT rfJ IJl ~ • tE}ts!iM&~ i~~~ -~~*~~-~~~- : fthfl'l£~Jmffl ~Fc~~~l~~ ~~m~~·~~-*~*~~~~~~~~~. (d) l!l'*m®m19: w~IJi~•1J'j&£ea m~m~~~~~~~~.~~tt~~~-mlim ~~~~~~~~~ff~~~~-~-"~~n~ •~•~-~~~~--1J',#m~~~W*~~ ~)!Jl. ~VJ..l:.~~mFP~, IJi ~~~~~~ iSf'ffl'~lt ~~~~~~4aRA~~¥*1n*fu£Wm~ ~. a. a ~~~~~ ist'~~F tH~lt~fi~m ~~,w~~~-~~~"~~-~·~ 7,#~tA\1±~ ifcp ~~~ l'iiJJl, ~Jl,~~~F'*' I~ oTiil~¥fl4~~i'Wm~~a~~~~~ftF ~~aRt~iS-: ca> iSF~iiJia~~-~ifTIJi ~ RJ~1rlW m~.~~~tt!Ji~~~A~~•c•~~~~ ~R,RJ~~ttlli-~tl~~*~~~!Ji~*~~ -~2~~,ff~4lli.~tl~RJ~~ftlli·rf.J~ 1m [ ~- -=Ji :lift.-=-·-·.::.' .=. ~ liii ] 0 ii :fQihls!!l!f:Dt~iHH ~CXJ-W-i! '~l~~~ • ·e o~~~ll1•m~ +!~ (3llfi CXJ*~k~"lf 'lt~CXJ (3llff[:B~ '# (3 lJ1~ ~T~~#~~E3~-W-~~·····W~E3~~ ~~a~- 'm'4!~~-.m•r~~~~ (&) [ ~ ':~-•na••~ J o .!J~~~~-~WJJ~if , ~tk! ~ • ~a llfi .:U-~ saw~~ ~a llfi ~ ( 1 > • 3!: f~CXJi~ W~M- £i~ ~ ~ ~ ~~ M~~~~~~~~~fmw~~~~.w-~JJ~~ ~,~.~~~13~~~-~~~'a:t•~•* ~·~-~~.:W-T~~~~~~~~~~·~~¥ ·~-m~,~~~~E3~~-~-#~o~!l!~ ~ (a> W.!U-13 ldi ~ a '*- LJ a! ¥1 ~~ .fJflg ¥ [ fr£~1_~~~;\·~· ~-] o~~~~~~ew~•a·~~~j~~ ii•=~~'*•¥w~~v~~k'~JJ~~~ ~~~y~~~~~~~·~·~~~~~~~· ~ qg il$1(( wa • i~ w~~ ~ 11 ~ 1t (' > a• [~~~­ ·=··~-~ J ·~t~J~~it+!I!'J,Lr,ii(U,li#J.¥~ ~'~~~.:U-I~W·~~'~m~-JJ~W~~ ~-~~~~~~~g±~~~·g~~~~=k m~*·~~~~w~~~~JJ~~a~~~~·~­ • =UEfj,f, LJ ~*± 03* .fu. ~ (> ' E3 In r:W o 0 [ 9~fjd-~] ~81¥J';tJJ - TZ - - 22 - N*-+~~\ff~~~£+~~~tt~, ~~tt~~~m~~m~~~~-~~·~~~~ ~~~~~.~A~~m~r~~*~,•~•e ~-m~.~~mRAM~¥~AM~~~~~~ ~~~.~~~~m~•~~~~.&w~~•ff ~~.~~-~m~-~~~~~~.*~~*~ ~mi ~l.l~~~~1-trf.J:t*r~JA. •ff"-~~~~~ff~m~¥~Aa•~ ~w~~.~•~w~~~rf.J•~·*~~&*~ rf.Jrr~o•~n&~~~•~.~~~~&~•~ tt I~ ),91 £fJ ;l >\!. o 9• .;=- ;)ft-fii 11- ·-·=~~~~\W~I~rf.J-~ *•~•-+~~,mft~~=~\ff~ I~rf.J~~\~~~~~~~o~~~ff~£¥~ .;=-M,~ft~~~¥&~~·~~mi~rfJN*' -~~~~-ft,~··~.~-I~~~&~~ ~~~~[~~~~~~rf.J~ffl~FWJ,~~~ ~~~[*ff~~~~~rf.J··~-~], ~~­ ~ff~[~*~~~&~~~~rf.Jtl·\~~~~ F~7~*~•Lrf.JW~l~~*-·~~~[~ ·-~**Sf'~F~rfJF W, *~t:.*XAf'tl~ ~ ~ l ~ o ~-T¥JI~Pa:J~1fi·J~ ... tl~m~~~fFW ~-~-*~~~-ftW~;.E&~~~~*~ ~ft~~\ff~I~~~·4*~~~~D'*~ W'iiffm~~I'~IA~~~o - 23 - •.::.•=1~~~ *•~~7-••~~~~*~~m.~ -~~~~~~~-~~*·~~~.~-~~~­ ~m*~~·~~~~~m-~.~~B·~~w ·~ft~~~-~~~-.~~~+*•~7~~ : -"tt~6*' RfVJ.fittt, ~~jLIJ..fl-f'fffiJlJt ~ ; -"tt~~ •, ~VJ.. ~~3~i1f~;kJAiUI, )I .fir *~' l*lt¥~. ~rJi 1§1. •~•:~~ttm-~a~~m~•~~tt B'J~ttfi *•w~~~~l§l~~tt~~-•~•• ··~~~·~~~~-;&~~~*·~~~~*] ~~ : 1'ral~$S+f~tt~!:i~'t~*J&t.fii{I11 ~~~~-[~~~-~~An~~~~~~~* ~rJil§l~~~ttfil.~ftttfi~~Rf~4;kJ7~ ~~1§1~-~-~~~-~~.~~~·~~wm 7~-~~m~~~~tt·*•~~7-~~~~ •~-~~~~~·*•~~m•~~"~~~T ~*•T~-I~.~•~a~~oo~~•*·* •ft~7~"~mN*:~~+~mttm~~-~ •;~~~m;R~•-~M~nm~.T•ff~ ~7~~~~~1§1aftttm~•~-~~m~~ . • g,*~~ftttfi~~&~~~~~~~-·* • tE.~ lti:JI: ~ 7 ;IJ\!.~. ~ 0 !JeB·=~rJii§IW~tFfffft *·~~~~1Jil§lt¢~~~7A~~~~ N*~~,*~ft~ff~Itf~ffi~~~-~~· - 24 - - ~'l - - 26 - ~#f. 1Sft1f:.r. A*ff'fft I 11=-~~. 1'1'1 1f •· .:r • ~ ¥fi" mii.l )CJ~~. ~~T-It~~l'l"tW~&~~.-~A·~- W~~~-~Am~~·~~~~~. DISTRIBUTORS OF WORLD BANK PUBLICATIONS ARGE~TI:OO\ (.'.,k"' lloNh. SRL .liANC'F. Yr'orkJ llilnl l'uhiK'iiiMift\ ......"·' r\IJhol II••~ Si.'r"lolu' tl. :\ II.IJ f ••r 'uh... r•J'l•"" ,.,,.._ r' lnat·m.uu•n •• l \ur•"'r•re•••n ~nht' G.altna -~.IOU Uonn I !'M.·oiUI ( .. ~ldln l7 ~ zona I Ku.d.a l.umpur h•r \ln~lc lllle,. MF.MRB lnf''"""""" Sc,..ocn Oua~emalal'lly PO. Box ~7!>0 ~n:XI('O .-\MCl .. nih'' Kunt•l lfm,.,Lh.. n.Jel t.Wwna Too.-a J 17 HON(; KONG, MACAU INI'OlloC' k.-.-,·run:'t-'..lloln I.!, (t,,, lb '"h Asoa 2000 Led. Ap.ulado Po"cal :!2 ·hH.) S Itt.\ :.1 ~lut.Lhulm ... GLADE.SH BA. ~ H., 146 Pnnc< Edwoud Rood, W. (.'c•l J•f.: A Pobrc Mocm lnclusrnes Dow:lcopmoa1 A n i - Society Ko,..Joon l.atlhO rloalpan. Mea.1cu D.F. h•r ~U~:\t:UJ'I(It.lft flft.kn. CMIDASI llonJK""' \\cnftl:'rJ!n:-n·Wdl•om•s AR G. P.O. Bo• 1100 IIIOR(K'C'O H•llltU,).I DbaU HliNGARY S..lCaelt d'FJYdts M.ar1.rhnc Mautco~inc S ltl4 !~ Sh-.:Ukllm Kultun 2 Kuc: Muhrre. IW. d'Ani; BELGIUM PO. Hn• 1.1'1 ('a...,blalk:a SWITlt'RI.ASII Publowions dn N - . Unin IJK9 lludapo:>t 62 l.1~r.unr Poayul Av .... Roi :!0~ THE NETHERLANDS h kut GrtnU\ l()(o()BrusKIS INDIA Medocallloob Europo:. BV cMBEI Cob< J'U'W JKI hw .. mt:ltlllfc, Noon!<,.. ...IK Cll I~ II Citncoo II BRAZIL I'BS Puhhohm lloulo. SP lhll\ l.•hr.ill"\' .illkllni,ll'm..ltK•n S.:l'\11.'(' P. o If,,, ~!'1'1 lfl hr~ol M,11n N.OOMI Pn~ak lto11!. ().U'tS S.. iJ.am ('.\'•t\D.\ Go~rhlht 1'-o~~ar N('" ~brLtl Lt D111u...:ur Au..:LI.iinrJ TII.\11."-SII <: fl M~. I~UI .-\mrcre St~«l ltoanrahn ;h(U.JII Ct"'nlral l~ranm~o·nl Shti"C' Roud~tn die. ()ucb:..: NI(;F.RI.-\ \t.Jf'l ~lllt•m M.uok.l J•H ~l'b Ar«J•) Chamh<". P 0 llox 7.11> Unr\C'"'n" I'Jt,, l.1mllct.l lt.;an!!LuL ~ \\'.:.allacc Stn-ct llu.:c ('r;,..,n, Hu1lt.lan~ Jcnd•n CHILE lton1N~ 4tlUH TRI,IIl-\11 6 TUIIAC;n, ASTICOI 1.\. h"IUI4.' MJII liJ~ ~ N~ F.dnoni61 RC'R.ll:lm~nto H· 1-R. Chtlwnnl!h« Unc 6.-\ltBIII.\, 11\ltii-\IMIS. 1111\IISII'"-· lttat.l•n Maratlon:'lo .\.~-' Cakuna 711ll1Jib c;Jt•:'·\11.\. C;(I\".-\S.\, \ICISTSUUHT. ~1. Sanua,o SCIJt\\,\\' Klrrs \'lill !lit:\'IS, !\T. U IH, Sl. 7'1KK. II At. s,.arup Na~ar lo~num K;arl J•th.tn. A S \ l'nsr & c;Jt•:s.,uls•~'i COL0\181.\ KanJ"lr :!t»Utl P 0 Jt,,, 1177 St.·ntnuu s, 'h.'UIJII~o., Sludtt:' l ~1111 F..ni~C' l.IJ.a o,J., I ..,~ l...~~ll'm !\.tJm ICu.ed CmrrJ b ~l., 51-11 ~I\ a)!iln~:.. Ru.MI ('ur,·r-:· lkl~UI..I 0 f. P-\KIST-\S Nun~"mh.tl..l..o~m lnn,J..J. WL""' lnll•~o.·, AJ'IIUolo>A-1-l.ICI M1r1.il HuuL Arcn.:~ 'tndril Na,ar l.alk>« .I S :\\cnuc t.lc l'.u1ha~~ Llhi'I:OJ T I'I:.Jl" l1;etn.a KUUU I h Tum~ C.lll< II· 1.' ...:ltl' A•. Ftm.uo.l<1 Gucll hw '-Ub-.cnpc.un nnlcr!r! 1-.dunnOtl Uc....rrullo SA Tl'ltKH San lost Universal Sutb&.·npt•un A,:r~y Pvl. Lid Aran..Ju .1K.:!.a U.a\CI Kll•r-:"\1 A S. 18-19 Communtly Centre SU.et l"mo 46'1. h......... ( 'ilddc~J COTE D'I\"OIRF. Nh